I know we are all anti- Big Mike right now

[JW82]

But at what point do we say Mike carried a perpetual big game loser like Rodgers to multiple championship games and a Super Bowl win? I am being sarcastic, BUT it is factual.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Rodgers has been to multiple NFC championship games without McCarthy though.

McCarthy hasn't won a playoff game since he left Rodgers.

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

He’s making championship games without MM though. I think the defense in 2010 is what won them that Super Bowl. Charles Woodson was insane that year

 

[JW82]

Rodgers has been to multiple NFC championship games without McCarthy though.

McCarthy hasn't won a playoff game since he left Rodgers.

zero rings. Home loss after home loss. Mikes coached one full season with a starting qb since he left.

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

zero rings. Home loss after home loss. Mikes coached one full season with a starting qb since he left.

They both have 0 SB appearance in over a decade. Do you really believe McCarthy was carrying Rodgers?

Does that make Lafleur the coaching deity for what he’s done?

 

[JW82]

I am not convinced we will win with Mike. I just Wanted to point this out since I have heard a million times how Mike only won because of Rodgers. Which of course can be said about almost every SB winning coach.

 

[CATCH17]

McCarthy isn’t a real factor either way and he’s better than Garrett.


The owner who will sign any check that would help us win stops short at signing a check for a top quality coach.


Unless something changes I think we just all need to take The Who cares approach with this team because they’re probably going to give us a status quo off-season and do nothing.

Jerry his doing his I’m not happy dance to act like he relates to fans but he will do nothing.

Our biggest hope I guess going forward would be Sean Payton sitting out a year and then coaching us after the year is over but if he wants money do you think Jerry will compete or keep paying McCarthy nothing to coach his team?

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

zero rings. Home loss after home loss. Mikes coached one full season with a starting qb since he left.

Green Bay is 41-13 in the 3 years since McCarthy was fired.

Them and Rodgers are okay without Mike.

 

[_sturt_]

I'm not. I think sober non-emotional people, the kind who value slow conclusions and thorough assessment realize that this topic is low-hanging fruit subject to shallow knee-jerk reactions, and especially among people who use sports in order to have something in their lives where they can feel superior and inject dopamine into their systems.

McC can win. But it's called a "team" sport because of the obvious.

This team had great talent. But sometimes there's a weak link that cannot be overcome in spite of adequate-to-good coaching and good talent all over the roster.

This one is at least as much on the people who didn't solve the LG and C weak link before the trade deadline as it is on anyone else.

 

[G2]

McCarthy isn’t a real factor either way and he’s better than Garrett.


The owner who will sign any check that would help us win stops short at signing a check for a top quality coach.


Unless something changes I think we just all need to take The Who cares approach with this team because they’re probably going to give us a status quo off-season and do nothing.

Jerry his doing his I’m not happy dance to act like he relates to fans but he will do nothing.

Our biggest hope I guess going forward would be Sean Payton sitting out a year and then coaching us after the year is over but if he wants money do you think Jerry will compete or keep paying McCarthy nothing to coach his team?

Who didn't he sign a bigger check to that was available?

 

[JBS]

Rodgers has been to multiple NFC championship games without McCarthy though.

McCarthy hasn't won a playoff game since he left Rodgers.

Making championship games and losing all of them isn’t anything to write home about

 

[CATCH17]

Who didn't he sign a bigger check to that was available?

It’s not just McCarthy. Jerry has always been this way.

The only time he went for a real coach is when he needed a stadium to be built.

 

[SDCowboy]

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Making championship games and losing all of them isn’t anything to write home about

I would take that over what we've had the past quarter of a century.

 

[big dog cowboy]

But at what point do we say Mike carried a perpetual big game loser like Rodgers to multiple championship games and a Super Bowl win? I am being sarcastic, BUT it is factual.

True, but it's the same Mike that A-Rod ran out of town.

 

[SlammedZero]

But at what point do we say Mike carried a perpetual big game loser like Rodgers to multiple championship games and a Super Bowl win? I am being sarcastic, BUT it is factual.

And on the other end of the spectrum, since so many people believe Dak is the worst starting QB in the league, at what point do we say Mike carried a perpetual big game loser like Dak to a 12-5 record and a playoff appearance?

 

[LittleD]

But at what point do we say Mike carried a perpetual big game loser like Rodgers to multiple championship games and a Super Bowl win? I am being sarcastic, BUT it is factual.

You really meant "Fat Butt Mike" didn't you. Mom always told me "Lazy Is as Lazy Does".

 

[JBS]

I would take that over what we've had the past quarter of a century.

No you wouldn’t

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

No you wouldn’t

Yes. I would.

 

[G2]

It’s not just McCarthy. Jerry has always been this way.

The only time he went for a real coach is when he needed a stadium to be built.

I was just curious as to who you were talking about.