What is involved with what a GM by definition?

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,488
Reaction score
21,746
In 1960, the National Football League approved a franchise for Dallas, and Murchison, along with Bedford Wynne, was the franchisee or license holder. A motivating factor in the NFL's decision to award a license for Dallas was the establishment of the American Football League (AFL) by Lamar Hunt, another Dallas area businessman. Hunt, in helping create the AFL, established a professional football presence in Dallas, and the NFL realized the urgency with which they needed to address a potential market gain by the upstart league and a loss for the established organization.

For the most part, Murchison was a hands-off owner, delegating a great deal of operational control of the Cowboys to general manager Tex Schramm, head coach Tom Landry and scouting/personnel director Gil Brandt. His general attitude was to hire experts and let them execute the aspect of the business that fell in their expertise. Hence, Schramm oversaw most of the Cowboys day-to-day business matters, and represented the Cowboys at league meetings–a prerogative normally reserved to the owner. Brandt had a free hand in drafting and scouting players, and Landry enjoyed absolute authority over the day-to-day running of the actual team.

Schramm interrupted his education to serve as an officer in the United States Army Air Forces during World War II.

When Schramm took command of the newly formed Dallas franchise in 1960, Brandt was one of the first people he hired. Schramm, Brandt and Coach Tom Landry formed the triumvirate which guided the Cowboys for their first 29 years.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tex_Schramm

In the National Football League, the general manager (GM) is typically the head of football operations. Major responsibilities include the power to hire and dismiss a head coach, leading the scouting department, handling free agent transactions and trades, and contract negotiations. Under such a model, the GM reports directly to the owner or team president. However, some team owners serve as GM or employ one who act in supporting role to the head coach. Al Davis of the Oakland Raiders was an example of a owner who also served as GM, while Bill Belichick is an example of a head coach having de facto GM responsibilities during most of his tenure with the New England Patriots.

The general manager (GM) is typically the head of football operations, which includes being head of the scouting department, handling free agent transactions and trades, and responsible for negotiating contracts with players and coaches. The scouting department's role is to evaluate college football players entering the annual NFL draft.[1] During the NFL Combine, general managers will interview players.[2]

Many GMs begin their front office career as an assistant scout and are promoted into roles such as director of college scouting or vice president of player personnel before being GM. The GM is also responsible for negotiating contracts with players and coaches.[3] As with head coaches and some players, GMs are required by the NFL to attend press conferences with the media. During the season, general managers will work 100 hours or more a week.[3] Some Pro Football Hall of Fame general managers include Tex Schramm, Al Davis, Bill Polian, Ron Wolf, Bobby Beathard, Gil Brandt, and George Young.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_manager_(American_football)#Responsibilities

RotoPat’s 2023 NFL GM Rankings​


12. Jerry Jones/Stephen Jones, Cowboys

What can Jerry Jones say? He knows how to draft a first-rounder. They remain the lifeblood of this roster, including Zack Martin and CeeDee Lamb on offense and Micah Parsons on defense. But Jones celebrated one hit a little too long. His undying Ezekiel Elliott devotion created cap complications that dovetailed into poor decisions like trading Amari Cooper. The Zeke saga is emblematic of Jones’ bad habit of making tough decisions a year too late instead of a year too early. It means the Cowboys are seemingly always operating off their back foot as they try to round out an annually impressive core. Some seasons there is enough slack in the line to win 10-12 games. 2021 and 2022 were both such campaigns. Too often, however, the bottom falls out despite the stars at the top. Even with Dak Prescott‘s on-field foibles, that star power continues to shine brightly. This team is a contender. We’ll see if that’s enough to overcome the annual depth issues in 2023, which look acute at pass catcher and could become a problem along an aging offensive line.

https://www.nbcsports.com/fantasy/f...goal-line-stand-rotopats-2023-nfl-gm-rankings


A sports GM oversees all aspects of the team's management, including athlete contracts and development, as well as working closely with the coaching staff.

In a professional sports setting, they will also usually be responsible for some aspect of managing finances and acting as the team president or spokesperson.

While managing the team is an integral part of the position as a sports general manager, overseeing the marketing and accounting department is equally as important.

A sports general manager shares similar responsibilities as a CEO and answers solely to the team owner.



