Rockytop6;1487154 said:
So far, over a dozen UDFAs have been signed or agreements reached with them. No doubt there will be a few more but of those already in the fold, how many of these have a legitimate shot at making the team and how many will just be camp fodder?
I think those with a good shot are:
QB Moore
RB Battle
NT Ola
I mention the NT because Ireland said to keep an eye on him during his interview yesterday.
I think Moore will wind up being our 3rd QB and Battle has a good shot at being the 3rd rb.
Several no doubt will make the PS but I think either 2 and at the most 3 will make the season's roster.
Who do you think will make it?
QB Matt Moore-- will probably win the 3rd QB job (if he lives up to his press clippings)... on a scale of 1 to 10, I'd rate his chances of making the team a 7.5...
RB/FB Jackie Battle-- will compete with Tyson Thompson for the 3rd RB job, I think the Boys might like to get bigger here, and with Isaiah Stanback and Miles Austin making Tyson expendable on kick returns, the Battle-ship might just have a chance... let's rate his chances a 7.0...
RB Alonzo Coleman-- a smaller Tyson Thompson basically, he was ultraproductive at a low level of competition in college... I don't think he has much chance of cracking the 53 man roster, though he does probably have the speed to play in the NFL... his chances are around a 5.5...
TE Rodney Hannah-- the Boys are thin at TE, but I kinda doubt Hannah has much of a realistic chance... he's just too raw... he might be an ideal developmental candidate for the practice squad, if he shows anything in camp... I'll grade him a 4.0...
WRs Jerard Rabb and Mike Jefferson-- both look intriguing, but the Boys are very deep at WR... they're both strictly possession receivers, and one of them might well wind up on the practice squad... give both of them 5.5 out of 10...
OG Robert Turner-- a big ol' mauler, but I think he's gonna prove to be too slow to make it in the NFL... another 4.0...
C Robert Rissler-- there's a need for a backup C, but Rissler is one of those guys who gets pushed back at the line of scrimmage... if he plays well in camp, he might benefit from a year on the practice squad, during which time he'd hopefully get stronger... grades out as a 3.5...
NT Ola Dagunduro... the Boys could use a quality backup NT, if Ola plays well in camp he has a chance of sticking... give him a 7.0 grade...
DE Marcus Wright... a real longshot, IMO... call him a 3.0 type...
ILB Dedrick Harrington... could factor in on the inside, has some cover skills... grade him a 6.5...
ILB Blair Phillips... not the cover guy that Harrington is, but stouter at the point of attack... give him a 6.0 grade...
OLB/DE Alex Obomese... faces a real numbers game to make the Boys... I have some question about whether he's fast enough for the NFL... 3.0 is the highest grade I can give him...
S Jasper Johnson... another total longshot, and another 3.0 grade...
P Sam Paulescu... only way he makes the squad is if McBriar gets hurt (and even then, the Boys might go out and bring in a vet)... at best, I see his chances as 2.5 out of 10...
So, to sum up, I rate the following players as having the best chance of making the 53 man roster, in order of how I see their chances:
QB Matt Moore
RB/FB Jackie Battle
DT Ola Dagunduro
ILB Dedrick Harrington
ILB Blair Phillips
WR Mike Jefferson
RB Alonzo Coleman
WR Jerard Rabb
I could see 2 or 3 of these players making the team, 5 or 6 of them winding up on the practice squad...