Would you rather have Elliott, or Aaron Jones GB rb?

beware_d-ware said:
Have we ever lined Zeke up at WR and thrown him a jailbreak screen like Jones has?
Click to expand...
I think they have , a couple have gained good yardage. But nothing all the way.
the 2 big runs with jones were partly due to scheme and aaron making the right decision .
 
QuincyCarterEra said:
Zeke has had one elite season, right? That's less than a couple example you gave.

I'm not understanding your position.
Click to expand...
In 2 of 3 seasons Zeke has been second in total yds from scrimmage. The one season he wasn't, he missed 6 games but still was a top 10 rusher on that season. Zeke in year 4 is still producing at a high level and is still among league leaders in many categories, despite our increased down field passing game.

Jones is in year 3 and hasn't shown that same level of consistency, in 3 seasons, he's only broken 100yds from scrimmage a handful of times. Recency bias, Jones played great in his last game, but that doesn't mean he can sustain a high level of performance. Zeke has proved that he can, going on 4 seasons, not just a handful of games. Zeke is a great RB, right now we don't know what Jones really is. Will he be a great RB or just a good one or above average with a splash day every now and then?
 
Roadtrip635 said:
In 2 of 3 seasons Zeke has been second in total yds from scrimmage. The one season he wasn't, he missed 6 games but still was a top 10 rusher on that season. Zeke in year 4 is still producing at a high level and is still among league leaders in many categories, despite our increased down field passing game.

Jones is in year 3 and hasn't shown that same level of consistency, in 3 seasons, he's only broken 100yds from scrimmage a handful of times. Recency bias, Jones played great in his last game, but that doesn't mean he can sustain a high level of performance. Zeke has proved that he can, going on 4 seasons, not just a handful of games. Zeke is a great RB, right now we don't know what Jones really is. Will he be a great RB or just a good one or above average with a splash day every now and then?
Click to expand...

And in both those seasons he lead the league in touches, yet was only 2nd in scrimmage yards. Bit scrimmage yards doesnt really have anything to do with what I said. We were talking about elite seasons by players, Zeke's had one.

Don't think anyone would argue a season with averaging 4.1 yards per carry, or having more fumbles than rushing TDs are elite at all.
 
Proof said:
Zeke ran for 9 less yards his rookie season than this guy has run for in his career. let's not be prisoners of the moment.
Click to expand...
Well you seem to be a prisoner of stats.
I want a RB who can be a game changer and help win games, not one who just piles up meaningless yards each year.
Also one who can show up in playoff games.
I will admit due to our hc and his staff, elliot does not get a chance to do more like he probably could.
But elliot has shown poor vision and decisions when running, and sometimes runs into his own guys, as well as defenders.
That is why he has not broke even 1 long run for td this year or last year.
And why he only had 38 yds in the ram playoff game. but I guess you guys think 38 yards is elite yards lol.
 
QuincyCarterEra said:
Wait, you do know Zeke has lead the league in runningback fumbles two of his three seasons, right?
4.5 yards per carry isn't garbage, it's painfully average.

I did watch it, but far his best game of the season, and one of his best over the last three years. Doesn't excuse the much much much larger sample size.
Click to expand...

Emmitt Smith averaged more than 4.5 ypc only 3 times in his career. Was he painfully average? A 4.5 ypc is pretty good. Elliott has had two seasons with 1900+ yards from scrimmage. That is 2 elite seasons out of 3 played.

Elliott has a much larger sample size because he is good. They feed him the ball because he can handle the workload. That matters. Elliott is also a year younger than Jones.
 
Roadtrip635 said:
In 2 of 3 seasons Zeke has been second in total yds from scrimmage. The one season he wasn't, he missed 6 games but still was a top 10 rusher on that season. Zeke in year 4 is still producing at a high level and is still among league leaders in many categories, despite our increased down field passing game.

Jones is in year 3 and hasn't shown that same level of consistency, in 3 seasons, he's only broken 100yds from scrimmage a handful of times. Recency bias, Jones played great in his last game, but that doesn't mean he can sustain a high level of performance. Zeke has proved that he can, going on 4 seasons, not just a handful of games. Zeke is a great RB, right now we don't know what Jones really is. Will he be a great RB or just a good one or above average with a splash day every now and then?
Click to expand...
Well as in my other post, it isnt about yards, it is about helping your team to win close games.
What did elliot do in the NO game which was close. what about the jets game?
Gb won because of the 2 long td runs by jones, I dont know how many yds he had, it does not matter.
Can he sustain it, I dont know, it really only matters for this season.
So far I can say he was main reason GB beat Dallas and KC, 2 good teams, and that is not something you can say about elliot.
If he can avoid injury, he will be a factor in playoffs I think, but you never know.
 
joseephuss said:
Emmitt Smith averaged more than 4.5 ypc only 3 times in his career. Was he painfully average? A 4.5 ypc is pretty good. Elliott has had two seasons with 1900+ yards from scrimmage. That is 2 elite seasons out of 3 played.

Elliott has a much larger sample size because he is good. They feed him the ball because he can handle the workload. That matters. Elliott is also a year younger than Jones.
Click to expand...
Shows a lack of knowledge when comparing stats from players 2+ decades apart.

The top 10 rushers in 1995 averaged 4.0 yards per carry. This year? 4.9.

Adjust Elliott by .9 that's 3.6 yards per carry

Bulk stats like scrimmage yards shouldnt impress anyone, and doesn't make your elite that's for sure.

You might want to delete your post.
 
DandyDon52 said:
Well you seem to be a prisoner of stats.
I want a RB who can be a game changer and help win games, not one who just piles up meaningless yards each year.
Also one who can show up in playoff games.
I will admit due to our hc and his staff, elliot does not get a chance to do more like he probably could.
But elliot has shown poor vision and decisions when running, and sometimes runs into his own guys, as well as defenders.
That is why he has not broke even 1 long run for td this year or last year.
And why he only had 38 yds in the ram playoff game. but I guess you guys think 38 yards is elite yards lol.
Click to expand...


Weird rebuttal. Jones has never played in a playoff game. Has only run for more than 50 yards twice this yr. only cracked 100 yds 3 time in his career. He’s had two really nice games, as guys like ty Montgomery have done previously. He’s not special and zeke eats his lunch.
 
Jordan Howard, Jay Ajayi, Kareem Hunt......all flash in the pans that looked incredible as well. Consistency is what I’ll take.

Having said that Jones looks real good. He was the only player UTEP had.
 
QuincyCarterEra said:
This sort of thinking has literally zero correlation to Randle, don't grasp for straws so hard.

No, but if you think Zeke is elite then yes the league is littered with elite backs.
Click to expand...

The league is littered with guys who, in their first 3 years, led in yards per game? The league is littered with guys drop 2000 total yards in a year?

Dime a dozen in your book
 
phildadon86 said:
Lol Chubb? Compared to Zeke? You need to seek help my friend. Zeke is a top 3 back in this league. Admit it don’t admit it I don’t care. It’s the way it is
Click to expand...
It is weird how much you overvalue Zeke and undervalue Dak. A true enigma.
 
AbeBeta said:
The league is littered with guys who, in their first 3 years, led in yards per game? The league is littered with guys drop 2000 total yards in a year?

Dime a dozen in your book
Click to expand...

Yes, the league is littered with guys who could produce 2,000 yards if you give them the most touches in the league.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 96 more.
Total: 14,608 (members: 196, guests: 14,412)
Robots: 1,255

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,577
Messages
14,546,358
Members
24,212
Latest member
JerryJonesSupporter
Back
Top