The job of general manager in the NFL is changing. It’s growing. It’s becoming more challenging. And thus, what a team is looking for in one has had to evolve, too.

Aspiring young GMs usually can’t point to one thing or another, the way an offensive coordinator can cite a quarterback’s development, or a defensive coordinator can send a team his unit’s key metrics, as a reason why they should be the next guy to land one of 32 coveted spots running a team.

Scouting roles, and roles in personnel in general, are normally too vague for any facts or figures to be blindly reliable—a person who holds a title in one place might have a vastly different job than a person holding the same title in another place—so sorting through a mountain of names to be considered usually requires a whole lot more digging. And it’s getting even harder as NFL organizations continue to add new departments and staff.

____________________________

1) An ability to hire staff.

2) An ability to work productively with the head coach.

3) An ability to manage people.

You might notice there’s nothing in there about finding a quarterback, maximizing a third-round pick or building out depth in your secondary. There also isn’t anything about managing the cap or implementing analytics. Why? Well, you can find people to do all of those things. And it’s great if the GM can check off a couple of those boxes themself. But ultimately, they’re going to need help, and that takes finding and deploying good people effectively.

https://www.si.com/nfl/2021/12/31/future-general-managers-week-17-preview

“You are the general manager—you can take that literally,” said one such NFC GM. “The job is broad, and so you have to be able to hire people that offset your own weaknesses. It’s not even necessarily a football job all the time. I deal with HR, I deal with contracts, I deal with things I’ve never had to deal with in my life. So no matter how well-trained you are, and obviously the more you’ve been exposed to, the better, you’re going be learning on the run.

You need good people at their specific jobs.

___________________________________

In one of the most dramatic eras of ownership in professional sports, Jerry Jones' stewardship of the Dallas Cowboys has brought unprecedented results and success to one of the world's most popular sports entities. His more than three-decade long journey reached a rare pinnacle with his induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame as a member of the 2017 class of enshrinees, as Jones became just the 15th owner in history to earn a bust in Canton.

Now Jerry is GM in name only. Most team decisions are made by highly qualified individuals to carry most roles in function.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

kskboys

Well-Known Member
Messages
44,537
Reaction score
47,386
They are? So that's why we suck drafting in the 2nd, highly qualified individuals, got it.
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,488
Reaction score
21,746
We’re primarily focusing on the following categories:

  1. Draft pick production compared to expectation
  2. Positional value consideration
  3. Draft trade value
  4. Free-agent signing value compared to expectation
  5. Early extensions
There is overwhelming historical evidence that trading down is a positive-expected-value move within the current construct of how draft picks are valued. However, maneuvering up and down can yield value, and opinions on pick values are starting to change. The Fitzgerald-Spielberger chart methodology is explained here, with the value of each pick listed.

Howie Roseman, Philadelphia Eagles (since 2010)​

Brett Veach, Kansas City Chiefs (since 2018)​

Duke Tobin, Cincinnati Bengals (since 1999)​

Jerry Jones, Dallas Cowboys (since 1994)​


First and foremost, we have to mention Cowboys vice president of player personnel Will McClay, who deserves as much credit for what Dallas does year in and year out as anyone.

Dallas has the highest ratio of homegrown to external talent in the NFL, truly taking the draft-and-develop approach to heart and consistently winning football games as a result. While this is the most sustainable and repeatable roster-building philosophy, Dallas showed this offseason in trading for wide receiver Brandin Cooks and cornerback Stephon Gilmore that it will supplement the roster with outside talent when the timing is right and the reinforcements are necessary.

“America’s Team” gets a lot of flak for coming up short in the playoffs over the past few decades, and what makes them sustainable arguably limits their ceiling at times, as well, but the consistent influx of elite talent in Dallas is undeniable. The Cowboys finally started to extend players like cornerback Trevon Diggs this past offseason to early extensions, which was a major weak spot in their operation for years.

https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-general-manager-rankings-2023-eagles-howie-roseman-chiefs-brett-veach
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,488
Reaction score
21,746
They are? So that's why we suck drafting in the 2nd, highly qualified individuals, got it.
You draft nobody and I don't ever remembering anyone inviting you to their board review or the draft. I bet you are really upset about that...huh. This isn't an insult directed at Jerry. Start another thread if you don't want to discuss valid issues of valid analysis. There is referenced material upon the OP.

