top 64 QB's

[Dingo05]

http://proxy.espn.go.com/nfl/insider/news/story?id=3147842

 

[theogt]

Plenty of laughs in this one. Favre ahead of Romo. McNabb ahead of Garcia. Eli Manning and Jason Campbell ahead of anyone.

 

[CATCH17]

Ill take Palmer all day every day over Big Ben.

And as good as Favre is Romo is the better QB currently and it has nothing to do with the "guys around him" like most people want to say.

Romo is just on another level right now. Hes playing better ball than Payton Manning right NOW.

 

[AdamJT13]

I take it they're not big fans of David Carr.

 

[Skin]

I take it they're not big fans of David Carr.

Speaking of Carr, where are all those people who said he was going to be great (or at least, good) when he left Houston? I remember some people on this board talking about how good a QB he was and ripping those who said he belonged on the scrap heap. I watched him when he played for the Texans and listened to him. I thought, at the time, and still believe that football is not that important to him.

Nice #1 overall pick.

 

[TheHerd]

I just don't get how many people think Favre is having a better year than Romo. Romo is better in wins, TDs, yds/att, rating. Only ints favors Favre. And don't give me that weapons story - Favre's receviers lead the league in YAC. Romo is #2, just ahead of Manning, if it's supposed to be just this year.

 

[Temo]

Actually this list makes perfect sense when you actually READ. They're combining past career accomplishments with current performance. Hence, Favre ahead of Romo. Hence, Palmer behind Roethlisberger (Roethlisberger has a super bowl ring).

I mean, you ask me this season, who would I take... I'd say Romo ahead of Favre and Palmer ahead of Roethlisberger... but that wasn't the question.

 

[Temo]

Vince Young at 15 is just idiotic though. He's one of the worst 5-10 QBs in the league.

 

[adamknite]

I didn't realize Patrick Ramsey was still in the league.

 

[sago1]

Favre is ahead of Romo only because of his HOF credentials and SB ring. You and I as Cowboy fans easily see Romo as having the best year and won't forget that it was the experienced Favre who failed to perform while the relatively inexperienced Romo stayed on course.

Bet Commander and Giants fans will be upset when they see how high Romo is ranked in comparison with their prized QBs - Eli & Campbell. BTW: I do think Eli is better then Campbell right now but for how long is another question.

 

[dmq]

Pretty sad but accurate for Eli being just above Campbell.

 

[gollum]

No love for Josh McCown either.

 

[TwoSteppinJJ]

"He is a big reason the Cowboys have the best record in the NFC." Correction... He is the reason.
​

​

 

[HogsRLegends]

Ill take Palmer all day every day over Big Ben.

And as good as Favre is Romo is the better QB currently and it has nothing to do with the "guys around him" like most people want to say.

Romo is just on another level right now. Hes playing better ball than Payton Manning right NOW.

Nobody is better then Peyton Manning. Nobody. Ever.

 

[THUMPER]

How is Brady Quinn even on that list? He has yet to throw a pass in a regular season game yet he is better than 27 other NFL QBs?

I guess he is at zero and the ones below him are in the negative.

 

[Temo]

How is Brady Quinn even on that list? He has yet to throw a pass in a regular season game yet he is better than 27 other NFL QBs?

I guess he is at zero and the ones below him are in the negative.

That's actually pretty accurate.

 

[burmafrd]

When you have not done anything in the NFL you will be above those that are stinking it up.

 

[cstanton1987]

Vince Young at 15 is just idiotic though. He's one of the worst 5-10 QBs in the league.

Hoge?

 

[DWhite Fan]

Ill take Palmer all day every day over Big Ben.

And as good as Favre is Romo is the better QB currently and it has nothing to do with the "guys around him" like most people want to say.

Romo is just on another level right now. Hes playing better ball than Payton Manning right NOW.

Carson Palmer is the most over-rated quarterback to ever play in the NFL. More even that Jeff George. Figures Palmer would play for the most over-rated team in the league. Just like the Bengals, Palmer has never done anything to warrant all the hype he gets. Carson would not make a scab off the elbow of Big Ben.

As to the list, Romo and Manning should be #1 and #2 respectively. I would put Farve and Ben at #3 and #4. I have no use for Brady because he runs his mouth too much.

 

[smarta5150]

Ill take Palmer all day every day over Big Ben.

And as good as Favre is Romo is the better QB currently and it has nothing to do with the "guys around him" like most people want to say.

Romo is just on another level right now. Hes playing better ball than Payton Manning right NOW.

Carson Palmer is the most over-rated quarterback to ever play in the NFL. More even that Jeff George. Figures Palmer would play for the most over-rated team in the league. Just like the Bengals, Palmer has never done anything to warrant all the hype he gets. Carson would not make a scab off the elbow of Big Ben.

As to the list, Romo and Manning should be #1 and #2 respectively. I would put Farve and Ben at #3 and #4. I have no use for Brady because he runs his mouth too much.

the Palmer is overrated part.

I would take Big Ben after Brady, Manning and Romo.