Troy Smith

[Rampage]

I liked him before the draft

have not seen him play

have you ? anybody

I live in NY so yes I saw him play. he looks comfortable and not scared like McGee does.

 

[UnoDallas]

I live in NY so yes I saw him play. he looks comfortable and not scared like McGee does.

I would be scared to put McGee in a game

I really like Bomar cause he started at OK then got in minor problems ended up at Sam Houston - put up some big numbers there

I remember that me an some guy were having daily arguements about Bomar

 

[RCowboyFan]

Dumb question he wasn't cut from the falcons.

I asked about a trade....Not pick up...We got some gems out in force today.

 

[erich1r]

how about we trade for drew brees. how about payton manning. how about chris johnson. yeah we do have a gem on here tonight. still a dumb question.

 

[casmith07]

Troy Smith was supposed to be the starter in Baltimore until he got sick.

I think him vs. Joe Flacco is a wash. Either one of those guys could've driven the bus.

 

[BourbonBalz]

he looked better than McGee did and I think McGee is a waste of a roster spot.

Did you actually watch the last preseason game? McGee looked pretty damn good to me, especially for a third string developing QB that has very limited experience.

 

[RCowboyFan]

how about we trade for drew brees. how about payton manning. how about chris johnson. yeah we do have a gem on here tonight. still a dumb question.

Yep, it is, that was my point, genious. :laugh2:

 

[erich1r]

if u were smart enough to read my question you would see i wasnt saying let's cut mcgee and pick up smith. so before you respond with smart remarks to someone's post why dont you read and understand it first.

 

[RCowboyFan]

if u were smart enough to read my question you would see i wasnt saying let's cut mcgee and pick up smith. so before you respond with smart remarks to someone's post why dont you read and understand it first.

Since you are entertaining me, who do you propose you cut for 4th QB who will never see a snap in regular season? Btw, there is a quote button, use it, so people know you are responding to someone. And if you cut whoever you propose, what do you suppose you do when injury bugs hits that position, when you guy heavy with a position that has no use on 45 man roster? Especially for a guy who hasn't shown to be anything special at all.

Really you should quit while you are ahead. More you post more it doesn't make sense.

 

[erich1r]

i told u i didnt say to cut anyone or pick anyone up READ the question i was asking if he was an upgrade over mcgee "what do you all think" it's like taking a poll. I'm fine with mcgee. you seem like an educated individual try reading the question first let it sink in and you will see i was not saying cut mcgee or pick smith up. Stop trying to be a smarta** and read.

 

[RCowboyFan]

i told u i didnt say to cut anyone or pick anyone up READ the question i was asking if he was an upgrade over mcgee "what do you all think" it's like taking a poll. I'm fine with mcgee. you seem like an educated individual try reading the question first let it sink in and you will see i was not saying cut mcgee or pick smith up. Stop trying to be a smarta** and read.

Oh I see, you just like to throw crap against the wall and see what sticks. Got it. I didn't finish my high school eduacation, so I am not eduacated enough to understand the depth of your question. :

 

[erich1r]

would it sink in if i said any other qb rb cb lb etc. it's obvious there's people on here that like mcgee and some dont. i've read their post. some people have responded positively and negatively about mcgee in this post . they understood the question. simple yes or no if smith was an upgrade over mcgee "what do you all think" unlike yourself they understood. you probably have a college degree I'm not gonna call u stupid, just shows u have book sense and in this simple question no common sense. you see i'm not saying cut mcgee or pick up smith in my question and yet u still got something smart to say. Please explain what crap i'm throwing up against the wall cause you out of 3 pages of post is the only person that don't understand the simple question

 

[RCowboyFan]

would it sink in if i said any other qb rb cb lb etc. it's obvious there's people on here that like mcgee and some dont. i've read their post. some people have responded positively and negatively about mcgee in this post . they understood the question. simple yes or no if smith was an upgrade over mcgee "what do you all think" unlike yourself they understood. you probably have a college degree I'm not gonna call u stupid, just shows u have book sense and in this simple question no common sense. you see i'm not saying cut mcgee or pick up smith in my question and yet u still got something smart to say. Please explain what crap i'm throwing up against the wall cause you out of 3 pages of post is the only person that don't understand the simple question

You keep repeating the same thing like a Mantra, as if, if you say it, it will somehow become true. You whined about people saying that was foolish question or not a valid question. If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.

Just released from the ravens upgrade over our 3rd Qb or not? What do you all think

Any reasonable man would think based on that, you are proposing to cut McGee or pick upTroy over McGee. So your question got both redicule and some who agreed with you. So live with both the Redicule and agreements. Just don't complain about this being a forum and any question is valid. Kapish? You can pose any question you want. Just like I did about Tony Romo to Matt Ryan question. You called it dumb. Hence that was my point about your question. It was equally dumb, since anyone, who has seen McGee in the fourth pre-season game, against Dolphins starters, wouldn't think he is not worth the 3rd string QB spot. Yep there are some who still think he is not worth, but apparently cowboys front office/coaches don't agree with them. IN this case I think I trust the proffessionals.

Anyone who has seen Troy Smith, should know, he is a very limited QB, and no prospects of developing into something special or even a good backup QB. Thats the reason Ravens cut him. Now, beyond that, I see you don't get the point and you will continue to whine about being called out. I have nothing more to say, you cease to entertain me ( well I have to go out too now for real entertainment).

 

[erich1r]

Like i said repeatedly over and over i never said cut mcgee or pick up smith Rcowboyfan it's obvious you didn't read the post. How is it you're the only one that think i'm saying cut mcgee and pick smith or keep 4 qb's . i would have said cut mcgee or lets pick up smith. which i clearly did'nt say. Ive said in my post to you that i'm fine with mcgee. Read and understand before you trash talk

 

[Plucky]

If you use any football sense to the question that was asked you would understand that McGee has struggled most of the preseason untill the other night when he was playing against mostly the later second and thrid stringers. Besides does your ignorant football philosophy believe if someone is cut then that means that they are no good or that they may not just fit in that current system I.E.(Matt Leinart). So McGee lover, how can you determine a different opinion that even the coaches has said over and over that McGee needs to step up. He has not produced at any level since he has been with the cowboys. So do your research before you reply clown. Besides that is one of the reasons why Romo is so up and down because there is no one behind him that can really push him in the QB position especially having Kitna and McGee behind him.