We weren't the only ones having an off night

blindzebra

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,560
Reaction score
4,451
Just watched the DVR of the game through the 2nd Houston TD and the officials have been awful.

Blatant block in the back on the punt return, and it was the guy who had a bead on Jones too.

3rd and 4 on the drive that started at their 46, blatant PI on Houston...the guy who knocked it down had Crayton around the waist.

Greens long run, they called a horse collar on Henry, and it was Ware and he had him by the jersey and wasn't anywhere near the shoulder pads.
 

ScipioCowboy

More than meets the eye.
Messages
25,266
Reaction score
17,597
blindzebra;1606486 said:
Just watched the DVR of the game through the 2nd Houston TD and the officials have been awful.

Blatant block in the back on the punt return, and it was the guy who had a bead on Jones too.

3rd and 4 on the drive that started at their 46, blatant PI on Houston...the guy who knocked it down had Crayton around the waist.

Greens long run, they called a horse collar on Henry, and it was Ware and he had him by the jersey and wasn't anywhere near the shoulder pads.

The officiating was indeed poor last night, but Mike Carey remains one of my favorite refs. He and Johnny Grier also seemed to officiate the Cowboys fairly...unlike Ed Hock-a-loogie.;)
 

TunaFan33

Benched
Messages
1,824
Reaction score
0
blindzebra;1606486 said:
Just watched the DVR of the game through the 2nd Houston TD and the officials have been awful.

Blatant block in the back on the punt return, and it was the guy who had a bead on Jones too.

3rd and 4 on the drive that started at their 46, blatant PI on Houston...the guy who knocked it down had Crayton around the waist.

Greens long run, they called a horse collar on Henry, and it was Ware and he had him by the jersey and wasn't anywhere near the shoulder pads.

For the most part, I thought we looked pretty good coming out the gate-outgained the Texans 77-17 in 1st qtr yardage, played very good D in that 1st qtr, and yeah, it was an obvious block in the back on that punt return. But either way, there are times where we'll get short-changed, and then get benefited at the same time.

All in all, we looked pretty solid throughout that 1st qtr-only to shoot ourselves in the foot afterwards. Otherwise, we might have ran away with it by then. In this league, you just can't botch your early opportunities, or it WILL bite you in the butt later, like it showed us.
 

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365
Staff member
Messages
62,320
Reaction score
64,020
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
blindzebra;1606486 said:
Greens long run, they called a horse collar on Henry, and it was Ware and he had him by the jersey and wasn't anywhere near the shoulder pads.
That tackle was replayed repeatedly. As you've said, Ware had all jersey. That's a clear example of a penalty which the ref should be 100% sure of before throwing the flag. However, if the flag is thrown, the booth ref should review it and remove all doubt because in this case, it was a bad call.
 

Rampage

Benched
Messages
24,117
Reaction score
2
players get blocked in the back all the time on returns it's just a matter of if they call it. go watch 1 of roy's highlight vids where he runs that pick back in washington. there was a blatant block in the back but it wasn't called. spencer should have made the tackle on the punt return but he sucks so far
 

tomson75

Brain Dead Shill
Messages
16,720
Reaction score
1
dwarecwby311;1606503 said:
not to mention mcbriar was way out of position in coverage

Well that's one way to introduce yourself to the board...
 

firehawk350

Active Member
Messages
2,108
Reaction score
0
DallasEast;1606495 said:
That tackle was replayed repeatedly. As you've said, Ware had all jersey. That's a clear example of a penalty which the ref should be 100% sure of before throwing the flag. However, if the flag is thrown, the booth ref should review it and remove all doubt because in this case, it was a bad call.
The rule was altered to include back of the jersey horse collars too. Legit call.
 

Beast_from_East

Well-Known Member
Messages
30,140
Reaction score
27,231
blindzebra;1606486 said:
Just watched the DVR of the game through the 2nd Houston TD and the officials have been awful.

Blatant block in the back on the punt return, and it was the guy who had a bead on Jones too.

3rd and 4 on the drive that started at their 46, blatant PI on Houston...the guy who knocked it down had Crayton around the waist.

