Kiper's favorite prospect at each position

Risen Star

Likes Collector
Messages
92,809
Reaction score
225,704
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
* Any criticism of Mel will be reported.

Take it away, your hairness.

-

This is not a list of the best overall prospects in the 2022 class nor is it a list of the guys I consider the best at each position. These are the prospects whom I've:

  • Often rated higher than other evaluators within the draft media or than team evaluators with whom I discuss prospects, or ...

  • Ranked higher in close debates within position groups, or ...

  • Watched and rewatched on tape, just because I like the way they play the game.


Quarterback

i

Malik Willis, Liberty
Willis is electric with the ball in his hands and has a cannon for an arm. What's not to like? He didn't play with much NFL talent in college, but he made everyone around him better. He took an FBS-high 51 sacks last season -- some were because he held on to the ball too long -- and still finished with 878 rushing yards (yes, college football still counts sacks as negative yards for quarterbacks).

Willis took a leap forward as a passer in 2021, even with a trio of three-interception games. He had 63 plays of 20-plus yards over the past two seasons, which ranked seventh in the country. He is extremely accurate when he gets outside the pocket. Again, he did this at Liberty, which doesn't have any other draft picks in this class. Like any young quarterback, Willis needs to go to a team with talent around him (Pittsburgh?) to be at his best. But he has the highest ceiling of all the 2022 signal-callers.

Projection: I think he's going to land in the top 10, maybe for a team trading up to get him.


Running back
i

Pierre Strong Jr., South Dakota State
I mentioned Strong as an under-the-radar prospect everyone should know back in September, after he looked great in wins over Colorado State and Indiana State. He finished the season with 1,673 rushing yards and 18 scores while averaging 7.0 yards per carry. He has great balance through the hole, can hold his own in pass protection and was durable for the Jackrabbits.

Strong is really good at most everything. He impressed at the combine, too, running a 4.37-second 40-yard dash at 5-foot-11, 207 pounds.

Projection: Strong is going to be drafted late on Day 2 or early on Day 3, and I really think he could be a steal. He has a chance to be a starter in the NFL in the right situation (and given a little time to adjust).

Wide receiver
i

Alec Pierce, Cincinnati
Pierce probably isn't going in Round 1, but it wouldn't totally shock me if he sneaks into the top 32 picks. He has the physical traits that could make a team fall in love with him. He ran a 4.41 40 and had a 40.5-inch vertical at the combine. Pierce isn't just a workout warrior, though; he averaged 17 yards per catch, scored eight touchdowns and was one of the best vertical threats in the country last season. He's going to run by defensive backs at the next level.

I also thought about Western Michigan's Skyy Moore here. He's only 5-foot-10, but he had the biggest hands of any receiver at the combine. He's dynamic after the catch.

Projection: I comped Pierce to Jordy Nelson, and Pierce could go right around where Nelson did in the 2008 draft (No. 36 overall).


Offensive tackle
i

Trevor Penning, Northern Iowa
The easy one here is Ikem Ekwonu (NC State), but he's likely going in the top six picks, so let's go with Penning, whose tape is entertaining to watch. I say that because he's a nasty and physical finisher who will put defenders on their butts and get in their face (sometimes after the whistle). The big test for him was at Senior Bowl practices in January, and the 6-foot-7, 325-pounder held his own against some great players. He has the versatility to play left or right tackle in the NFL.

Projection: Penning will likely be drafted among the top 20 picks, with a chance for the top 13 depending on how the board shakes out.


Interior offensive line
i

Dylan Parham, Memphis
I'm combining center and guard for this year's favorites list, because there's not a center whom I love. I am, however, a big fan of Parham, who started 51 games in college, playing both guard spots and right tackle. He's not a massive road grader in the run game -- he measured 6-foot-3, 311 pounds at the combine -- but he is very technically sound. He knows exactly what he's doing on every snap. He allowed just one sack last season.

Projection: Parham could be a value pick in Round 3, because he could stay at guard or move to center. I think he'll be ready to play early.
 
Defensive end
i

Arnold Ebiketie, Penn State
OK, I'm sneaking in Ebiketie here at defensive end, even though he might be better suited for outside linebacker at the next level. I wanted to use another OLB, though, so bear with me. My pal Todd McShay keeps arguing with me about Ebiketie, saying I have him too high in this class. I'd take him in Round 1, though. He leveled up after transferring from Temple last season, racking up 9.5 sacks and 46 pressures.

