What's the win-loss record for QBs whose defense surrenders 51 points?

[Red Dragon]

My guess is, something like 0-50? 0-100?


(Meaning NFL regular-season and playoff games only, of course)


Case closed.

 

[CooterBrown]

actually, I think it is something like 3-363. It's all Romo's fault. If he hadn't thrown that pick it would have been 4-362. (okay, that last is sarcasm.)

 

[jimmy40]

what's the record when their defense gives up 48?

 

[Red Dragon]

actually, I think it is something like 3-363. It's all Romo's fault. If he hadn't thrown that pick it would have been 4-362. (okay, that last is sarcasm.)

True.

Blaming Romo is like blaming a pitcher who has pitched a near-perfect game all game long but his team scores no runs and the game is tied 0-0 late in the ninth when that pitcher finally throws a bad pitch that ends in a solo home run and his team loses 1-0.

 

[jimmy40]

True.

Blaming Romo is like blaming a pitcher who has pitched a near-perfect game all game long but his team scores no runs and the game is tied 0-0 late in the ninth when that pitcher finally throws a bad pitch that ends in a solo home run and his team loses 1-0.

sucks but that would be his fault.

 

[JD_KaPow]

Teams are 0-174 when giving up 51 or more points.
Teams are 4-176 when giving up 48-50 points.

 

[Sage3030]

That loss would be the fault of the bats. Not the pitcher.

 

[JD_KaPow]

sucks but that would be his fault.

No, it wouldn't. At all.

 

[jimmy40]

No, it wouldn't. At all.

yes it would

 

[JD_KaPow]

yes it would

If a pitcher goes 9 innings and gives up 1 run, he's done his job (more than, really). Doesn't matter when he gave up the run. The idea that he's at "fault" for his team's failure to score is ludicrous.

 

[Red Dragon]

That loss would be the fault of the bats. Not the pitcher.

Exactly.

 

[jimmy40]

If a pitcher goes 9 innings and gives up 1 run, he's done his job (more than, really). Doesn't matter when he gave up the run. The idea that he's at "fault" for his team's failure to score is ludicrous.

Obviously the pitcher got out pitched, not the batter's fault.

 

[jimmy40]

True.

Blaming Romo is like blaming a pitcher who has pitched a near-perfect game all game long but his team scores no runs and the game is tied 0-0 late in the ninth when that pitcher finally throws a bad pitch that ends in a solo home run and his team loses 1-0.

your analogy makes no sense whatsoever unless you say what the other pitcher was doing, did he also have a perfect game? did he give up 20 hits and have 10 double plays behind him?

 

[AdamJT13]

Teams are 0-174 when giving up 51 or more points.
Teams are 4-176 when giving up 48-50 points.

Teams are 350-4 when scoring at least 48 points.

 

[JD_KaPow]

Obviously the pitcher got out pitched, not the batter's fault.

Ah. You're trolling. Never mind then.

 

[Fredd]

Teams are 350-4 when scoring at least 48 points.

This is exactly what I was thinking...

 

[Sage3030]

Obviously the pitcher got out pitched, not the batter's fault.

The bats are paid to get hits and score runs.

They failed at their job. The pitcher didn't.

 

[jimmy40]

Ah. You're trolling. Never mind then.

no you just made a half assed analogy.

 

[jimmy40]

The bats are paid to get hits and score runs.

They failed at their job. The pitcher didn't.

why? because the other pitcher pitched better?

 

[Sage3030]

why? because the other pitcher pitched better?

Because their job is to get hits and score runs. If they aren't doing that then they are failing.