Greens long run, they called a horse collar on Henry, and it was Ware and he had him by the jersey and wasn't anywhere near the shoulder pads.

The officiating was clearly one-sided last night, I not using that as an excuse, I am just saying.:mad:
 

blindzebra

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,560
Reaction score
4,451
firehawk350;1606530 said:
The rule was altered to include back of the jersey horse collars too. Legit call.

Care to supply a source, because here is the list of rule changes for 2007:


2007 NFL Rules Changes

Take this story to go! - RSS | Podcast | Mobile
April 16, 2007
A number of playing-rules changes were adopted by NFL owners at the NFL Annual Meeting in late March.
Following are the changes, with comments from the co-chairman of the NFL Competition Committee,
  • INSTANT REPLAY: Made a permanent rule. “We think instant replay has been an accepted part of our game now for a number of years,” says McKay. “It’s worked quite well.” Also, high-definition replay equipment will be installed in NFL stadiums.
  • INSTANT REPLAY: Also made permanent in the replay system were “down-by-contact” as a reviewable play and each review being limited to a maximum of 60 seconds.
  • SPIKING OF BALL: It will now be a five-yard penalty for a player to spike or throw the ball after a down has ended, except for after a touchdown. “We did not think this type of spiking was good for sportsmanship or the administration of the game by officials,” says McKay.
  • PLAYER SAFETY: It will now be a 15-yard penalty (rather than five yards) for a player to make a block below the waist against an eligible receiver while the quarterback is in the pocket. Also, when a player who receives the snap fumbles or muffs the ball, the restrictions on the defensive team relative to illegal contact and an illegal cut- block will end.
  • TWO-MINUTE WARNING/10-SECOND RUNOFF: The requirement that the offense has to be behind in the score or the score has to be tied for a 10-second clock runoff to be exercised against the offense for an excess timeout with two minutes to go in the first half or in the game has been eliminated. Now a 10-second runoff will take place no matter what the game situation. Any possible advantage for the offense (e.g., the old rule would not require a 10-second runoff if it were ahead) has been eliminated. The defense has the option to decline a 10-second runoff (which will give it more time should it get the ball back).
  • CLOCK STOPPAGE: Two exceptions were added to the rule that dictates that the play clock be restarted at the time at which it was stopped prior to the snap. Now an instant replay review prior to the two-minute warning will reset the clock at 25 seconds (as has been the case with other stoppages such as a penalty), as will an instant replay review after the two-minute warning that results in a reversal. These changes will make the administration of the rule more consistent.
  • PACE OF GAME: The foul for unintentional touching of a forward pass by an interior lineman has been eliminated. It was felt that no advantage was gained by the offense on such a play, and elimination of the rule would speed up the game.
  • CROWD NOISE: The five-yard penalty against the defense for excessive crowd noise has been eliminated. The penalty had not been called in many years.
Although they are not playing-rule changes, two procedures for coaching employment also were changed:
  • Assistant coaches on Super Bowl teams may now interview for a second time with a club for its head-coaching position during the off-week after the championship game. “We wanted to make sure that coaches on Super Bowl teams did not feel it was a disadvantage,” says McKay.
  • Clubs now have the exclusive right to an assistant coach’s contract through the second Tuesday after their season has ended or last playoff game, rather than the third Tuesday as in the past.
The rules of 2006 clearly stated it did not include the jersey.
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
It was changed before the 2006 season to include jersey grabs.
 

J-DOG

Active Member
Messages
2,135
Reaction score
0
ScipioCowboy;1606489 said:
The officiating was indeed poor last night, but Mike Carey remains one of my favorite refs. He and Johnny Grier also seemed to officiate the Cowboys fairly...unlike Ed Hock-a-loogie.;)
I disagree with that.
Carey's crew is always in the middle of numerous conferences trying to figure out what to call and in general his crew is in some controversy or another.
Carey crew was the one who called illegal chop blocks against our rb's last year claiming that our rb's blocked def. linemen or blitzing lb's while they were engaged with an off. linemen.
The replays showed otherwise and Parcells mentioned that afterwards.
I knew when I saw him doing the game we would get a lousy game from the refs.
How many holding calls did they miss?
That block in the back against Davis was easy to see...they were a joke last night.
 

