Top players at Each position this year.

Macnalty

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,639
Reaction score
2,162
What they are measuring is not valid to dialogue like the article presents. This is just some glorified database with lots of fine tuning still needed(I am being kind), very analogous with a mock draft in Sept. IMO
 

Sinister

Well-Known Member
Messages
395
Reaction score
496
What they are measuring is not valid to dialogue like the article presents. This is just some glorified database with lots of fine tuning still needed(I am being kind), very analogous with a mock draft in Sept. IMO

I dislike PFF, I don't like their numbers and I don't think that their analysis is very well done. Ask yourselves this, why are they not applying this type of widespread analysis to the college game where if this analysis was as good as they claim it is then they should have no trouble picking out and finding legitimate prospects (noticed they have started by doing one game a week I believe).

Having said that there are not many or any objective analysis of players in the NFL so while I think their analysis is flawed it is interesting to see how the league compares on their 'objective' scale, but anything written by PFF should be taken with a huge grain of salt.
 
Last edited:

Macnalty

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,639
Reaction score
2,162
I dislike PFF, I don't like their numbers and I don't think that their analysis is very well done. Ask yourselves this, why are they not applying this type of widespread analysis to the college game where if this analysis was as good as they claim it is then they should have no trouble picking out and finding legitimate prospects (noticed they have started by doing one game a week I believe).

Having said that there are not many or any objective analysis of players in the NFL so while I think their analysis is flawed it is interesting to see how the league compares on their 'objective' scale, but anything written by PFF should be taken with a huge grain of salt.

I do find it entertaining much like the National Enquirer.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,708
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
What they are measuring is not valid to dialogue like the article presents. This is just some glorified database with lots of fine tuning still needed(I am being kind), very analogous with a mock draft in Sept. IMO

I dislike PFF, I don't like their numbers and I don't think that their analysis is very well done. Ask yourselves this, why are they not applying this type of widespread analysis to the college game where if this analysis was as good as they claim it is then they should have no trouble picking out and finding legitimate prospects (noticed they have started by doing one game a week I believe).

Having said that there are not many or any objective analysis of players in the NFL so while I think their analysis is flawed it is interesting to see how the league compares on their 'objective' scale, but anything written by PFF should be taken with a huge grain of salt.


It's too bad that PFF is garbage. It's a great concept to have all players graded and ranked. Unfortunately, their method of doing it just isn't accurate.
 
Top