Every team needs pass-rushers, and Ebiketie is a complete player. (He can get swallowed up at times in the run game, but his limitations are overblown.) He'll play all three downs in the NFL, and he has All-Pro potential.

Projection: Ebiketie is going to go somewhere in the top 40 picks. I had him going to Dallas at No. 24 in my recent mock, but I could see the Lions, Giants or Jets taking him early on Day 2 if he's still available.


Defensive tackle
i

Matthew Butler, Tennessee
Want a Day 3 pick who will play a long time in the league? That's Butler. I love his tape, and he rarely left the field for the Volunteers the past two seasons. At 6-foot-4, 297 pounds, he can split double-teams (or blow them up) and is incredibly disruptive (seven sacks from the interior since 2020). Turn on the film from the Alabama game to see him wreak havoc on the Crimson Tide, even in a blowout loss.

And like I said, his stamina and consistent effort is rare for 300-pounders in the NFL. He's not going to be an every-down player early in his career, but he has the tools to get there.

Projection: I have a Round 4 grade on Butler, but I still feel like I might be underrating him. You can bet I'll be mentioning him in my draft grades in two weeks.


Outside linebacker
i

Channing Tindall, Georgia
How about a linebacker who could go in the top 50 who never actually started a game in his college career? Tindall played in 50 games for the Bulldogs but was behind Nakobe Dean and Quay Walker on the depth chart. He was finally put into a consistent role last season and he showed flashes of being a star. He flies to the football and has some juice as a pass-rusher. He could end up as an inside or outside linebacker, depending on the scheme.

Tindall ran a blazing 4.47 40 and posted a 42-inch vertical at the combine, solidifying what he showed on tape. I'm looking forward to seeing where he lands in the NFL.

Projection: Tindall is going to go in Round 2, and it could be in the 30s.


Inside linebacker
i

Troy Andersen, Montana State
I love Andersen's versatility. As a freshman in 2017, he started games at both linebacker and running back for the Bobcats. In 2018, he was the first-team All-Big Sky quarterback. He ran for 21 scores that season. Now, he couldn't really throw much, so he stuck at linebacker from 2019 on, and he put up 150 tackles last season.

Andersen did not look out of place at Senior Bowl practices, and he ran a 4.42 40 at the combine, which was the second-fastest time among the front seven players there. He's legit.

Projection: I'm just going to say Day 2 here for now, because I could see him going late in the second round or closer to the middle of the third round. It's a big step up from the FCS to the NFL, so he'll need some time to adapt to the speed of everyone around him.


Cornerback
i

Derek Stingley Jr., LSU
I'm going to stick with a corner I've loved since 2019, when he looked like a candidate to be a future No. 1 prospect on my Big Board. As a true freshman for that LSU national title team, he had six interceptions and blanketed his side of the field. He was unbelievable. The problem is that he has had injuries the past two seasons and has played just 10 games since that dazzling debut year. That's an issue for NFL teams, who want to see consistent reps over a few seasons.

Still, I would bet on Stingley's talent, and he has the talent to be a true shutdown No. 1 corner in the NFL. Plus, he proved at his pro day earlier this month that he has recovered from his foot injury.

Projection: I don't think Stingley is going to fall out of the top 12 picks, with Minnesota lurking as his floor. He could still be picked over Cincinnati's Ahmad "Sauce" Gardner.


Safety
i

Daxton Hill, Michigan
Let's end with a defender I moved all the way to No. 13 overall on my Big Board. The former five-star recruit was kind of a tweener for the Wolverines, and he spent most of last season at slot corner. He had some inconsistent snaps there, but that versatility is appealing to NFL teams. He has already gotten reps at nickel corner and all over the field as a safety. Hill could be best as a center fielder at the next level; he ran an elite 4.38 40 at the combine.

He can get a few sacks and interceptions, and he'll smother tight ends who try to outmuscle him. He is also an excellent tackler in space.

Projection: Hill is going in Round 1, likely in the 20s.
 
some of my favs in there like Hill and Penning.
Hill is my favorite prospect for sure. I love the flexibility and that he can play slot or FS. With Hooker locked up for two seasons, I think Hill can help this defense take it to the next level.

My only gripe is that we would be taking a tweener in the first round. This is why I love a trade down and getting a Zion, Hill etc and gaining more picks.
 
I really like Ebiketie a lot. I think he’s going to add juice to a pass rush immediately. He won’t be a full time player right away IMO, but he is going to get after the QB from jump street. I wouldn’t be upset with him at 24, and I think he would make a difference on that defense. Parsons, Lawrence and Ebiketie would create issues for passing games.

