Will Mcfadden Win Heisman???

theogt

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
Avery;1818274 said:
Tebow can and should win as he's had the best season IMO. McFadden is a better prospect, but winning the Heisman doesn't guarantee success (see Crouch, Weinke, etc.)

Gimmick offense or not, if I have a QB who can pound the ball inside the five yard line for 6, I'll work him too.
Click to expand...
That's fair. It's hard not to confuse "best prospect" with "most productive college player."
 
Biggems

Biggems

White and Nerdy
Messages
14,327
Reaction score
2,254
No other college player has ever ran for 20 TDs and passed for 20 TDs in the same season.......Tebow is the 1st and only.

Tebow even did this with subpar RBs to give the ball to. Also, everyone knew he was gonna have the ball in his hands 90% of the offensive game and still couldn't stop him.

BTW, every offense is a gimmick offense and every defense is a gimmick defense. Some have better gimmicks than others. Some don't work unless you have a certain type of player to fit the scheme. Some are universally successful.

Tebow is the best college player this year hands down. McFadden is the best pro prospect this year, and I would have to say defensively the best prospect is Chris Long. Last year it was obviously Adrian Peterson on offense and Patrick Willis on defense.
 
dbair1967

dbair1967

Arch Defender
Messages
30,782
Reaction score
1
Avery;1818274 said:
Tebow can and should win as he's had the best season IMO. McFadden is a better prospect, but winning the Heisman doesn't guarantee success (see Crouch, Weinke, etc.)

Gimmick offense or not, if I have a QB who can pound the ball inside the five yard line for 6, I'll work him too.
Click to expand...

I dont watch Tebow and say "wow"

I watch McFadden, even when they play the best teams and say "wow"

McFadden has had back to back sensational years in the best conference (I know Tebow is SEC too) but the difference is I see Mcfadden carrying them to wins even against better teams...I dont see Tebow doing anything other than manning the station...UF has had tons of NFL talent, you cant say the same thing about Arkansas

David
 
Future

Future

Intramural Legend
Messages
27,566
Reaction score
14,714
dbair1967;1818264 said:
he's overrated because he plays in a gimmick offense and gets alot of tds on 1yd TD runs
David
Click to expand...

Darren McFadden plays in a gimmick offense as well. Brennan throws on every play...

Aren't like half of Emmit's td's under 5 yards?

50 touchdowns...i dont care if its a gimmick or not
 
smarta5150

smarta5150

Mr. Wright
Messages
7,163
Reaction score
0
dbair1967;1818262 said:
I think the opposite will happen/is true

Tebow will get it, but McFadden deserves it...he's the best player

Tebow is overrated IMO

David
Click to expand...

Overrated or not... he has done something no other QB has EVER done.
 
Rack

Rack

Federal Agent
Messages
23,906
Reaction score
3,106
I'm one of the biggest McFadden fans out there, but there's no doubt in my mind that Tebow should win the Heisman.
 
Hostile

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
I'd put my money on Tim Tebow for the Heisman, and Darren McFadden as the best player int he draft. The Heisman doesn't mean the best NFL prospect. It means who has the most gaudy stats from a big program school. That's Tebow.

My vote would be for McFadden (if I had a vote), but the realist in me knows what is more likely to happen.
 
Avery

Avery

The Dog that Saved Charleston
Messages
19,465
Reaction score
20,518
McFadden will always remember not winning the Heisman, but the amount of zeroes in his bank account this spring will definitely help.
 
Hoofbite

Hoofbite

Well-Known Member
Messages
40,865
Reaction score
11,566
dbair1967;1818262 said:
I think the opposite will happen/is true

Tebow will get it, but McFadden deserves it...he's the best player

Tebow is overrated IMO

David
Click to expand...

Thats what I was thinking. McFadden is by far the best player but Tebow will get it.
 
dbair1967

dbair1967

Arch Defender
Messages
30,782
Reaction score
1
smarta5150;1818335 said:
Overrated or not... he has done something no other QB has EVER done.
Click to expand...

thats because most teams use a RB to carry the ball in short yardage

David
 
Cowboy4ever

Cowboy4ever

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,189
Reaction score
4,494
I don't understand this ,, he got a lot of short runs for TD's argument against TT. Who got them down there to get the short run for the TD? Is a 1 yard TD run less valuable than a 60 yd td run? Tebow should win this award. He has had the best season. he as done something that NO other player has ever done. DMac for all his hype and praise has been inconsistant this year. I think he will be the first RB taken in the draft though but he does not deserve to win this award over TT.... and its not even close.
 
Biggems

Biggems

White and Nerdy
Messages
14,327
Reaction score
2,254
SibannacRex;1818789 said:
http://i94.***BLOCKED***/albums/l81/ATXHogan/tebowsgf.jpg
Click to expand...

i wonder if they can do the heisman stance........well at least Tebow has a place to mount his trophy....hehehehe
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top