Why so much wringing of hands and gnashing of teeth?

bsbellomy

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,455
Reaction score
3,210
As he pointed out, he's a Giants fan. He has disincentive to post something hopeful here.

He also happens to be right. As for why the doom and gloom exists, I'd have to say it's one part the nature of fans and one part Cowboys fans collectively being a bunch of giant entitled babies. At least that's my best guess.

I don't think you can say he's right. I don't think it's a matter of fact that as a team we were not super bowl caliber. And we've basically destroyed that notion by our actions thus far.
 

bsbellomy

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,455
Reaction score
3,210
Here's why.

The team just went 13-3 and probably should have been in the NFC Champ game. We aren't the Browns or someone similar who is building up to something to where you can't look at things in terms of one season or two, rather, look 3-4 years down the road. The Cowboys, while still being young, are also in a win now mode. They were the #1 seed in the NFC last year. They return a talented roster that should make them a contender in 2017.

Now clearly there were flaws on the 2016 team. There was certainly opportunities to improve and make the team even better. Pass rush was obviously a big issue that needed fixing. And yes, the secondary while competent probably could have used some upgrading as well.

But the strategy seems to be what we see from bottom feeders............ rip it down and take a few years to build it up. Put all the eggs in the draft basket.

Personally, I wanted no parts of the entire secondary coming back. But I thought they'd let one of the CBs walk and let Church walk and then look to maybe bring in a good vet CB and then ok to the draft.

This idea that being a bit more aggressive in FA runs counter to the "long view" is silly. It just is. FA could have been used to add some decent pieces to where you don't have to put pressure on the FO to "nail" another draft.

And it's not even that we're not interested in overpaying. DJ Swearinger is a very good safety and he got 3 years 13 Mil. We're just not interested in spending ANY money.
 

iceberg

rock music matters
Messages
34,430
Reaction score
7,948
As many know, I am a Giants fan, but I am also a (best-that-I-can-be) objective observer of the sport, and I while I understand a lot of Cowboys fans' frustration with this offseason, I think that many are being entirely unreasonable and unfair to team management, and aren't taking the long view. In my opinion, I think that it is obvious that the Dallas front office has a clear plan, and I think it is a very good one.

The bottom line is that even though statistically the Cowboys defense looked pretty good this year, it was nowhere near as capable as the offensive side of the ball. I think that management has soberly concluded that while they will certainly try to win this year (and while somewhat depleted they still have the talent to do so) the defense needs to be rebuilt in order to be championship caliber -- and the Super Bowl is their ultimate goal.

They realize that they have three years remaining while BOTH Dak and Zeke are on their rookie deals. They know that they have to pay to keep the OL together. They know that Romo's money will be off the books soon no matter how that soap opera finally plays out. And they want to get away from having to play the salary cap credit card game, where restructuring is a way of life, and offseason flexibility is a dream that can only be realized by hamstringing tomorrow to some -- and often substantial -- degree.

So it makes complete sense to take a very possible slight step backwards in 2017 to set up very legitimate SB shots in 2018 and 2019. Take the year to capitalize from a ridiculously-deep DB draft and after a season of learning on the job have a talented, cost-controlled secondary that is better than last year's more expensive group. Add another pass rusher in April as well, and also use 2017 to develop the raw D-Line talent you have on the roster. And set yourself up cap-wise to ensure that you can stay strong into the future, even after you have to shell out the big bucks for Prescott and Elliott.

Could they have gone through the ridiculous cap machinations that some on this board have suggested in order to overpay FAs and gun for it this year? Sure. But so could EVERY other team in the league. And there is a reason that hardly anyone ever does it -- because it is just poor management if you want to establish a base for sustained success over a number of years.

So there is a method to the Cowboys' offseason madness. And I, for one, think it will serve Cowboy fans well, no matter how frustrated some may be now.

cause it's the off-season and every team just has a segment of fans that freaks out this time of year.

doesn't matter what happens, they freak.
 

Verdict

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,246
Reaction score
20,539
I guess I am in the minority but I don't see letting Church and Wilcox go as being all bad. I think Heath is better than both of them, he just hasn't been given the opportunity to play full time yet.

I would sort of like to see a short 1 year extension for Heath on the cheap. It would give Heath some security and the Cowboys an insurance policy for cheap labor going forward. Win/win.

