JD_KaPow
jimnabby
- Messages
- 11,069
- Reaction score
- 10,833
Both matter.People say this all the time, and it just isn’t true. Point differential in the regular season is the single strongest predictor of postseason success there is, even more so than regular season wins or what seed you are in your conference.
For perspective, the team with the #1 or #2 best point differential has participated in 49 of 57 Super Bowls and won 32 of them. No team with the #1 point differential has ever been eliminated prior to the divisional round of the playoffs, and only two teams with a top-3 point differential have ever missed the playoffs.
Style points ABSOLUTELY matter because they are the strongest indicator of overall team quality.
Yes, point differential is a better predictor of future performance than W-L record. But in such a short season, the performance in close games can make a huge difference in playoff seeding or making the playoffs at all. Banking wins also buys you margin of error to get through a rough patch (because of injuries or whatever).
If every game you play is close, you're not that good regardless of your final record.
Conversely, if you destroy a bunch of teams but purely by luck go 2-4 instead of 4-2 in your close games, you may find yourself without a bye week and having to play on the road in the playoffs.