Who was the best Batman?

BrAinPaiNt

Mike Smith aka Backwoods Sexy
Staff member
Messages
78,654
Reaction score
43,000
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I don't consider Adam West in this since it was a different era and TV/Movies were so different. So I give him a pass.

Worst and Best

Clooney and Kilmer tie for worst Batman.
I don't mind clooney so much, like some of his movies and others I don't care for at all. I do like Val Kilmer in most of his work. But the thing is they were just not good as Batman. It does not help that those movies were terrible but they just did not pull it off as Batman IMO. I could flip flop on which one was worse or better between the two but I will stick with the tie.

Keaton and Bale tie for the best.

They just fit the role better IMO. Although I may lean more towards Bale as the movie was better and he has more of that tormented look.
 

HTownCowboysFan

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,940
Reaction score
71
Adam West was excellent for how the role was portrayed -- it was a spoof of comic books.

Bale is the best -- just nailed the part...both of them. Keaton was good. I think Keaton gets a lot of props because he was the first "serious" live-action Batman. Do you all remember the outrage when Keaton was cast back in '88! It was nuts!
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
HTownCowboysFan;1532365 said:
Adam West was excellent for how the role was portrayed -- it was a spoof of comic books.

Bale is the best -- just nailed the part...both of them. Keaton was good. I think Keaton gets a lot of props because he was the first "serious" live-action Batman. Do you all remember the outrage when Keaton was cast back in '88! It was nuts!

I don't know if it was really a spoof on comic books as much as it was just a spoof on life at the time. Ronald Reagan was then governor of California during the Adam West days. They had a bad guy that developed a weapon called the Ronnie Ray Gun.

That was some funny stuff in Cracked. The best line is "O'Donnell's an actor, in short, who makes one long for the playful, layered nuance of a Keanu Reeves performance." Ouch.

Joel Schumacher as director and whomever were the writers just did horrible jobs with Batman. It would not have mattered who was acting the part of Batman. Kilmer just seemed bored with the part and brought nothing to the character. Clooney does not pull off any type of tormented character. He just seems too happy. I bought Keaton as Bruce Wayne, but I did not see him as much of a Batman. Bale just seems to nail both characters.

I am impressed with Bale as an actor. Well, at least his dedication to his craft. This is from IMDB:

"Due to his part in Maquinista, El (2004) (aka The Machinist), Christian Bale was vastly underweight (about 120 pounds on his 6 foot+ frame) when he was under consideration for the part. After being cast, he was told to become as "big as you could be" by Christopher Nolan. Bale underwent a dietary and exercise regimen and ending up weighing about 220 pounds (about 40 pounds above his normal weight). It was decided that Bale had became too large (friends of his on the film's crew dubbed him "Fatman") and he quickly shed about 20 pounds to have leaner, more muscular frame."
 

carphalen5150

New Member
Messages
1,064
Reaction score
0
I like Kilmer, he was just wrong for the part. He was excellend in The Ghost and The Darkness.

His giant mole through me off too...he could of played Two-Face.:D
 

Concord

Mr. Buckeye
Messages
12,825
Reaction score
119
Danny White;1532328 said:
Cracked.com comes up with the definitive list... and it's damn funny, too!

http://www.cracked.com/index.php?name=News&sid=2111&pageid=1

Hey that's a good site.

Funny and plenty of articles to read.

This one (of Many) made me laugh...


Mr. Freeze uses his only superpower to turn the floor into an ice rink just as Batman and Robin are about to apprehend him. Luckily, our crimefighters yell "Batskates!", at which point, yes, Batskates pop out of their boots and they proceed to play ice hockey with Mr. Freeze's hockey stick-toting goons. Observant Batman fans might notice that being able to make things appear suddenly from the recesses of his body isn't Batman's power; it's Inspector Gadget's (or, failing that, Richard Gere's).

:laugh2:
 

Kevinicus

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,886
Reaction score
12,670
I think Batman Forever gets too much flak. It was an ok movie. Certainly very flawed, but watchable. And as bad as Batman and Robin was, it still isn't close to the horror that is Batman Returns. The original Batman is pretty dull as well.
 

Cochese

Benched
Messages
7,360
Reaction score
0
joseephuss;1532376 said:
I don't know if it was really a spoof on comic books as much as it was just a spoof on life at the time. Ronald Reagan was then governor of California during the Adam West days. They had a bad guy that developed a weapon called the Ronnie Ray Gun.

