Yakuza Rich: Thoughts on the NFC East Happenings

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
It's on my blog, thought some may be interested, if not...bleh.

Thoughts on the NFC East Happenings
by Yakuza Rich
http://yakuzarich.blogspot.com/

---DallasCowboys.com reports that:

Starting cornerback Terence Newman likely will miss the remainder of the
preseason, according to Cowboys head coach Wade Phillips, but still should be
available for the Sept. 9 season opener against the Giants


There's a cause for concern here because obviously Newman is an excellent cornerback. But the other issue is that he plays the slot position in the nickel as well. A lot of fans and even writers posing as "experts" like to believe that because Newman plays the slot in the nickel it makes him a lesser defender, but in reality it makes him a more valuable commodity given the difficulty of the position, mainly stemming from being unable to use the sideline as an extra defender. And it's not like teams are opposed to putting their #1 WR in the slot position against an opposing team's #3 corner to get the mismatch in their favor. The Bucs have used Rhonde Barber in this fashion for years and the Cardinals signed Roderick Hood for this specific reason as well.

I always get a little cautious when I hear of injuries like this as in the past, especially in the Parcells era, the Cowboys had a nasty habit of initially underreporting an injury only to find out it was something really serious. Last year with Terry Glenn was one of the few times where they reported an injury pretty seriously from the start, only to find out that he would just miss a couple of games.

I probably wouldn't be too worried though since the goal of this preseason under Phillips has been keeping the starters healthy from the onset. But this does raise a point for next year's draft with Anthony Henry turning 31, Newman turning 30, and Aaron Glenn turning 36 years old. I've like Jacques Reeves, but he may not be to Phillips' liking. Of course Dallas does have two first rounders, but I'd be surprised if Julius Jones sticks around (at best he plays pretty well and asks for too much $$$$ for his services).

Darren McFadden appears to be the favorite for Cowboys fans and I can't blame them, but there's a long season ahead. Cleveland still has to be pretty bad adn McFadden can't get hurt too bad. Even if Cleveland finishes 6-10, Dallas may have a shot at McFadden because nobody really thought Adrian Peterson would go past the #3 spot at this time last year and he wound up going to the 6-10 Vikings. But if there's a cornerback that is just as good, can you blame Dallas for taking them? And what if there are serious questions about McFadden's attitude and work ethic (I have no idea what they are, but this could happen)? There's no guarantees in the NFL and there are certainly no guarantees come draft time.


----Commanders.com reports:

Head coach Joe Gibbs confirmed on Thursday that the team is close to trading for
12-year veteran offensive lineman Pete Kendall from the New York Jets



The reports have that they'll trade Kendall for a 4th rounder. You'll get two sides of this argument as either being "great trade for the Skins!" or "another stupid free agent trade by the Skins" depending whom you talk to.

I'd lean towards the former for them because their O-Line has looked horrible in preseason. Randy Thomas has played like his usual self, but Rabach stinks and the normally reliable Jon Jansen has been horrific. Stephon Heyer, filling in for the injured Chris Samuels, has been worse and Todd Wade at left guard has been a disaster. And sadly for them it's only been preseason. With Kendall they should solidify the left guard spot for now as Wade was a bust at the position. Samuels will come back and if he's not right or if Jansen still stinks they can at least put Wade at either position, but he's really only a right tackle in this league. It was a desperate move, but still a good one and I figure they felt that losing a 4th rounder in order to better protect their young QB was worth it.

Kendall has been really good at guard the past 3 years (he did play some center in 2005 and struggled), but he's 34 years old and I question how quickly he'll adjust to a new system so late in the year. But I can't really blame them for taking a stab at it. It does make clear that the Skins will have to address all of their starters on the O-Line in the next year or so because they are at least 30 years old and Thomas, Jansen, and Samuels have had some injury issues in the past. (Just an FYI - Kendall finished 9th at left guard in my statistical O-Line rankings last season)


---- Got this from http://mvn.com/nfl-eagles/2007/08/15/how-serious-is-shawn-andrews-injury/ on the Eagles:

Via ProFootballTalk.com comes a link to a strange sidebar on a
ComcastSportsNet.com story about the Eagles’ defense that adds more mystery
to Shawn Andrews’ ankle injury. Andrews was apparently evasive in answering any
question about the extent of his injury, but said that his meeting with a
medical specialist was a “tear-jerker,” wouldn’t comment on whether the injury
was season- or career-threatening, and wouldn’t directly answer if he would be
ready for the season opener. Instead, he said, ““I don’t know what the future
holds.”



