Who Are Your Top O-Lineman?

[NeonDeion21]

List your order of the Top O-Lineman in the order you would draft them.

1. Tyron Smith
2. Gabe Carimi
3. Mike Pouncey
4. Anthony Castonozo
5. Nate Solder
6. Danny Watkins
7. Derrick Sherrod

 

[Gaede]

I'll go to 10

Gabe Carimi
Mike Pouncey
Derrick Sherrod
Tyron Smith
Marcus Cannon
Danny Watkins
Anthony Castonzo
Rodney Hudson
Steve Wisniewski
Nate Solder (really don't like him)

Woulda put Watkins alot higher, but if it's in the order I would draft him then I can't justify havin him over the other younger guys

 

[YosemiteSam]

I'll go to 10

Gabe Carimi
Mike Pouncey
Derrick Sherrod
Tyron Smith
Marcus Cannon
Danny Watkins
Anthony Castonzo
Rodney Hudson
Steve Wisniewski
Nate Solder (really don't like him)

Woulda put Watkins alot higher, but if it's in the order I would draft him then I can't justify havin him over the other younger guys

You realize you have a guard above some of the top tackles in the draft? Not only that, you have a guard above players that are better tackles than he is a guard. :bang2:

 

[Jongb35]

From my board:

OT
1. Tyron Smith USC
2. Ben Ijalana Villanova***
3. Anthony Castonzo Boston College
4. Gabe Carimi Wisconsin
5. Derek Sherrod Mississippi State
6. James Carpenter Alabama
7. Willie Smith East Carolina
8. Nate Solder Colorado
9. Joseph Barksdale LSU

G/C
1. Mike Pouncey Florida
2. Rodney Hudson FSU
3. Marcus Cannon, TCU
4. William Rackley Lehigh
5. Clint Boling Georgia
6. Danny Watkins Baylor
7. Jason Pinkston Pitt
8. DeMarcus Love Arkansas
9. Stefen Wiskiewski Penn State

Top 9 Combined
1. Smith
2. Ijalana
3. Castonzo
4. Carimi
5. Pouncey
6. Sherrod
7. Hudson
8. Cannon
9. Rackley

As you see, I'm really high on Ijalana. If he somehow fell to 40, I would be thrilled. I think he has OT/OG versatility.

 

[NeonDeion21]

I'm surprised how low Solder is on some lists.

 

[Arch Stanton]

This thread fails the Moffitt test.

 

[supercowboy8]

OT
Carimi
Smith
Castanzo
Sherrod
Carpenter

Sleepers
Jah Reid
Derek Newton

OG
Pouncey
Ijalana
Cannon
Watkins
Rackley
Franklin
Boling
Marcus Gilbert
Jason Pinkston
John Moffitt

 

[fortdick]

I'm surprised how low Solder is on some lists.

True, and I don't understand it, but what the heck, maybe we could get him in the second and grab and FS/DE in the first. Notice I said FS, cause if we take a CB, we will have to move someone to FS.

 

[Gaede]

You realize you have a guard above some of the top tackles in the draft? Not only that, you have a guard above players that are better tackles than he is a guard. :bang2:

OK dude, give it a shot. I thought I'd give it a try but I've clearly failed at giving an opinion

 

[funkytown]

1. Tyron Smith OT USC
2. Gabe Carimi OT Wisconsin
3. Anthony Castonzo OT Boston College
4. Mike Pouncey OG Florida
5. Nate Solder OT Colorodo
6. Derek Sherrod OT Mississippi
7. Danny Watkins G/T Baylor
8. Marcus Cannon G/T TCU
9. Ben Ijalana G/T Villanova
10.Rodney Hudson C/G Florida St.
11.Stephen Wisniewski C/G Penn St.

 

[TheCount]

True, and I don't understand it, but what the heck, maybe we could get him in the second and grab and FS/DE in the first. Notice I said FS, cause if we take a CB, we will have to move someone to FS.

Michael Huff! :laugh2:

 

[Chocolate Lab]

I'm surprised how low Solder is on some lists.

True, and I don't understand it, but what the heck, maybe we could get him in the second and grab and FS/DE in the first. Notice I said FS, cause if we take a CB, we will have to move someone to FS.

Somehow with Smith it's unlimited potential, but with Solder it's overrated athleticism.