Discussions on topic aren't all good, that is a given. You don't even attempt to discuss beyond insult. Tell me now, after the Herchel Walker deal, how is he really doing here and now?
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,488
Reaction score
21,746
Mazi -Taco and Schoonmaker.....Great picks...1st- 2nd pick
Too soon to pass the Bill Parcells rule: three seasons...and no where close here. I'm still very interested in those two. Heroes are grown on the team level.

Taco failed...good bye, but not quickly in his career for some reason.
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,488
Reaction score
21,746

Duke Tobin, Cincinnati Bengals​

Technically, the Bengals don’t have a “general manager” title. But the architect responsible for their on-field product is Duke Tobin, their director of player personnel for over two decades. In his time, Tobin has mostly struck the right chords as Cincinnati’s master puppeteer.

From 2005 to 2015, the Bengals qualified for the postseason on seven occasions. When it was time to tear the Marvin Lewis/Carson Palmer/Andy Dalton era down, Tobin didn’t miss. He made Joe Burrow — a superstar quarterback — the centerpiece of his rebuild. Then he added Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins. That trio amplified an already promising defensive core of DJ Reader, Sam Hubbard and Trey Hendrickson. And when he had to keep Burrow upright, Tobin wasted no time investing in three offensive line starters — Ted Karras, Alex Cappa and Orlando Brown Jr.

Suffice it to say: Tobin is responsible for the Bengals becoming a marquee team and a genuine Super Bowl contender (as long as Burrow is their quarterback). I don’t envision him leaving the top five any time soon.

https://ftw.usatoday.com/lists/nfl-gm-rankings-2023-best-worst-howie-roseman-george-paton
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,488
Reaction score
21,746

John Lynch, San Francisco 49ers​


His first-round picks leave a lot to be desired — especially Trey Lance — but Lynch has still managed to construct a Super Bowl heavyweight in San Francisco. Lynch’s 49ers have played in three of the last four NFC title games because they’re stacked with difference-making skill players and destructive defensive buzzsaws. From George Kittle and Deebo Samuel to Fred Warner and Talanoa Hufanga, these are all guys Lynch has brought to town.

Thanks to Lynch’s instrumental hand, San Francisco is in a position to win its first Super Bowl in almost three decades. A word of advice to him, though: I’d try to keep Nick Bosa happy at all costs.

https://ftw.usatoday.com/lists/nfl-gm-rankings-2023-best-worst-howie-roseman-george-paton
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,488
Reaction score
21,746

Brandon Beane, Buffalo Bills​


Beane’s Bills have been so consistently successful that his former assistant GM, Joe Schoen, now leads his own operation with the New York Giants. And I can’t blame anyone for emulating Buffalo right now. Five playoff berths in six seasons. Drafting a very raw Josh Allen and turning him into perhaps the most successful development story in NFL lore. And a gifted roster with justifiable Super Bowl aspirations as long as No. 17 is their quarterback.

I have my qualms about how Beane chooses to help Allen on the field. Fun fact: You are allowed to add more receivers alongside Stefon Diggs! That said, Beane is still a top-dog executive.

https://ftw.usatoday.com/lists/nfl-gm-rankings-2023-best-worst-howie-roseman-george-paton
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,488
Reaction score
21,746
Team Defenses starting in 2020

BUFFALO BILLS

2020 Defensive Pass Efficiency Rank: 10
2020 Defensive Rush Efficiency Rank: 25
2020 Base Coverage: Cover 3
2020 Third-Down Mentality: Sit back in Cover 3 or Cover 1

Although they still base in single-high defenses, the Bills utilize two-high structures at a high rate on all downs. They played quarters coverage at the league's fifth-highest rate last year.

Head coach Sean McDermott and defensive coordinator Leslie Frazier aren’t thought of as blitz-happy coaches. In fact, they are at their best on third down when they don't blitz, as they finished sixth in EPA allowed per play last year when they didn’t blitz on third down.

CINCINNATI BENGALS

2020 Defensive Pass Efficiency Rank: 25
2020 Defensive Rush Efficiency Rank: 21
2020 Base Coverage: Cover 1
2020 Third-Down Mentality: Blitz and play Cover 1

The Bengals have tried to be a singe-high team under defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo. It worked for the most part in 2020, as they were excellent playing Cover 1 and Cover 3 on third down, finishing second league-wide in defensive efficiency in those situations.