Andrews made my All Pro team last year as he was truly a dominant blocker. He was overrated in 2005 as he ballooned up to 385 pounds and at times was pretty immobile out there, but he got motivated and dropped about 50 pounds last year and reminded me a lot of a young Larry Allen. If he's gone, that will put a big dent into the Eagles running game. The Eagles like their O-Line depth, but Todd Herremanns isn't exactly a world beater, so if backup Max Jean-Gilles was better than him, he'd be starting.

The one thing that scares me a bit about the Eagles is that if they finally get into balancing their run and pass attack, they could be a dangerous team. This league is built on winning the passing game battle, but you still need a running game to maintain your leads and put games away. Up until last year, Andy Reid never fully understood it and it has haunted the Eagles for years.

With all of that being said, this NEWZ comes from profootballtalk.com, which the chasm between what they report and the truth is so wide that Evil Knievel would fail to jump across it.


- I've been following the Giants a bit closer this preseason since the Cowboys open with them. The O-Line has looked pretty good so far and Eli played pretty well against the Ravens who run a similar 3-4 to what Wade runs. They've got a lot of injuries, but from what I've been told and what I've read I think you'll see a different kind of offense in New York this year. Former O-Coordinator Jim Hufnagel loved to do two things, throw it deep and throw the screen pass. The Giants threw the most screen passes in the game last year. Under new O-Coordinator Kevin Gilbride and the loss of Tiki Barber, I expect more no huddle offenses to keep defenses off balance and much more 3 step drops from Eli.

While the Giants situation doesn't look good this year, September 9th shouldn't be a cakewalk as the Giants have started each season 5-2 under Tom Coughlin. They are very good out of the gate, but as the season goes along they can't make adjustments.


- Dallas faces 4 teams in preseason that either use the Cover 2 as their base defense or it's their most used coverage shell. That should come in handy against the 5 full time Cover 2 teams they face this year (Buffalo, Minnesota, Chicago, Green Bay, and Detroit) along with other teams that love to use the Cover 2 like the Giants, Commanders (who may be getting away from that this year), and St. Louis.




YAKUZA
 

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
skinsfunguy;1602059 said:
Nicely written for the most part. Casey Rabach hardly stinks though. He has been a very good center for us.

Nah, he's terrible. Horrible in pass coverage, makes a lot of penalties, and being surrounded Thomas and then Dockery along with having Portis and Betts as tailbacks has carried him. He's not a complete liability, but he's hardly good.




YAKUZA
 

skinsfunguy

New Member
Messages
268
Reaction score
0
Yakuza Rich;1602071 said:
Nah, he's terrible. Horrible in pass coverage, makes a lot of penalties, and being surrounded Thomas and then Dockery along with having Portis and Betts as tailbacks has carried him. He's not a complete liability, but he's hardly good.




YAKUZA

Gonna have to disagree with you on that. He used to have a problem with penalties but that seems to be in his past now.

One thing I really like about him alot is his smarts. He does a great job of reading defensive packages and making adjustments accordingly.
 

WR17

Benched
Messages
139
Reaction score
0
Yakuza Rich;1602071 said:
Nah, he's terrible. Horrible in pass coverage, makes a lot of penalties, and being surrounded Thomas and then Dockery along with having Portis and Betts as tailbacks has carried him. He's not a complete liability, but he's hardly good.




YAKUZA

Thats surprising. The Skins offensive line has been amazing for the past two seasons. I remmember one stinker by Casey which was against the Chargers where he negated a 15 or 20 yard run by Portis with a hold, thats a play that would have sealed the game for us with a W and the division title.

So if Casey is terrible, who are the strong holds of the line? I know Thomas and Samuels are both awesome. Dockery was solid but Jansen was a stinker last season. Just wondering, what was the reason the Skins were so good up front while having two stink bombs like Casey and Jansen?

Personally, I love Rabach. Hes a smart guy who gets the job done week in week out. Hes the center of a line that had one of the best rushing attacks last season and gave up the least sacks in the NFC. I'm really surprised by this.
 

AmishGangsta

Member
Messages
710
Reaction score
0
skinsfunguy;1602083 said:
Gonna have to disagree with you on that. He used to have a problem with penalties but that seems to be in his past now.

One thing I really like about him alot is his smarts. He does a great job of reading defensive packages and making adjustments accordingly.

