Undisputed talks Dak's NFL Ranking

triplets_93

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,984
Reaction score
6,460
Skip Bayless, Keyshawn Johnson and Emmanuel Acho react to Dak Prescott being ranked No. 9 on the Top 10 NFL quarterback list. They then discuss whether Dak is capable of leading the Dallas Cowboys to a Super Bowl or not.



Some silly points made. Yet, some interesting points made by Keyshawn and Acho.
 

Reverend Conehead

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,951
Reaction score
11,849
Some of their points make me wonder if the league should have some additional stat categories:
* interceptions-QF (quarterback's fault)
* interceptions-RF (receiver's fault)
* interceptions-BF (both at fault)
 

InPhiltraitor

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,152
Reaction score
1,279
Wow. I said Keyshawn was going to be the voice of reason with this band of misfits and he is.

Pretty sure I would have slapped Acho in his noggin. Skip stupidly wondering why Dak's numbers went down against an excellent defense like the 9er's following a great performance against a garbage playoff team like the Bucs just demonstrates very low intellectual ceiling. Open your eyes, Skid - shut-up Acho!
 

plasticman

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,468
Reaction score
17,556
People can "rank" these quarterbacks any way they want, it is totally arbitrary and useless. You can pick any method you want and the results have nothing to do with a quarterback's primary function.

The quarterback rating system is one of the most popular to use so let me ask you a question......

In 57 Super Bowls, how many Super Bowl champion teams were led by the highest rated passer that season?

The answer is 8.

The last one was Drew Brees in 2009. Staubach did it in 1971.

The only ranking that means anything at all is the won-loss record of the team they are playing for. and that puts Dak in the top five of all active NFL QB's since his first start, the first game of his rookie season.
 

shabazz

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,480
Reaction score
35,591
Some of their points make me wonder if the league should have some additional stat categories:
* interceptions-QF (quarterback's fault)
* interceptions-RF (receiver's fault)
* interceptions-BF (both at fault)
Beautifully said, as usual but how can you leave out the infamous NF category?...."Nobody's Fault"

It would be an instant go to with our resident homers.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
Skip Bayless, Keyshawn Johnson and Emmanuel Acho react to Dak Prescott being ranked No. 9 on the Top 10 NFL quarterback list. They then discuss whether Dak is capable of leading the Dallas Cowboys to a Super Bowl or not.



Some silly points made. Yet, some interesting points made by Keyshawn and Acho.

Hilarious how all the haters or doubters on there did the same laughable nonsense.

All they could to discredit Dak was use Mahomes and Rogers as examples.

They cherry picked the Niners game, they talked about the 15 picks that has never happened before, and they used the 2-4 playoff record which is a team record.

Skip complimented Pollard, but failed to point out Pollard got injured early in the Niners game. They also never seemed to figure out that the Niners have the #1 defense in the NFL either.

I would have tore Skip and that out chump a new one.

All did agree that Dak was top 10 though.
 

Mannix

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,953
Reaction score
11,298
Sorry to disappoint the Skip haters, but what he says at 6:02 is 100% dead nutz correct!!!
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
46,768
Reaction score
22,472
People can "rank" these quarterbacks any way they want, it is totally arbitrary and useless. You can pick any method you want and the results have nothing to do with a quarterback's primary function.

The quarterback rating system is one of the most popular to use so let me ask you a question......

In 57 Super Bowls, how many Super Bowl champion teams were led by the highest rated passer that season?

The answer is 8.

The last one was Drew Brees in 2009. Staubach did it in 1971.

The only ranking that means anything at all is the won-loss record of the team they are playing for. and that puts Dak in the top five of all active NFL QB's since his first start, the first game of his rookie season.
:clap:
 

acr731

Jerry learned to GM from Pee Wee Herman
Messages
10,089
Reaction score
27,981
People can "rank" these quarterbacks any way they want, it is totally arbitrary and useless.
It IS useless. But it's a common thing the Dak fans use to prop him up. Take that away and what else would they have? Literally no one thinks he can lead a team to a super bowl like Mahomes so they use the meaningless rankings.
 

Virginia-Dave

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,803
Reaction score
3,355
Acho is someone I cannot stand to listen to. He has clearly been trying to build a career out of Cowboys bashing, aka Stephen A. Smith. Every time he opens his mouth, I wish somebody would punch him in the face. At least SAS is entertaining, and embraces being a villain. Acho is just a smiling clown.
 

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,449
Reaction score
29,647
The 49ers have shown you the last 2 years exactly what your lists, stats, and rankings are worth.
 

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
42,070
Reaction score
28,655
Some of their points make me wonder if the league should have some additional stat categories:
* interceptions-QF (quarterback's fault)
* interceptions-RF (receiver's fault)
* interceptions-BF (both at fault)
how can you not have one for offensive line can't block you know when his arm gets hit on his follow through or his back of his jersey gets grabbed because of the pass rush win rate was pretty poor last year that's gotta be a problem too???!

that is why real fans see the big picture and we know about six or seven of those interceptions were not his not alone anyway yes, he threw the ball but there were many reasons it got picked off and most of them were not bad decisions or he should have not thrown the ball.

it gets tiresome that that's all they focus on but if I bring up all the other interceptions from my other quarterbacks in the past they start bringing up stuff like Era, oh it's different, it's not the same, and blah blah blah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!​
or we talk about Peyton Manning had twice as many interceptions in the first 97 games also have the same playoff record it's not the same blah blah blah and we talk about Matthew stafford's 20 interceptions in his Super Bowl Rams win he had two in that game alone and you know what the difference is,​
the team helped him win the game the team helped eight men and Roger and Brett farve and Peyton Manning win those games they did not do it alone..
You give Prescott a better run game and a better offensive line in the Rams 2018 game in both 49ers games and we win those games but playing one-dimensional ball with a less than physical offensive line and no run game yeah that's what happens you lose the game by one score..
 
Top