You'll be happy to learn I was only half-kidding. Not even 1/2... probably 1/8. So I agree with your response. I agree with it more where actual rookies are concerned, but I agree with it nonetheless. You don't torture the inexperienced for even a handful of bad preseason plays. Especially when there are other plays that counterbalance. Have routinely cited, for instance, to Josh Ball haters the Archer column after preseason 2011, encouraging readers to not be too down on Tyron Smith for his mistakes so early in his career.