The Realist

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,504
Reaction score
2,027
blindzebra;1606546 said:
Care to supply a source, because here is the list of rule changes for 2007:


2007 NFL Rules Changes

Take this story to go! - RSS | Podcast | Mobile
April 16, 2007
A number of playing-rules changes were adopted by NFL owners at the NFL Annual Meeting in late March.
Following are the changes, with comments from the co-chairman of the NFL Competition Committee,
  • INSTANT REPLAY: Made a permanent rule. “We think instant replay has been an accepted part of our game now for a number of years,” says McKay. “It’s worked quite well.” Also, high-definition replay equipment will be installed in NFL stadiums.
  • INSTANT REPLAY: Also made permanent in the replay system were “down-by-contact” as a reviewable play and each review being limited to a maximum of 60 seconds.
  • SPIKING OF BALL: It will now be a five-yard penalty for a player to spike or throw the ball after a down has ended, except for after a touchdown. “We did not think this type of spiking was good for sportsmanship or the administration of the game by officials,” says McKay.
  • PLAYER SAFETY: It will now be a 15-yard penalty (rather than five yards) for a player to make a block below the waist against an eligible receiver while the quarterback is in the pocket. Also, when a player who receives the snap fumbles or muffs the ball, the restrictions on the defensive team relative to illegal contact and an illegal cut- block will end.
  • TWO-MINUTE WARNING/10-SECOND RUNOFF: The requirement that the offense has to be behind in the score or the score has to be tied for a 10-second clock runoff to be exercised against the offense for an excess timeout with two minutes to go in the first half or in the game has been eliminated. Now a 10-second runoff will take place no matter what the game situation. Any possible advantage for the offense (e.g., the old rule would not require a 10-second runoff if it were ahead) has been eliminated. The defense has the option to decline a 10-second runoff (which will give it more time should it get the ball back).
  • CLOCK STOPPAGE: Two exceptions were added to the rule that dictates that the play clock be restarted at the time at which it was stopped prior to the snap. Now an instant replay review prior to the two-minute warning will reset the clock at 25 seconds (as has been the case with other stoppages such as a penalty), as will an instant replay review after the two-minute warning that results in a reversal. These changes will make the administration of the rule more consistent.
  • PACE OF GAME: The foul for unintentional touching of a forward pass by an interior lineman has been eliminated. It was felt that no advantage was gained by the offense on such a play, and elimination of the rule would speed up the game.
  • CROWD NOISE: The five-yard penalty against the defense for excessive crowd noise has been eliminated. The penalty had not been called in many years.
Although they are not playing-rule changes, two procedures for coaching employment also were changed:
  • Assistant coaches on Super Bowl teams may now interview for a second time with a club for its head-coaching position during the off-week after the championship game. “We wanted to make sure that coaches on Super Bowl teams did not feel it was a disadvantage,” says McKay.
  • Clubs now have the exclusive right to an assistant coach’s contract through the second Tuesday after their season has ended or last playoff game, rather than the third Tuesday as in the past.
The rules of 2006 clearly stated it did not include the jersey.

NFL Rule changes for 2006


By Scout.com

Posted Aug 12, 2006

There are several new rules in the NFL in 2006. The NFL Competition Committee spends the early part of the offseason examining existing rules, and suggesting possible changes to the rules.

Rules changes are then voted upon by the teams at the NFL Annual Meeting in the spring. No matter what the changes, NFL players and coaches know they have to be cognizant of them.

“Our approach to the game is the same as it always is: to know the rules and to play within them,” says New England Patriots head coach Bill Belichick.

New NFL rules for 2006:
• Down by contact calls may be reviewed by instant replay. Previously, a fumble was not reviewable if the ball carrier was ruled down by contact. If the ruling of down by contact is changed, the ball belongs to the recovering player at the spot of the recovery of the fumble.
Reason for the change: Provides a mechanism for correcting an obvious on-field officiating error.

• Each instant replay review will be a maximum of 60 seconds in length. Previously, instant replay could last up to 90 seconds.
Reason for the change: Shortens game length.