The CB situation is a bit more tenuous. I don't want to force a pick on a CB. If that's BPA, sure, pull the trigger.

We have Brown, Scandrick and the Eagle. We might grab a CB in the top 5 rounds and call it a day at CB if we are confident in what we have and then sift through the UDFA scrap heap.

I wouldn't be surprised at all if we went RT, TE, WR or even Mixon in round one instead of CB or DE in a draft that is purportedly deep at both positions but not a lot of depth in top end talent at those positions.
 

Tenkamenin

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,605
Reaction score
4,026
The wringing of hands and gnashing of teeth is the result of our team looking a lot like the Romo years. Remember the years when Romo had to put this team on his back to keep us competitive owing to our crappy defense?
 

haleyrules

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,060
Reaction score
42,877
And how pathetically sad is that. Our defensive talent is the worst in the NFL right now.
Not the worst. Just not good enough. There is some talent that needs to be built on. You don't think Marinelli is a good talent?
 

JoeKing

Diehard
Messages
36,677
Reaction score
31,964
McCarthy made them 14 points better. The real difference was Coaching
I'm not disputing your point about the coaching, just curious now about the distribution on points here. If McCarthy made them 14 points better, what did we get right to only lose by 1?
 

haleyrules

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,060
Reaction score
42,877
I'm not disputing your point about the coaching, just curious now about the distribution on points here. If McCarthy made them 14 points better, what did we get right to only lose by 1?
Our offense was very competitive!! The defense put the club in a huge early hole. They came out slow and unprepared. The last possesion won and the D failed. The Cowboys were every bit as good overall team as the Packers. A great HC or great QB would have beaten Green Bay. Mc Carthy was a much more prepared HC and a tougher Leader than Garrett. Garrett had the better overall talent and should have won that game. IMMHO!
 

conner01

Well-Known Member
Messages
29,025
Reaction score
26,654
And how pathetically sad is that. Our defensive talent is the worst in the NFL right now.
I don't think it's the worst but I think it just got worse. That said the strength of this draft is secondary and wr. They signed Twill and that takes that away as a big priority. So my hope is they felt the talent in this draft lended itself to getting younger and better in the secondary
As long as there is a real plan and a thought process to the moves and not just about the money
 

Bleu Star

Bye Felicia!
Messages
33,925
Reaction score
19,920
As many know, I am a Giants fan, but I am also a (best-that-I-can-be) objective observer of the sport, and I while I understand a lot of Cowboys fans' frustration with this offseason, I think that many are being entirely unreasonable and unfair to team management, and aren't taking the long view. In my opinion, I think that it is obvious that the Dallas front office has a clear plan, and I think it is a very good one.

The bottom line is that even though statistically the Cowboys defense looked pretty good this year, it was nowhere near as capable as the offensive side of the ball. I think that management has soberly concluded that while they will certainly try to win this year (and while somewhat depleted they still have the talent to do so) the defense needs to be rebuilt in order to be championship caliber -- and the Super Bowl is their ultimate goal.

They realize that they have three years remaining while BOTH Dak and Zeke are on their rookie deals. They know that they have to pay to keep the OL together. They know that Romo's money will be off the books soon no matter how that soap opera finally plays out. And they want to get away from having to play the salary cap credit card game, where restructuring is a way of life, and offseason flexibility is a dream that can only be realized by hamstringing tomorrow to some -- and often substantial -- degree.

So it makes complete sense to take a very possible slight step backwards in 2017 to set up very legitimate SB shots in 2018 and 2019. Take the year to capitalize from a ridiculously-deep DB draft and after a season of learning on the job have a talented, cost-controlled secondary that is better than last year's more expensive group. Add another pass rusher in April as well, and also use 2017 to develop the raw D-Line talent you have on the roster. And set yourself up cap-wise to ensure that you can stay strong into the future, even after you have to shell out the big bucks for Prescott and Elliott.

Could they have gone through the ridiculous cap machinations that some on this board have suggested in order to overpay FAs and gun for it this year? Sure. But so could EVERY other team in the league. And there is a reason that hardly anyone ever does it -- because it is just poor management if you want to establish a base for sustained success over a number of years.

So there is a method to the Cowboys' offseason madness. And I, for one, think it will serve Cowboy fans well, no matter how frustrated some may be now.
Thank you.

They'll get it eventually.
 
Top