Trade Analysis Based on Draft Value Chart

[theogt]

Yes, I know it's antiquated, but people still generally use it or something close to it. So..........


Dallas Gave Up:

2007
1st (22)........780.0 pts
3rd (87)........155.0 pts
5th (159)........27.8 pts

Total Given Up: 962.8 pts

Dallas Received:

2007
1st (26th)......700.0 pts
2008
Browns 1st......550.0 pts

Total Received: 1250.0

Net Gain: 287.2 pts

Value: 30th pick in the 2nd Round (62 overall)

That's a 2nd round pick out of thin air.

Way to go Jerry.

 

[Dday22t]

Browns 1st......550.0 pts <------ & that's worse case scenario, I think for practical purposes we did even better

 

[burmafrd]

AND next year we have 2 #1's

 

[Doomsday101]

Browns 1st......550.0 pts <------ & that's worse case scenario, I think for practical purposes we did even better

Not to mention Cleveland is a bad team. Thomas and Quinn are not going to turn them into winners overnight.

 

[theogt]

Browns 1st......550.0 pts <------ & that's worse case scenario, I think for practical purposes we did even better

Well, when you do the value you take the position they're in this year and lower it a round. So that's what the 3rd pick in the 2nd round is worth.

In my opinion that's too much of a discount, so we really got more out of the trade.

Either way, it's an amazing set of deals.

 

[CrazyCowboy]

AND next year we have 2 #1's

That is what I like....

 

[MC KAos]

i would have been happier if we wouldnt have traded with the eagles, the first trade was great, i dont know about the second, but at the same tocken i have never heard of spencer

 

[Doomsday]

If Spencer helps provide some much needed pass rush help then the points would mean diddly. Obviously he was one of the main guys they were targeting and they had to get in front of NE to get him.

That said any trade that involves the Feagles leaves a bad taste in your mouth.

 

[theogt]

i would have been happier if we wouldnt have traded with the eagles, the first trade was great, i dont know about the second, but at the same tocken i have never heard of spencer

He was the most productive defensive end in college football.

It's a shame that people have never heard of him.

 

[DragonCowboy]

I think you can also go ahead and set those 1st round picks equal, since Jerry said he was picking Spencer either way.

 

[dogunwo]

I think you can also go ahead and set those 1st round picks equal, since Jerry said he was picking Spencer either way.

Good point on them being equal.

 

[MC KAos]

He was the most productive defensive end in college football.

It's a shame that people have never heard of him.

really? well hopefully he will pan out then, wouldnt it be great if he had like a multiple sack game against the eagirls?

 

[theogt]

I think you can also go ahead and set those 1st round picks equal, since Jerry said he was picking Spencer either way.

Great point. That'd bump it up to about the 22nd pick in the 2nd round.

For free.

 

[big dog cowboy]

He was the most productive defensive end in college football.

It's a shame that people have never heard of him.

Thanks for the chart theogt. That is what I call perspective.

 

[Hostile]

Yes, I know it's antiquated, but people still generally use it or something close to it. So..........


Dallas Gave Up:

2007
1st (22)........780.0 pts
3rd (87)........155.0 pts
5th (159)........27.8 pts

Total Given Up: 962.8 pts

Dallas Received:

2007
1st (26th)......700.0 pts
2008
Browns 1st......550.0 pts

Total Received: 1250.0

Net Gain: 287.2 pts

Value: 30th pick in the 2nd Round (62 overall)

That's a 2nd round pick out of thin air.

Way to go Jerry.

Great post.

 

[mmillman]

are you kidding me? Cleveland stinks that will be a top 5 pick and worth a lot more than that. It was a great deal!!!!! I wish they would do that every year.

 

[theogt]

really? well hopefully he will pan out then, wouldnt it be great if he had like a multiple sack game against the eagirls?

Also, one of the Joneses said that they talked to several OTs, including Joe Thomas, and they all said that Spencer was the best DE they played against.

 

[MossBurner]

AND next year we have 2 #1's

And 0 in 2007

 

[theogt]

And 0 in 2007

Huh? We picked Spencer in the 1st.

 

[Bizwah]

And 0 in 2007

Know the facts before you flame.

We had the 26th pick this year.

Now, we don't have a third....or a fifth....

got us there.