Turns out yardage is more important than turnovers after all

Red Dragon

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,395
Reaction score
3,773
For a long time, conventional wisdom seemed to have held that forcing turnovers is more important for a defense than limiting opposing yardage, especially after last season when the Cowboys had a hard time coming up with any turnovers at all.


But this year, turnovers haven't been a problem. The Cowboys defense, in fact, may end up getting twice as many takeaways as it did last season.


And yet...........the Cowboys gave up 31, 31, 51, 31, and 49 points to the Giants, Chargers, Broncos, Lions and Saints.

The Cowboys are a mediocre 5-5.


Why? Because, as much as we think that yardage is just stat-padding, it can very well decide the outcome of a game. Against Detroit, the Cowboys forced 4 turnovers but still lost - why? Because the defense gave up over 600 yards.

Against the Saints? Defense allowed over 600 yards.

Against the Chargers? Defense allowed over 500 yards.

Against the Broncos? Defense allowed over 500 yards.

Against the Giants? The Cowboys forced 6 turnovers - but even still, after they had had their 5th takeaway, the Cowboys were still on the brink of defeat. If it weren't for a lucky bounce of the ball off of a Giants' players' hands into the hands of Brandon Carr, the Cowboys may very well have lost that game 31-30. Why? Because Eli Manning had huge yardage against the Cowboys, as often is the case.



So conventional wisdom has been turned on its head: Yardage is actually more important than turnovers.
 
Messages
18,222
Reaction score
28,531
The Cowboys defense is an extreme case. Having this many turnovers doesn't help when you give up yards like they do.

You must have turnovers, but whenyou don't get them, you have to stop the opposition every now and then. This defense either gets a turnover or lets the offense waltz down the field to score.

Some 3 and outs once in a while would be nice.
 
Top