Nah, I think he was among the league leaders, I'm pretty sure Mr Yakuza must have ran across this link:

http://www.footballoutsiders.com/2007/08/07/ramblings/stat-analysis/5289/ Lists a bunch of lineman and a TE suprisingly Jason Witten, who lead the league in penalties. I think that goes to show that, even some of the leagues best get penalized. :)

Here's a quote from Ray Brown on Rabach, I found interesting:

"I think his awareness of when guys need help and where he needs to lean the protection is really key," Brown said. "I thought he was a Pro Bowl player last year. He came on like gangbusters and was locking guys up. Very few better than him come to mind. Immediately at center I think of Olin Kreutz [who has been to six straight Pro Bowls with Chicago], but Casey is actually a bigger guy, he runs just as well, he's great out in space and he could probably be a heck of a guard if he had to."
 

TunaFan33

Benched
Messages
1,824
Reaction score
0
AmishGangsta;1602102 said:
Nah, I think he was among the league leaders, I'm pretty sure Mr Yakuza must have ran across this link:

http://www.footballoutsiders.com/2007/08/07/ramblings/stat-analysis/5289/ Lists a bunch of lineman and a TE suprisingly Jason Witten, who lead the league in penalties. :)

Speaking of which-that penalty in the Chargers game was unecessary too-whether or not he held that DL, Portis was running way on the right and away from the play nonetheless.
 

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
AmishGangsta;1602102 said:
Nah, I think he was among the league leaders, I'm pretty sure Mr Yakuza must have ran across this link:

http://www.footballoutsiders.com/2007/08/07/ramblings/stat-analysis/5289/ Lists a bunch of lineman and a TE suprisingly Jason Witten, who lead the league in penalties. I think that goes to show that, even some of the leagues best get penalized. :)

Witten has actually been a poor blocking TE the past two years. He blocked pretty well his rookie year, but I don't know what happeneed. Supposedly he's blocking much better this training camp/preseason.

Rabach was second in penalties for starting centers in 2005, only behind Robbie Tobeck who had an absurd amount of penalties that year. I don't have all of the stats for starting centers for 2006, but I recall him being in the latter half of penalty yards allowed again.

A couple of friends of mine work as coaches, one used to work in D-Iaa college and one in high school and when we watch games (we usually catch Cowboys, Bears and Commanders games), Rabach usually stands out as being a mediocre center. In fact we often discussed how bad the NFC East centers were when they were Hank Fraley, Al Johnson, Rabach, and Shaun O'Hara. Now with Jammal Jackson and Gurode into the fold things have gotten better. I don't think my eyes are fooling me, but those friends know a lot more about football than I do (one of them is an O-Line coach) and if they are agreeing with my sentiment and there's stats to back it up, that usually works for me.



YAKUZA
 

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
WR17;1602100 said:
Thats surprising. The Skins offensive line has been amazing for the past two seasons. I remmember one stinker by Casey which was against the Chargers where he negated a 15 or 20 yard run by Portis with a hold, thats a play that would have sealed the game for us with a W and the division title.

The O-line wasn't awesome in 2005. It was pretty good that year and excellent in 2006. They started off a little slow in 2005 and then came along nicely, although they were miserable once Randy Thomas went down.

So if Casey is terrible, who are the strong holds of the line? I know Thomas and Samuels are both awesome. Dockery was solid but Jansen was a stinker last season. Just wondering, what was the reason the Skins were so good up front while having two stink bombs like Casey and Jansen?

Jansen only started out rough, but came along well. Dockery is a rare bird because he's big and athletic, but struggles in pass protection. But since he's a guard it's tough for teams to take too much advantage of that. His technique blows, but he's so big and mobile he has been fantastic the past two years at getting in the way of defenders. In fact, ESPN's KC Joyner had Dockery with a 90+% run block success in 2005, which is extremely high.

I compare Samuels to Ivan Lendl (former pro tennis player). People pretty much knew Lendl was a good tennis player, but they never really fully appreciated his skill in my mind because he wasn't really flashy. I think the problem with Samuels is that he had such high expectations out of college (he was known for never allowing a sack in HS or in College) and he's usually good for about 2 bad games a year, which is pretty normal for even the best left tackles in the game figuring you can face guys like DeMarcus Ware, Dwight Freeney, and Umenyiora in one season. But overall, Samuels is darn near excellent.

Thomas has superb technique and is a solid athlete. The only thing seperating him from somebody like Shawn Andrews, Vince Manuwai or Steve Hutchinson is those guys have surreal athletic ability, but he's still a really good/great guard.

Jansen hardly stunk last year, he only gave up 4 sacks last year when the league average is around 7 for starters.





YAKUZA
 
Top