The "anonymous scouts" (and some not so anonymous) on our draft picks

AdamJT13

Salary Cap Analyst
Messages
16,583
Reaction score
4,529
DAVID BUEHLER Southern California 6-1 1/2 227 4-6

"He's a tremendous kickoff guy," said Eric DeCosta, Baltimore's director of player personnel. "He's raw on his techniques as a field-goal kicker." Booted 48 touchbacks in 88 attempts in 2008, an impressive 54.6%. Two-year FG kicker made 26 of 33 (78.8%). "Thing with him is, he just tries to kill the ball all the time," an NFC special-teams coach said. "He just needs to control his approach a little bit." Athletic (4.61 seconds in the 40-yard dash) and strong enough (bench-pressed 225 pounds 25 times) to have played RB and LB in junior college before transferring to USC in '06. "He looks like a safety," one scout said. His uncle, George, was an outstanding guard for Oakland from 1969-'78. "Mentally, he's very strong," an AFC special-teams coach said. "He's not like a typical kicker. Very aggressive. Very focused. Built like the (Nick) Folk kid at Dallas. Really a solid character kid."




MICHAEL HAMLIN Clemson 6-2 211 4.60 5

Co-captain and team leader. Started 43 of 48 games, finishing with 14 interceptions and 22 passes defended. "Another big stiff guy," one scout said. "Not a space player. For a big guy, not very strong (bench-pressed 225 pounds 17 times)." Got run over several times in Alabama game. "He looks great," another scout said. "But he's straight-line and stiff." Directs traffic well and is a good communicator. "He can't run," a third scout said. "And he isn't always physical."





"In a Journal Sentinel poll ... 19 scouts with national orientation were asked to rank the best cornerbacks and the best safeties on a 1-to-4 basis. A first-place vote was worth four points, a second three and so on.

At cornerback, Jenkins (11 first) led the way with 66 points, ahead of Vontae Davis (six firsts) and 47 points; Darius Butler (two firsts), 38; Alphonso Smith, 31; Kevin Barnes, Mike Mickens and Sean Smith, each two; and Byrd and D.J. Moore, one apiece.

At safety, Louis Delmas (14 firsts) easily won with 62 points, ahead of Patrick Chung, 39; William Moore (three firsts), 36; Rashad Johnson (one first), 22; Chip Vaughn, eight; Sherrod Martin, six; Byrd (one first), five; and Michael Hamlin, three."
 

28 Joker

28 Joker
Messages
7,878
Reaction score
1
If Hamlin runs well, he goes in at least round 3. When you don't run a good 40 time, some scouts may only see the flaws in you. They may forget the tape. This guy is better than Watkins and Brown, so that is a win for Dallas, a 5th round pick win.

Hamlin is a ballhawk.
 

AdamJT13

Salary Cap Analyst
Messages
16,583
Reaction score
4,529
41gy#;2751896 said:
If Hamlin runs well, he goes in at least round 3. When you don't run a good 40 time, some scouts may only see the flaws in you. They may forget the tape. This guy is better than Watkins and Brown, so that is a win for Dallas, a 5th round pick win.

Hamlin is a ballhawk.

The comments on Hamlin were all negative, but the same sources ranked him as a fifth-round pick and the eighth-best safety in the draft.

We got Hamlin with the 166th pick overall. Pro Football Weekly ranked him 69th overall, The Huddle Report had him 86th, Draft Countdown had him 105th, and NFL Draft Scout had him 109th. Even ESPN's Scouts Inc. had him 137th.
 

28 Joker

28 Joker
Messages
7,878
Reaction score
1
AdamJT13;2751914 said:
The comments on Hamlin were all negative, but the same sources ranked him as a fifth-round pick and the eighth-best safety in the draft.

We got Hamlin with the 166th pick overall. Pro Football Weekly ranked him 69th overall, The Huddle Report had him 86th, Draft Countdown had him 105th, and NFL Draft Scout had him 109th. Even ESPN's Scouts Inc. had him 137th.

I didn't know all those rankings. Thanks.

He looks like a bargain to me. Plus, look at all the good cover people Dallas snagged.

The days of Jacques Reeves and Nate Jones and Watkins and Brown are over.
 

DallasFanSince86

Pessimism Sucks
Messages
2,064
Reaction score
19
41gy#;2751916 said:
I didn't know all those rankings. Thanks.

He looks like a bargain to me. Plus, look at all the good cover people Dallas snagged.

The days of Jacques Reeves and Nate Jones and Watkins and Brown are over.

:crossed:
 

SaltwaterServr

Blank Paper Offends Me
Messages
8,124
Reaction score
1
DallasFanSince86;2751920 said:
:crossed:

x2. A few of the happiest, non-game day memories for me were when Reeves was signed by Houston and Nate was gone as well.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
41gy#;2751896 said:
If Hamlin runs well, he goes in at least round 3. When you don't run a good 40 time, some scouts may only see the flaws in you. They may forget the tape. This guy is better than Watkins and Brown, so that is a win for Dallas, a 5th round pick win.

Hamlin is a ballhawk.

Then you haven't seen him play enough. He may make the club (I have some doubts) but that's because we suck at safety. I hope I'm wrong.
 
Top