Lawrence vs Fields vs Wilson

[Shunpike]

How would you rank them and why?

For me it is as below

Wilson
Lawrence
Fields

Wilson has accuracy, processing speed and insane arm. His upside is Mahomes low side Matt Ryan

 

[cnuball21]

How would you rank them and why?

For me it is as below

Wilson
Lawrence
Fields




Wilson has accuracy, processing speed and insane arm. His upside is Mahomes low side Matt Ryan

Lawrence by about 10 slots

Wilson
Fields

 

[RS12]

Wilson stock is really rising in the eyes of many personnel people in the league. Some like him better than Lawrence. Wilson goes no lower than number 2 overall

 

[Future]

He is absolutely nothing like Matt Ryan lol

 

[CATCH17]

Lawrence

Wilson

Fields


There is clear separation between all 3. Fields turned out about like I thought he would before the season when a lot of people were telling me he was better than Lawrence.

 

[CATCH17]

Wilson stock is really rising in the eyes of many personnel people in the league. Some like him better than Lawrence. Wilson goes no lower than number 2 overall

Wilson has acquired the most skill coming into the league of all these guys imo.

I wish Dallas could find a way to get him.

 

[stilltheguru]

Wilson is lucky you cant really hit qbs anymore but even then I still think he'll be injury prone

 

[DFWJC]

How would you rank them and why?

For me it is as below

Wilson
Lawrence
Fields

Wilson has accuracy, processing speed and insane arm. His upside is Mahomes low side Matt Ryan

 

[baltcowboy]

How would you rank them and why?

For me it is as below

Wilson
Lawrence
Fields

Wilson has accuracy, processing speed and insane arm. His upside is Mahomes low side Matt Ryan

Wilson played with a bunch of scrubs and is a pinpoint passer. I am concerned about him because he did not play well against Coastal Carolina.

Lawrence is the best prospect because of his size and arm strength but he is skinny. I believe he injured his shoulder against Ohio St. He seems to crumble when pressured like last season against LSU.

Fields is so underrated by this board. He lit Clemson up and looked like the best quarterback on the field throwing the football. The Ohio St offense concerns me because it is so simple.

I believe all three quarterbacks will do well but it depends on what team drafts them. Fields would be great in a Cowboys uniform.

 

[CATCH17]

Wilson played with a bunch of scrubs and is a pinpoint passer. I am concerned about him because he did not play well against Coastal Carolina.

Lawrence is the best prospect because of his size and arm strength but he is skinny. I believe he injured his shoulder against Ohio St. He seems to crumble when pressured like last season against LSU.

Fields is so underrated by this board. He lit Clemson up and looked like the best quarterback on the field throwing the football. The Ohio St offense concerns me because it is so simple.

I believe all three quarterbacks will do well but it depends on what team drafts them. Fields would be great in a Cowboys uniform.

Fields would be like replacing Dak with Dak.. It’s a lateral move.. I’m not against it for monetary reasons but he is a see guy open and then throw type of player.. Slow in his progressions.


Lawrence and Wilson have the potential to carry teams. Fields is a guy who will just be along for the ride.

I think Lance may end up going ahead of Fields too because there is just more upside there.

Fields is a very safe choice though I do believe. High floor.

 

[Sydla]

Anyone who doesn't have Lawrence #1............... LOL

That's not to say Wilson can't be a good QB but Lawrence is just a different type of prospect.

 

[Sydla]

Fields would be like replacing Dak with Dak.. It’s a lateral move.. I’m not against it for monetary reasons but he is a see guy open and then throw type of player.. Slow in his progressions.


Lawrence and Wilson have the potential to carry teams. Fields is a guy who will just be along for the ride.

I think Lance may end up going ahead of Fields too because there is just more upside there.

Fields is a very safe choice though I do believe. High floor.

I don't know........... Fields seems like the riskiest choice. He can be all over the map. Every talks about his performance in the playoffs but forget how brutal he was in games during the regular season.