That was some funny stuff in Cracked. The best line is "O'Donnell's an actor, in short, who makes one long for the playful, layered nuance of a Keanu Reeves performance." Ouch.

Joel Schumacher as director and whomever were the writers just did horrible jobs with Batman. It would not have mattered who was acting the part of Batman. Kilmer just seemed bored with the part and brought nothing to the character. Clooney does not pull off any type of tormented character. He just seems too happy. I bought Keaton as Bruce Wayne, but I did not see him as much of a Batman. Bale just seems to nail both characters.

I am impressed with Bale as an actor. Well, at least his dedication to his craft. This is from IMDB:

"Due to his part in Maquinista, El (2004) (aka The Machinist), Christian Bale was vastly underweight (about 120 pounds on his 6 foot+ frame) when he was under consideration for the part. After being cast, he was told to become as "big as you could be" by Christopher Nolan. Bale underwent a dietary and exercise regimen and ending up weighing about 220 pounds (about 40 pounds above his normal weight). It was decided that Bale had became too large (friends of his on the film's crew dubbed him "Fatman") and he quickly shed about 20 pounds to have leaner, more muscular frame."


You should see the Machinist. Its an incredible film, and Bale is brilliant like he always is. He looks like he literally just came out of the concentration camp, its amazing he could get that big that fast to play the role of Batman.


Bale wins hands down, I just couldnt believe scrawny Keaton as THE Batman. He is a good actor, but probably was miscast in the role.
 

Cochese

Benched
Messages
7,360
Reaction score
0
BrAinPaiNt;1532359 said:
I don't consider Adam West in this since it was a different era and TV/Movies were so different. So I give him a pass.

Worst and Best

Clooney and Kilmer tie for worst Batman.
I don't mind clooney so much, like some of his movies and others I don't care for at all. I do like Val Kilmer in most of his work. But the thing is they were just not good as Batman. It does not help that those movies were terrible but they just did not pull it off as Batman IMO. I could flip flop on which one was worse or better between the two but I will stick with the tie.

Keaton and Bale tie for the best.

They just fit the role better IMO. Although I may lean more towards Bale as the movie was better and he has more of that tormented look.

I have respect for Clooney as he has said (well at least I have read) that he will personally refund anyones money who comes up to him and says they saw his horrible Batmovie in the theatres.
 

Big Dakota

New Member
Messages
11,876
Reaction score
0
Adam West #1

Funny read but not nearly as funny as watching Crispin Glover, ****:bang2:
 

HTownCowboysFan

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,940
Reaction score
71
I think Batman Forever gets too much flak. It was an ok movie. Certainly very flawed, but watchable. And as bad as Batman and Robin was, it still isn't close to the horror that is Batman Returns.

I've been ripping BATMAN RETURNS for years. That was nothing more that a Tim Burton film that just happened to include characters from the Batman universe. Geez, I HATE that film.
 

Crown Royal

Insulin Beware
Messages
14,229
Reaction score
6,383
ChldsPlay;1532983 said:
I think Batman Forever gets too much flak. It was an ok movie. Certainly very flawed, but watchable. And as bad as Batman and Robin was, it still isn't close to the horror that is Batman Returns. The original Batman is pretty dull as well.

HTownCowboysFan;1533055 said:
I've been ripping BATMAN RETURNS for years. That was nothing more that a Tim Burton film that just happened to include characters from the Batman universe. Geez, I HATE that film.

Pretty much agree with this. I enjoyed Batman Forever, not because of Batman, but because it was Jim Carrey at the Height of Jim Carrey Sweeps Hollywood. I watch it now, though, and I see a piece of Joel Schumacker garbage with funny pastel colors and a ******** new car.

As far as returns - it's amazing when I watch that how different it is from Batman. The Burton crap is just too thick - the Danny Elfman score that sounds like every other stupid Danny Elfman score, the snow/Christmastime motif that inundates all Burton movies, the Circus with scary clown people, another Burton favorite.

Burton was interesting for a small while, but I can walk into a Burton movie and recognize it immediately now. I hope he never makes another live action film.
 

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365
Staff member
Messages
62,330
Reaction score
64,032
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Cracked.com's rankings are dead on. To date, Bale's performance is the closest depiction of Bob Kane's creation. IMO, Batman Begins is the best DC movie adaptation of all-time.
 
Top