Who would you choose?

[RealCowboyfan]

Lavar Arrington Or Manny Lawson

Manny Lawson

LAVAR ARRINGTON DIDN'T SIGN WITH JAXSONVILLE JAGUARS TODAY..

 

[Cbz40]

Manny Lawson.......Build through the draft.

 

[DeaconMoss]

Lavar no question. If for no other reason he would try to decapitate every skin!

 

[neosapien23]

Lawson. Alot cheaper and alot younger.

 

[theogt]

I chose Arrington simply because he's proven he can be productive in the NFL. He's relatively young as well. Of course this is all pointless. Should have done a Lawson/Carpenter/Greenway poll.

 

[yeppers]

manny

 

[Rumor]

Depending on the scenario really...Win now or build? At this point, I would pick Lavar since he is experienced, even though he hasnt lived up to what I thought he would be and the whole attitude/free lance thing....but I would still have to go with him...I just feel manny would be good this year to play in the NFL....but will rise above that in his 2nd and third years...plus with Lavar you know what you get, manny has never played in the NFL...No matter how great in college there is always that chance they may bust...with manny that seems unlikely to me, but you never know...

 

[Rack]

Manny Lawson.


I'd also take Bobby Carpenter over Lavar Arrington.

 

[ghst187]

can I pick both?

 

[dannyboy]

I'd trade back and pick up a 3rd and draft Carpender

 

[Hostile]

Before I even look at the results, this one is going to be lopsided.

 

[Dalmations202]

As long as the idea is to win while Bill is here, Lavar Arrington over any questionable rookie.

 

[big dog cowboy]

Before I even look at the results, this one is going to be lopsided.

It's even worse than I thought.

 

[the kid 05]

mannt hes a freak! 40 time was what 4.43? thats like a bigger meaner randy moss and is on defense....the defensive line, if i were a qb i would be shivering if we had Dware and then manny fresh on the other side

 

[dbair1967]

I chose Arrington simply because he's proven he can be productive in the NFL. He's relatively young as well. .

when was the last time he was productive, 2002? 2001?

the guys been nothing but media hype since day one...one of the worst top-5 picks of the last ten years IMO

David

 

[theogt]

when was the last time he was productive, 2002? 2001?

the guys been nothing but media hype since day one...one of the worst top-5 picks of the last ten years IMO

David

One of the worst top-5 picks huh? Geez, how do you expect people take you seriously?

 

[dbair1967]

One of the worst top-5 picks huh? Geez, how do you expect people take you seriously?

people hyped him as an LT clone, and the guy has been an overrated, injury plagued knucklehead who makes as many dumb plays as good ones

at the time he was picked I thought it was a terrible pick because the Commanders were going to be a 4-3 defensive team, and to me drafting a 4-3 LB with that high of a pick is a waste...and I've been proven right...guy has not been an impact player...makes a few highlight film hits here and there, but for the most part he has been just another overhyped player

David

 

[theogt]

people hyped him as an LT clone, and the guy has been an overrated, injury plagued knucklehead who makes as many dumb plays as good ones

at the time he was picked I thought it was a terrible pick because the Commanders were going to be a 4-3 defensive team, and to me drafting a 4-3 LB with that high of a pick is a waste...and I've been proven right...guy has not been an impact player...makes a few highlight film hits here and there, but for the most part he has been just another overhyped player

David

I will certainly agree that he is/has been overhyped.

 

[DCowboyz]

LaVar is headed for Miami.. The Dolphins will get him.. There was some rumors for Arrington coming to the Cowboys, but that was just.. A rumor..

 

[juice28]

manny...easily