 

[CATCH17]

I don't know........... Fields seems like the riskiest choice. He can be all over the map. Every talks about his performance in the playoffs but forget how brutal he was in games during the regular season.

He’s got a great deep ball..

He can run..

He makes a lot of conservative throws.

I think it just depends who drafts him..Like imagine him with Shannahan and the bootlegs they could do off that zone scheme...

 

[baltcowboy]

Fields would be like replacing Dak with Dak.. It’s a lateral move.. I’m not against it for monetary reasons but he is a see guy open and then throw type of player.. Slow in his progressions.


Lawrence and Wilson have the potential to carry teams. Fields is a guy who will just be along for the ride.

I think Lance may end up going ahead of Fields too because there is just more upside there.

Fields is a very safe choice though I do believe. High floor.

Lance just has not played enough football for me to risk a pick on him. Our team is built for a pocket passer. Lance has along way to go.

 

[CATCH17]

Lance just has not played enough football for me to risk a pick on him. Our team is built for a pocket passer. Lance has along way to go.

NFL is all about taking risks..

Those who play it safe get safe results.

 

[beware_d-ware]

IMO - Fields is a monster and would go #1 in any draft that didn't have Lawrence. He reminds me almost of Vince Young physically, and is much more polished than he gets credit for. Rotoworld did a good breakdown here showing the kind of reads he was still making even with pockets falling apart around him.

I wrote yesterday how athleticism is getting to be a trump card for NFL QBs, and how flaws in college like poor accuracy or gimmicky schemes just don't seem to matter any more if you're physically talented enough. Fields has all the talent in the world and comes with better accuracy and football IQ than most. He is exactly what teams want right now.

 

[fivetwos]

How would you rank them and why?

For me it is as below

Wilson
Lawrence
Fields

Wilson has accuracy, processing speed and insane arm. His upside is Mahomes low side Matt Ryan

This allows zero shot for him to bust, which just isn't true.

I like him, but Dallas just isn't going this route.

 

[beware_d-ware]

Forgot to edit in the Rotoworld article on Fields, it's here.

https://www.nbcsports.com/edge/article/qb-klassroom/qb-klassroom-ohio-state-qb-justin-fields-1

 

[fivetwos]

Wilson has acquired the most skill coming into the league of all these guys imo.

I wish Dallas could find a way to get him.

There's definitely a way.

That would involve Prescott wanting to go to the Jets and the Jets being willing to pay him.....AND Jerry wanting to do this.

The Jets aren't going to deal for an unhappy player, so it couldn't be done without everyone on board.

IMO Dallas would get an additional first as well as pick #2 in this draft.

Why in the world the Jets would do this instead of taking Wilson themselves makes little sense, but they were reportedly ready to part with multiple firsts to get Watson.

Houston doesn't seem willing to deal Watson at this point, so I'm sure the Jets called Dallas as a fallback plan....and I'm sure of what they were told.

I admit I'd prefer to keep Dak, but this scenario would far from upset me.

They would have to deal with having a rookie QB, but they would have the resources to fix the rest of the team in this case.......I just don't see Jerry entertaining something like this under any circumstance.

 

[CATCH17]

There's definitely a way.

That would involve Prescott wanting to go to the Jets and the Jets being willing to pay him.....AND Jerry wanting to do this.

The Jets aren't going to deal for an unhappy player, so it couldn't be done without everyone on board.

IMO Dallas would get an additional first as well as pick #2 in this draft.

Why in the world the Jets would do this instead of taking Wilson themselves makes little sense, but they were reportedly ready to part with multiple firsts to get Watson.

Houston doesn't seem willing to deal Watson at this point, so I'm sure the Jets called Dallas as a fallback plan....and I'm sure of what they were told.

I admit I'd prefer to keep Dak, but this scenario would far from upset me.

They would have to deal with having a rookie QB, but they would have the resources to fix the rest of the team in this case.......I just don't see Jerry entertaining something like this under any circumstance.

I just don’t get why a team would rather have Dak at his price tag vs Darnold or Wilson at his.

I don’t think a real NFL team values Dak like Cowboy fans do.