Which kicker would you rather have to win a playoff game tomorrow?

[big dog cowboy]

Remember when Tucker was considered the best kicker in the league? Has the torch been passed? Yup! Butter!!!

 

[CowboysLakerBamaFan]

Tucker is 34.

There's several younger kickers in the league now that are better

 

[CCBoy]

The current Cowboy's kicker...untouchable on accuracy and distance both. No returns as well.

 

[CTcowboy203]

Aubrey has been better this year and he may be the best in the league but I’d still take tucker in a huge spot until I see Aubrey so it (which I think he can)

 

[ATXSRT]

Have we tested Aubrey in weather / clutch conditions? The kicker from Eagles nailed that 60 yarder in insane wind and rain to send them to overtime and win. I love Aubrey but we haven't really been in a make it and win position yet I don't think - someone correct me if I'm wrong.

 

[John813]

Aubrey has been better this year and he may be the best in the league but I’d still take tucker in a huge spot until I see Aubrey so it (which I think he can)

Same. Beyond happy with Aubrey but kickers at some point will hit a rut. Some bounce back others don't and get cut to bounce around to find that groove again or not.
Tucker has been a great kicker over his career.
One thing I've noticed is he had a strong leg but the past two years he's missed 9 kicks from 50 yards out. Not sure if it was **** weather games or not but curious to see if that's a trend he can correct or not

 

[rambo2]

Remember when Tucker was considered the best kicker in the league? Has the torch been passed? Yup! Butter!!!

Remember the windy days in Oxnard when we were told that the Cowboys were cheap and didn't know what they were doing? Lol

 

[big dog cowboy]

Remember the windy days in Oxnard when we were told that the Cowboys were cheap and didn't know what they were doing? Lol

Oh gosh yes. Stingy Jerry not signing a vet was going to kill our season.

 

[Jake]

Tucker is 34.

There's several younger kickers in the league now that are better

Yeah, he's still pretty darn accurate but he's losing his long ball - only 1/5 from 50+ this year.

Aubrey is 9/9 from 50+. No one is outkicking him.

The only thing we don't know about Aubrey is playoff pressure. His team won the USFL title both years, but that's not quite like a full NFL stadium atmosphere.

 

[JBS]

Yeah, he's still pretty darn accurate but he's losing his long ball - only 1/5 from 50+ this year.

Aubrey is 9/9 from 50+. No one is outkicking him.

The only thing we don't know about Aubrey is playoff pressure. His team won the USFL title both years, but that's not quite like a full NFL stadium atmosphere.

Is he really 1/5 from 50+ ? Yikes

 

[Virginia-Dave]

Oh gosh yes. Stingy Jerry not signing a vet was going to kill our season.

Aubrey has been unbelievable, but don't act like you weren't cursing out loud when he missed his first XP attempt of the season. I thought we were screwed at kicker for the year!

 

[rambo2]

Aubrey has been unbelievable, but don't act like you weren't cursing out loud when he missed his first XP attempt of the season. I thought we were screwed at kicker for the year!

Lol

 

[Jason 82 Witten]

After that first missed extra point not one of us thought he would turn out to be as great as he has been. However, like most every other Cowboy player at one point, fans on here will eventually turn on him

 

[Clove]

I'm dying on the hill with the Cowboy player every time.

 

[Sarge]

There are cracks in the Tucker wall. No thanks.

 

[CCBoy]

Have we tested Aubrey in weather / clutch conditions? The kicker from Eagles nailed that 60 yarder in insane wind and rain to send them to overtime and win. I love Aubrey but we haven't really been in a make it and win position yet I don't think - someone correct me if I'm wrong.

You are right, immediately following a 60 + kick against the wind SHOULD immediately be tested,,,