Twitter: Tierlist for skill position talent of every team

[Aerolithe_Lion]

Dallas G has played over 70% of the offensive snaps 3 seasons running for Philly.
His production has been really meh for all those snaps.
That is likely not all his fault as the Eagles have struggled at QB/WR and not helped him much.

Ertz only had 168 yards in his 6 Eagles games last year so tough to charge he was to blame. His numbers really surged in Zona.

Dallas is a better big play guy than Dalton but Dalton gets open A LOT more and is producing more per snap.
Think teams would take Dallas over Dalton by a pretty sure margin but at same time that production really needs to tick up for him to get the pay day he wants.

Interestingly enough both guy are in pay day years.

We got to Goedert early, he’s signed through 2025 on a pretty good deal.

Ertz had the 30 targets that differentiated Dallas and Dalton. If those go to Goedert, he breaks 1k yards. How do you mean Dalton produced more per snap if Goedert had more yards on way fewer catches?

 

[superonyx]

I'd trade Schulz for Goedert straight up without thinking twice right now.

Me too.

But what if it was our WR's, RB's, TE's for theirs straight up?

 

[Praxit]

..who creates these things or ideas? Its like saying Vanilla Oreo's are better then chocolate, ...and so forth.

 

[Sydla]

Me too.

But what if it was our WR's, RB's, TE's for theirs straight up?

It’s a lot closer than you want to admit. I think this guy ranking Philly in the elite class is silly but the Cowboys no longer have the clear best group of skill players in the division.

 

[ESisback]

Just no my dude. Just no.

Barkley has been in the league 4 NFL seasons. He had a very solid rookie campaign.
1307 yards on 5 YPC.
Year 2 he dipped to 1003 yards on 4.6 yards per carry.
Year 3 was a total wash with injury.
Year 4 was 593 yards on 3.7 yards per carry.

Zeke in what we called an awful year had 1000 yards, 10 TDs and 4.2 YPC .
Barkley's accounted for 8 TDs in 4 years. Barry averaged 10 TDs a season. Zeke had 10 last year.


Saquon was a monster at Penn State and he did display some of that explosion as a rookie but it has been MIA since.
And he has NEVER touched Barry Sanders ability to make people miss or shift gears or have that body control and balance. He was a big, strong, fast straight-line guy.
Muich more Bo Jackson than Barry Sanders he needs to add some power now that he has lost some speed.
And he badly needs to display some between the tackles vision.

I think injuries, playing on a crap team, and simple bad luck have contributed to a lesser impact. As to a lack of power, I don’t know. He’s plenty strong. I’ve seen him do some impressive stuff.

 

[DFWJC]

Wow Eagles?

Dallas Goedert was beaten by Schutlz in every category last year.
Aj Brown, D Smith and Jalen Reagor are not better than our WR's and Miles Sanders isn't even as good as Pollard.

This is what happens when the media overhypes AJ Browns 61 catches and 998 yard per year average.

The reality is most members of the media barely watch the titans games and just listen to the player demanding a big contract and assume he is great because he said so.


Now if it was about OL, the eagles have us beat.

I want to say Dallas is better, but they are not.

• The Eagles WR trio IS better. Maybe not if we still had Cooper.
• Goedert IS better than Shultz. Just needs the reps
• I'd give our RB duo the nod though

all jmo though

 

[john van brocklin]

Eagles, 49ers and Seahawks are way too high

Agreed, how are the egirls that high up?