• Individual players are prohibited from using foreign objects or the football while celebrating. They are also prohibited from engaging in any celebrations while on the ground. A celebration shall be deemed excessive or prolonged if a player continues to celebrate after a warning from an official. Previously, players were not prohibited from using props or celebrating on the ground.
Reason for the change: Promotes sportsmanship.

• If possible, rushing defenders must make a conscious effort to avoid low hits on the quarterback. Previously, defenders were not compelled to make a conscious effort to avoid low hits if momentum was a factor. Penalty: Roughing the passer, loss of 15 yards.
Reason for the change: Player safety.

• The prohibition against blocking in the back above the waist applies to a player of the kicking team while the ball is in flight during a scrimmage kick. Previously, this was not a foul. Penalty: Loss of 10 yards.
Reason for the change: Player safety.

All players are prohibited from grabbing the inside collar of the back of the shoulder pads or jersey, or the inside collar of the side of the shoulder pads or jersey, and immediately pulling down the runner. This does not apply to a runner who is in the tackle box or to a quarterback who is in the pocket. Previously, the “horse-collar” tackle rule did not include the back of the shoulder pads or jersey. This increases the scope of the rule. Penalty: Loss of 15 yards.
Reason for the change: Player safety.

• During a field goal attempt or a PAT, any defensive player within one yard of the line of scrimmage at the snap must have his helmet outside the snapper’s shoulder pad. This will provide protection to the snapper, who is in a defenseless position. Penalty: Illegal formation, loss of five yards.
Reason for the change: Player safety.

• No more than six players can line up on the same side of a formation on a kickoff. Previously, teams could “load up” one side with more players for onside kicks.
Reason for the change: Player safety.

• If there is a personal foul or unsportsmanlike conduct foul that is (a) not in the continuing action immediately after the end of a down and (b) occurs between the end of the second period and the beginning of the third period (or between the end of the fourth and beginning of OT), the penalty shall be enforced on ensuing kickoff. Previously, these penalties were not carried over.
Reason for the change: Provides uniform enforcement for personal or unsportsmanlike conduct fouls throughout the game.

• If there is a foul during a scrimmage kick or a free kick prior to a player of the receiving team securing possession of the ball, the offended team will have the option of taking the penalty at the previous spot and replaying the down or adding the penalty yardage on to the end of the play. Previously, the offended team could either take the penalty and replay the down or decline the penalty and take the result of the play.
Reason for the change: Eliminates re-kicks.

• If an offensive foul is a foul by the kicking team prior to a player of the receiving team securing possession of the ball during a down in which there is a safety kick, scrimmage kick, or free kick, the period may be extended by an untimed down, if the defense accepts the penalty. This provides the option for a receiving team to extend a period if a kicking team commits a foul prior to a change of possession. Reason for change: Eliminates fouling to obtain an unfair advantage.

• Teams can now opt to take the result of the play OR replay the down when there is an inadvertent whistle. Previously, an inadvertent whistle would force the down to be replayed without exception. Reason for the change: Current rule too punitive.
 

blindzebra

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,560
Reaction score
4,451
I stand corrected...it's still a stupid rule.;)

Okay we can replace that one with several blatant holding calls on Ware that were not called.:D
 

jimmy40

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,866
Reaction score
1,888
blindzebra;1606486 said:
Just watched the DVR of the game through the 2nd Houston TD and the officials have been awful.

Blatant block in the back on the punt return, and it was the guy who had a bead on Jones too.

3rd and 4 on the drive that started at their 46, blatant PI on Houston...the guy who knocked it down had Crayton around the waist.

Greens long run, they called a horse collar on Henry, and it was Ware and he had him by the jersey and wasn't anywhere near the shoulder pads.
Wow, making excuses for losing to Houston. What's next, Houston was game planning?
 

blindzebra

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,560
Reaction score
4,451
jimmy40;1606678 said:
Wow, making excuses for losing to Houston. What's next, Houston was game planning?


Where did I say it cost us the game?

Comprehension skills are still sharp as ever I see.
 
Top