I also like Butler in the mid rounds, and I think Hill is one of the best defenders in this draft, although I don’t think Dallas would take him, even if he did make it to 24.
 
I really like Ebiketie a lot. I think he’s going to add juice to a pass rush immediately. He won’t be a full time player right away IMO, but he is going to get after the QB from jump street. I wouldn’t be upset with him at 24, and I think he would make a difference on that defense. Parsons, Lawrence and Ebiketie would create issues for passing games.

I also like Butler in the mid rounds, and I think Hill is one of the best defenders in this draft, although I don’t think Dallas would take him, even if he did make it to 24.

What are pros and cons - Ebiketie vs Sam Williams?
 
Last edited:
What are pros and cons vs Sam Williams?
Alot of the same as Robert Quinn as a pro. Maybe he doesn't have quite the tool to reach the heights Quinn has at certain points in his career as a rusher, but he is a pretty safe bet to be an 8 to 12 sack guy most of his career. He'll probably be weak againt the run like Quinn

Without character issues he is probably a 1st rounder
 
  • Like
Reactions: BAT
What are pros and cons - Ebiketie vs Sam Williams?
Just talking about what I see when watching them:

Ebiketie Is a better athlete. More twitchy. More bendy. More flexibility. Williams is a really good athlete… just not as elite as Ebiketie.

Williams is stronger and more stout against the run. Better with speed to power, I think. Also a little more polished, IMO. He also has had an off field issue that scares some (but not me).

I see Ebiketie’s pass rush potential as higher than Williams, although I do think Sam has real potential as well. Ebiketie has rare get-off and speed in the edge. Kyle Crabbs from The Draft Network says about the Penn State product: There are some instances in which he is simply overwhelming off of the edge. The drive and initial stem on his outside rushes puts tackles in high stress sets and he’s always going to loom as a threat to take the edge.

Williams is built more like a 43 DE and Ebiketie more like a 34 OLB. Speaking for myself though, I think the Cowboys need some real athleticism off the edge to go with Micah’s crazy athleticism. Armstrong would have no issue playing the weak side DE position on run downs. He’s strong and dependable there. What I want is a bonafied elite athlete to use in pass rush sets. Someone who will have the athleticism to beat any of the offensive players he’ll face and can stress that side of the line and create real issues in the offensive protection sets.

IMO, that is Ebiketie.

With him coming off the edge and Parsons blitzing on the same side, I could see a lot of problems for the offense when they have to deal with that type of athletic ability from two guys. Move Lawrence inside and let Micah play opposite Ebiketie and it is a whole different set of issues for the offense to deal with.

There are a ton of different ways that Quinn could draw up the pressure packages with Ebiketie added to the mix. I don’t care that he wouldn’t be a full time starter this season. These days, not many DL are. Just let Armstrong and Fowler play on early downs, and then give a specific package for Ebiketie.

Anyway, that is kind of how I view it. I do like Williams and I think he could definitely help… but the kind of twitch and movement that Ebiketie has can create issues for the offense that I don’t think Williams can.

I’m probably in the minority on this but that’s how I feel. It isn’t just the player, it is how I want to see one being used and what I feel the team needs.
 
And really, when I’m talking about Ebiketie vs williams athleticism… I’m not really talking about 40 time running in a straight line. I’m talking movement skills, flexibility, change of direction, etc. He is just a twitchy, easy mover. That’s more what I like about Ebiketie.

And I’ll say it again: I really, really do like Williams and I can see him being the better player of the two. It’s just more about how I want to see the team using their pass rush. Use him like having another Parsons sort of.
 
Mafe is better than both guys being discussed and should be the selection

But he will not be available in 2nd or 3rd round. 1st and 2nd round have to address the trenches imo.

Reason why Ebiketie and SW are my preference.

Amare Barno is another project with crazy athleticism IMO. And should be available after 4th.
 
If what he's saying about WR Pierce's Jordy comparison is true, expect MM to be all over this kid. Jordy was MM's most productive receiver as Pack HC, similar to what Kupp is to the Rams.
 
Malik Willis for this guy too? For the life of me I can't understand what NFL teams, among others, see so much in a first read/run quarterback? Do they not understand that doesn't translate well to the NFL in most cases? Last year the 49s sold the farm to trade up for a QB that was not NFL ready. Guys like Fields and Lance will never be great QBs. They are more athletic versions of Johnny football and Tim Tebow.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
465,501
Messages
13,879,378
Members
23,791
Latest member
mashburn
Back
Top