The problem was that they were less than stellar on other downs and when they tried to do anything else on the back end. They ranked 25th in EPA allowed per play on early downs.

Without William Jackson III, we could see the side move back to more zone coverage. Jackson clocked in with the seventh-best grade in Cover 1 last year at 80.8. They won’t have that luxury in 2021.

SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS

2020 Defensive Pass Efficiency Rank: 9
2020 Defensive Rush Efficiency Rank: 5
2020 Base Coverage: Cover 3 and quarters
2020 Third-Down Mentality: Blitz and play Cover 1

DeMeco Ryans takes over for Robert Saleh as the 49ers' defensive coordinator for 2021. Ryans worked under Saleh, so we can expect the defense to stay relatively stable. The 49ers played one of the highest rate of quarters coverages on early downs to go along with basing out of Cover 3. They have a low blitz rate on early downs but then turn up the pressure on passing downs. San Francisco ranked 19th in early-down blitz rate and third on third down last year. Overall, the unit ranked in the top 10 on early downs and third downs in EPA allowed per play.

DALLAS COWBOYS

2020 Defensive Pass Efficiency Rank: 20
2020 Defensive Rush Efficiency Rank: 29
2020 Base Coverage: Cover 3
2020 Third-Down Mentality: Cover 1 with a hole player

Dan Quinn becomes the new Cowboys defensive coordinator after six seasons as the Atlanta Falcons head coach. Quinn is thought of as a Cover 3 coach, but over the past two seasons, he’s played almost as much Cover 1 (36%) as he has Cover 3 (31%). He’s also added a subtle rotation into Cover 2 (14% of snaps) as a change-up.

Quinn also became more and more fond of the blitz as his reign in Atlanta went on, with his blitz rate climbing every year from 2016 on and jumping by just over four percentage points in each of the last two seasons.

https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-defensive-scheme-analysis-32-nfl-teams-2021
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,488
Reaction score
21,746

1. BUFFALO BILLS (NO CHANGE)

Even the loss of Tre’Davious White — Buffalo's best cornerback — can’t slow down the dominance of the Bills' defense. The unit proved against New England in Week 16 that they can stop the run well enough to make it a balanced game, and they are elite when that happens. No defense in the league allows scoring drives at a lower rate than the Bills (28.7%), and they are doing that without a whole collection of players grading at an elite level. Safeties Jordan Poyer and Micah Hyde are the highest-graded members of the defense, and neither carries an overall PFF grade higher than 85.0.

3. DALLAS COWBOYS (UP 13)

At some point, it’s time to accept that the Dallas defense isn’t just vastly improved from a year ago, but it’s actually one of the best in the NFL, driven by elite performances from several key players. Rookie Micah Parsons is one of the best defenders in the game already, and at multiple positions. Parsons has 60 total pressures despite playing as an off-the-ball linebacker most of the time.

Cornerback Trevon Diggs may not be quite as good as his league-leading interception total suggests, but those picks are the most valuable plays a defense can generate outside of also scoring on the turnover. No defense has forced more turnovers than Dallas.

16. CINCINNATI BENGALS (DOWN 2)

Few defenses have as wide a range of performance as the Bengals this season. Sometimes they look excellent and cause real problems for opposing offenses, and on other occasions they little more than a speed-bump for the opposition. Trey Hendrickson has proved to be an excellent free-agent acquisition, building on the career year that got him paid in the first place. He has 71 pressures, already 21 more than a year ago, and an 84.5 PFF pass-rushing grade, a significant jump on his previous career high.

18. SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS (UP 6)

San Francisco has rescued its season and looks headed for the playoffs, even as a late-season injury to quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo throws some doubt into the equation. Part of that revival in fortune has been down to the defense, which has massively picked up its game over the season.

Nick Bosa now has 70 pressures on the year and a 90.1 PFF pass-rushing grade. Arik Armstead, Samson Ebukam and even Arden Key have also been real factors in recent weeks in applying pressure on the quarterback.

https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-week-17-defense-rankings-2021

This is where there started to be seperation for the previously strong defenses and the Dallas playoff failure.
 
Top