So you believe your analogy with playing a instrument is equivalent to the first week of OTA's?
Yes. Yes I do. OTA's are mini workouts, right? a bit of drilling in "pretending"...if you will. Now me? WOuld I be able to tell an NFL players status in OTA's? No, Of course not. An NFL professional observer should be able to tell.
I wouldn't expect a non-guitar player to know what I know about it. The way you shoulder or hold a guitar. The way the fingers and wrist move to play notes. Just the way you look...or not look...at the fretboard. Without even playing one note.
OTA's = holding/handling a guitar
real NFL game = playing a full song with a band.
So yes...I fully stand by my analogy.