Wheat
Philosopher
- Messages
- 2,925
- Reaction score
- 4
You folks have been going back and forth on who to keep, trade, sign, extend, etc....... and I wanted to share my outsiders view, position by position.
QB- If the Tuna returns...the Bledsoe should also. He's got enough in him to manage a game. He won't win you a ton of a games, but with a decent OL, he won't lose them either. Think Trent Dilfer but better. ALSO, its time to decide who the future at QB is also. This doesn't mean that its always a slam dunk. But, you need to settle on a #2 and groom him for the future. Is it Henson? Romo? A rookie or FA? Lock that in and prep that guy to be a snap away from the field.
RB- When JJ is healthy, he's a beast. But, he's not very healthy. I like Barber also. I still think you need a big RB for goalline gut situations. This could be a draft of FA situation also. I wouldn't go after a Jamal Lewis though. Maybe take a gamble on a guy who's been hurt, but not is looking for some playing time. A Duce Staley (ok...he's a bad example). basically, you gotta plan for JJ to miss a few games a year now, so keep and eye out for some depth there I don't know anything about your FB situation.
TE- Extend Witten....keep Campbell. That simple.
OL- Ok, you need new tackles. This should be a draft priority if you want your pass protection and running game to work. I'd even label this as the most important offseason topic for your front office. OL! OL! OL! There is no reason your QB should be sacked 7 times in a game. this would be a good RFA situation where you go after a guy from another team, and maybe it costs you a mid round pick, but you get a solid guy
WR- Keyshawn and Glenn are talented mofo's....but they aren't young. If you think a guy like Crayton is the future in a starting roll. You lock him up, if not. Then you go look for guys who can start, or will be ready in the next season or two. Somebody who can be mixed in to keep your vets fresh, but also get this guy some playing time. T.O. is not the answer for any team. If you guys want to go after him, its your funeral. I'd say this is a draft solution. Maybe the best WR you can get after you draft a tackle or two. The Steelers won't let Randel El go, but as a Skins fan...I'd love to steal that guy
DL- Are you staying with the 3-4? going back to the 4-3? What's the deal? I love your rookies. Maybe find a legit NT or whatever that spot is called in the middle of the line in a 3-4. Other than that, I'd go for depth.
LB- Is Dat done? I'd go the FA route to add some depth here....and bounce Barrow out. I could have told you guys he was done. He never took a snap for D.C. Also, in my world, I'd use Roy Williams as a tweener of LB and Safety more. I think he's so much better in run support than pass support.
CB- Henry is ok, I was never a fan. I'd look for a guy who's challenge for the #2 spot next to Newman who's been a stud a times. But Henry as the nickel would be excellent. this is where you find a guy who could play nickel/dime or a safety spot if needed
Safeties- You've got Roy....and then what? This should be a focus. I don't know where you find solid guys for this spot. We've got a reject from the Giants who came into his own here. I'm happy with Ryan Clark. I think a blue collar guy who knows how role would be good. He doesn't need to make a ton of INT's or cause a lot of fumble. Just make the clean tackle, and don't mess up. I'd look for 2 of these guys so I could have Roy lining up as a LB sometimes.
Kickers- You need a new one, 'nuff said.
I know it looks like I am suggesting a ton of turnover, but I'm not. Its mostly depth and planning for the future.
thoughts?
QB- If the Tuna returns...the Bledsoe should also. He's got enough in him to manage a game. He won't win you a ton of a games, but with a decent OL, he won't lose them either. Think Trent Dilfer but better. ALSO, its time to decide who the future at QB is also. This doesn't mean that its always a slam dunk. But, you need to settle on a #2 and groom him for the future. Is it Henson? Romo? A rookie or FA? Lock that in and prep that guy to be a snap away from the field.
RB- When JJ is healthy, he's a beast. But, he's not very healthy. I like Barber also. I still think you need a big RB for goalline gut situations. This could be a draft of FA situation also. I wouldn't go after a Jamal Lewis though. Maybe take a gamble on a guy who's been hurt, but not is looking for some playing time. A Duce Staley (ok...he's a bad example). basically, you gotta plan for JJ to miss a few games a year now, so keep and eye out for some depth there I don't know anything about your FB situation.
TE- Extend Witten....keep Campbell. That simple.
OL- Ok, you need new tackles. This should be a draft priority if you want your pass protection and running game to work. I'd even label this as the most important offseason topic for your front office. OL! OL! OL! There is no reason your QB should be sacked 7 times in a game. this would be a good RFA situation where you go after a guy from another team, and maybe it costs you a mid round pick, but you get a solid guy
WR- Keyshawn and Glenn are talented mofo's....but they aren't young. If you think a guy like Crayton is the future in a starting roll. You lock him up, if not. Then you go look for guys who can start, or will be ready in the next season or two. Somebody who can be mixed in to keep your vets fresh, but also get this guy some playing time. T.O. is not the answer for any team. If you guys want to go after him, its your funeral. I'd say this is a draft solution. Maybe the best WR you can get after you draft a tackle or two. The Steelers won't let Randel El go, but as a Skins fan...I'd love to steal that guy
DL- Are you staying with the 3-4? going back to the 4-3? What's the deal? I love your rookies. Maybe find a legit NT or whatever that spot is called in the middle of the line in a 3-4. Other than that, I'd go for depth.
LB- Is Dat done? I'd go the FA route to add some depth here....and bounce Barrow out. I could have told you guys he was done. He never took a snap for D.C. Also, in my world, I'd use Roy Williams as a tweener of LB and Safety more. I think he's so much better in run support than pass support.
CB- Henry is ok, I was never a fan. I'd look for a guy who's challenge for the #2 spot next to Newman who's been a stud a times. But Henry as the nickel would be excellent. this is where you find a guy who could play nickel/dime or a safety spot if needed
Safeties- You've got Roy....and then what? This should be a focus. I don't know where you find solid guys for this spot. We've got a reject from the Giants who came into his own here. I'm happy with Ryan Clark. I think a blue collar guy who knows how role would be good. He doesn't need to make a ton of INT's or cause a lot of fumble. Just make the clean tackle, and don't mess up. I'd look for 2 of these guys so I could have Roy lining up as a LB sometimes.
Kickers- You need a new one, 'nuff said.
I know it looks like I am suggesting a ton of turnover, but I'm not. Its mostly depth and planning for the future.
thoughts?