What's missing is the X

Number1

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,690
Reaction score
1,326
aside from this defense learning to tackle and a consistent K thereis rther glaring hole in the offense

namely, no XWR, or rather no true X, at least not on the field, no physically dominant control WR

no Dez, no TO, no Mike Irvin, no Tony Hill

hear me out - this O is at it's core Sid Gillman's play action deep timing system

contrary to the notion it uses the run to set up the pass,
it uses key passes and runs to force the LBs and Ss to guess wrong and create big plays

you have to run to the G-T gap, you have to run wide (stretch and or sweep)

you have to throw WR slants, you have to throw TE dumps, you have hit the 9 ball

the plays feed off each other, or example
if you aren't running slants well the LBs and Ss can just hawk the run, regardless of how many are in the box
if you don't attack the G-T gap the LBs and Ss take away the seem game and kill WRs on crossing patterns ...
and you need a what Sid called a "wild card" ... Dunbar, Pollard, Bush, Kamara ... for screens & reverse

this team has the players to do all of it well, problem is the true X WRs aren't on the field
namely Wilson and Smith

Amari is an awesome all around WR and a legit #1 (most targets), but he nor Gallup or Cobb bring what the likes of Julio Jones or Antonio Bryant force on a defense

Zimmer went after the Boys the same way most DCs would w/o a true X - deep read and run LBs attacking the edge, why not if you don't lineup in run and throw a slant.
 
I think what the Cowboys are missing is coaching.

I am confused as heck. Correct me if I am wrong. Amari can play the X, Y and/or Z at an elite level. Poor coaching down the stretch was the problem. Dallas became concerned with the time on the clock instead of scoring. A bad sequence of plays cost the team the game. Then the fair catch. You can't make some things up. What really pisses me off, is I thought the Boys were legit. Jaylon and LVE look absolutely lost and have not improved through the "process",

SMH
 
Last edited:
aside from this defense learning to tackle and a consistent K thereis rther glaring hole in the offense

namely, no XWR, or rather no true X, at least not on the field, no physically dominant control WR

no Dez, no TO, no Mike Irvin, no Tony Hill

hear me out - this O is at it's core Sid Gillman's play action deep timing system

contrary to the notion it uses the run to set up the pass,
it uses key passes and runs to force the LBs and Ss to guess wrong and create big plays

you have to run to the G-T gap, you have to run wide (stretch and or sweep)

you have to throw WR slants, you have to throw TE dumps, you have hit the 9 ball

the plays feed off each other, or example
if you aren't running slants well the LBs and Ss can just hawk the run, regardless of how many are in the box
if you don't attack the G-T gap the LBs and Ss take away the seem game and kill WRs on crossing patterns ...
and you need a what Sid called a "wild card" ... Dunbar, Pollard, Bush, Kamara ... for screens & reverse

this team has the players to do all of it well, problem is the true X WRs aren't on the field
namely Wilson and Smith

Amari is an awesome all around WR and a legit #1 (most targets), but he nor Gallup or Cobb bring what the likes of Julio Jones or Antonio Bryant force on a defense

Zimmer went after the Boys the same way most DCs would w/o a true X - deep read and run LBs attacking the edge, why not if you don't lineup in run and throw a slant.
Totally agree.

I've been questioning for weeks why Kellen Moore refuses to play Cedrick Wilson at all, especially at the X position? Cedrick would help open up the pass even more since he is a good short-to-intermediate route runner, makes good cuts which create separation, has good height, long arms and good hands, and he has size that could help him shield off an opposing smaller DB.

Devin Smith has blazing speed, along with good height, nice hands and a fairly decent deep route runner where he could become a consistent deep threat, thus helping open up the pass underneath for the other WRs. Kellen Moore needs to get Cedrick and Devin much more involved.
 
It would be nice to have a bigger body who can win a jump ball. We definitely don't have that player on the team is going to muscle through something.
 
It's 90% coaching and 10% our running back. Daks career will always be held back by Garrett the same way Romos career was. Having said that when was the last time you seen Zeke get to the second level? For this offense to flourish Zeke needs to dedicate himself. He needs to take this serious and get into shape. If not this offense will only go as far as Dak can carry them.
 
X gon' give it to ya!!

Seriously though, I don't see why Gallup couldn't be that guy.
 
I think what the Cowboys are missing is coaching.

I am confused as heck. Correct me if I am wrong. Amari can play the X, Y and/or Z at an elite level. Poor coaching down the stretch was the problem. Dallas became concerned with the time on the clock instead of scoring. A bad sequence of plays cost the team the game. Then the fair catch. You can't make some things up. What really pisses me off, is I thought the Boys were legit. Jaylon and LVE look absolutely lost and have not improved through the "process",

SMH
I think we get a new coach for next season and we will be in awe how good this team really is. It will be like an animal cracking out of its shell.

I can dream, right? :laugh:
 
X is traditionally your possession receiver
Y is traditionally your route runner
Z is traditionally your deep threat

The way I see it:
Cooper is a Z/Y/X
Gallup is an X/Z/Y
Cobb is a Y
Austin is a Y/Z
Wilson is an X/Y
Smith is a Z/Y

Gallup is most definitely a true X. He’s a physical possession receiver, he just needs to lower his drops. And I disagree with your assessment that Smith is an X. He’s mainly a Z that can play some Y. Cooper can play anywhere but he’s the ideal Z.

I’d replace Witten with Jarwin and start giving Pollard more snaps. They’d be dangerous on RB & TE screens. And I never thought I’d say this, but we also need to start calling more slants. We’re running way too many stop routes now.

(and now that Dak has improved as a downfield passer, Dez would be the perfect X for this offense)
 
It would be nice to have a bigger body who can win a jump ball. We definitely don't have that player on the team is going to muscle through something.
100% right. It’s a dimension this offense is missing.
 
(and now that Dak has improved as a downfield passer, Dez would be the perfect X for this offense)

You got me. I liked your post until I saw your sneaky little fine print at the end.

I will not rescind my like though. You got me this time, however, I will not allow you to fool me again!!

Well played sir.
 
was hoping we'd get one in Smu's Courtland Sutton...he didnt get past denver tho.
in the 2020 draft...South Carolina's Bryan Edwards might be the guy...or Texas big'n Collin Johnson.
it would be an interesting dynamic to have with Cooooop and Gallup.
 
X is traditionally your possession receiver
Y is traditionally your route runner
Z is traditionally your deep threat

The way I see it:
Cooper is a Z/Y/X
Gallup is an X/Z/Y
Cobb is a Y
Austin is a Y/Z
Wilson is an X/Y
Smith is a Z/Y

Gallup is most definitely a true X. He’s a physical possession receiver, he just needs to lower his drops. And I disagree with your assessment that Smith is an X. He’s mainly a Z that can play some Y. Cooper can play anywhere but he’s the ideal Z.

I’d replace Witten with Jarwin and start giving Pollard more snaps. They’d be dangerous on RB & TE screens. And I never thought I’d say this, but we also need to start calling more slants. We’re running way too many stop routes now.

(and now that Dak has improved as a downfield passer, Dez would be the perfect X for this offense)
Cooper is an X first. And I think the X and Y you have listed are often one and the same.
 
I think we get a new coach for next season and we will be in awe how good this team really is. It will be like an animal cracking out of its shell.

I can dream, right? :laugh:

Maytbe your right. Maybe not.

All I know is that we aren't going anywhere with Garrett.
 
I am confused as heck. Correct me if I am wrong. Amari can play the X, Y and/or Z at an elite level.

ever watch Megatron play? or Julio? or Dez?

there are guys who can play X, but aren't prototype X, Amari can't run over or out jump or push DBs around

I'd play Amari all over the field in X, Y, Z and as a pitch back ... but this system needs a true X, particularly vs a good run defense

it's like Drew Pearson compared to Mike Irvin ... it takes both
Gallup is a pure YWR, but he can play X and Y, Cobb a pure Z, but can play all 3 as well
actually, all 3 do play all 3 every game, by the way, it takes a real smart QB to do this, that's more complex than Dez, Twill, and Cole playing the same spots all day

actually every WR on this roster can do a decent job at all 3... but Wilson and Smith are better at X

watch some tape off Romo and Dez ... and it's impact on the run game, Romo and Witten too

if you want to make the run work in this system you have to throw TE dumbs, and slants to your outside WRs to open running lanes
just as much as you have to run to open the slant and dump - that's why timing system coaches preach balance

as originally designed your most basic runs are pre or post snap r/p
- run strong side / TE option route
- run weak side / weak side WR slant
- run either side / double move deep

based on the QB's pre or post snap read of the play side LB, you hit the space LB gives up

notice this isolates a play side LB or S 1 on 1 vs WR / TE / RB
if you read it right simple plays turn into big plays

I really wish they would go back to using all 5 WRs and targeting 8 or 9 people a game
 

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,658
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top