Twitter: Top 10 QBs According To Players, Coaches, and Execs

[phildadon86]

You provided 73 and I used that.

I used it wrong, but that's where it came from.

Moved on already.

Yeah of course you did. I was waiting for everyone to figure it out. I used 73. That’s the only number you saw and you stopped reading. Because you thought you got me in an aha moment.
I said in the same freaking post that the numbers for a 100 yard rushing team were way higher. You obviously didn’t see that. You got giddy thinking you beat me or something.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Yeah of course you did. I was waiting for everyone to figure it out. I used 73. That’s the only number you saw and you stopped reading. Because you thought you got me in an aha moment.
I said in the same freaking post that the numbers for a 100 yard rushing team were way higher. You obviously didn’t see that. You got giddy thinking you beat me or something.

Yeah. There's certain posters that I just kinda skim through things with and you're one of em.

My fault on that one.

Oh well, it happens, moving on.

 

[phildadon86]

I don't think you'll find many people outside of Cowboys fans that would ever take Dak over Herbert, but hey, to each their own I suppose.

I’m a cowboys fan and wouldn’t take Dak over Herbert. Don’t lump me in there lol

 

[phildadon86]

Yeah. There's certain posters that I just kinda skim through things with and you're one of em.

My fault on that one.

Oh well, it happens, moving on.

So you asked me to provide you stats and then skimmed thru what I wrote? That’s rude and actually kinda mean my dude. It also proves yet again. You just don’t like Dak. And you’re here to rile up fans.

 

[plymkr]

Watson shouldnt even be included to be honest. Does it not bother anyone else that Zeke got 6 games with one accusation and Watson has gotten nothing and been traded and signed a huge deal?

After the last 2 seasons. I dont even have Wilson or Watson on the list. IMO.

Yes, it bothers me. Bothers me a lot. It also bothers me that Wade Wilson, our QB coach, got suspended for using PEDs to help his diabetes but Watson has gotten nothing.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

So you asked me to provide you stats and then skimmed thru what I wrote? That’s rude and actually kinda mean my dude. It also proves yet again. You just don’t like Dak. And you’re here to rile up fans.

Yeah.

I guess I didn't care that much.

 

[America's Cowboy]

Prescott was ranked 10th among NFL quarterbacks by executives and coaches polled by ESPN's Jeremy Fowler, with one pointing to his lack of postseason success as the reason he's still not an elite option.

"A good but not great QB; he has to play well in the playoffs," an NFC exec said. "Has to prove [he] can take them to the next level. He's not in the top echelon."

NFL Exec: Cowboys' Dak Prescott 'a Good but Not Great Qb'; 'Not in the Top Echelon' | News, Scores, Highlights, Stats, and Rumors | Bleacher Report

That nfl executive is a darn moron! Did he not see Dak's performance Dak's rookie year in the divisional round match-up against the Packers? Dak outperformed Rodgers, threw for over 300 yards and 3 TDs (should have been 4-5 TDs). The reason the Cowboys didn't advance to the NFC Championship Game that year is because the referees helped out Aaron Rodgers and the Packers ALL GAME LONG! Anyone with an unbiased and open mind (who rewatches that game can see all of this.

Plus, Dak outplayed and led the team to a win again Russell Wilson and the Seahawks during the 2018 playoffs. Russell Wilson and the Seahawks had just won the Super Bowl 4 years before.

Had Dak and the Cowboys not been bamboozled by the crooked refs during those playoff years, I doubt anyone would be spewing their misguided hate against Dak and the Cowboys.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

He is.

That's why anybody would be a fool to take Dak over him if given the choice.

So where does the discussion end? How far up does Herbert go? Is he the best in the league since he’s the most skillful?

 

[phildadon86]

Yeah.

I guess I didn't care that much.

No. You care. You cared when you wrote your diatribe trying to make me look stupid. But when the rest of the board came after you doing the same thing it’s “I’ve moved on” “I don’t care” you’re a child.

 

[phildadon86]

Yes, it bothers me. Bothers me a lot. It also bothers me that Wade Wilson, our QB coach, got suspended for using PEDs to help his diabetes but Watson has gotten nothing.

He got traded and a massive amount of money. That’s not nothing

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

You think people on this board downgrade him because he's a Cowboy?

Yeah, I am sure some do but the vast majority here tend to overrate our guys simply because they are a Cowboy.

I disagree. This place is very doom and gloom. I think Parsons is the one guy universally most agree is one of the best in the league. Maybe even add Martin to that list.

 

[Bigdog]

He is.

That's why anybody would be a fool to take Dak over him if given the choice.

I agree with you about skills. I really like Herbert but I just can't get past intangibles that is running through my head. I mean Brady is not the most physical skilled qb but he just knows how to win. Dak's intangibles are very high, imo.

 

[G2]

I disagree. This place is very doom and gloom. I think Parsons is the one guy universally most agree is one of the best in the league. Maybe even add Martin to that list.

Very true. In terms of football fans, I don't know a more negative place.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

No. You care. You cared when you wrote your diatribe trying to make me look stupid. But when the rest of the board came after you doing the same thing it’s “I’ve moved on” “I don’t care” you’re a child.

If you say so lol

 

[Dre11]

Well for starters, Herbert has only been in the league for two years. So you can't really compare a playoff resume of a two year guy to a QB who has been in the league 6 years. Again, after two years, Dak was 0-1 in the playoffs so it's not like he had such a noticeable advantage over Herbert.

It's mind numbing that we have fans that actually think Dak is a better QB. Is there a QB in this league you would rather have than Dak? In your eyes, is he a Top 3 QB? Top 5?

You keep talking about 2,3,4 years, you most definitely can compare that by year 2 Dak led his team to a playoff birth and Herbert hasn't, regardless if they won it or not Herbert hasn't led his team to nothing. It's mind numbing you can't give me any factors that make Herbert better. I consistently have Dak in the 7-10 RANGE, but I don't have Herbert ahead of Dak, he hasn't been in the league long enough or done anything. What has he done?

 

[Dre11]

If Herbert had a star on his helmet there's not a single person on the message board that would believe Dak is better than him.

BS if everything was the same except team, I'd have Herbert ahead

 

[Dre11]

You think people on this board downgrade him because he's a Cowboy?

Yeah, I am sure some do but the vast majority here tend to overrate our guys simply because they are a Cowboy.

I believe he gets criticized more harshly by critics in general because he plays for the Cowboys. I also think some people on this board can't let go of the fact he replaced Romo.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

You keep talking about 2,3,4 years, you most definitely can compare that by year 2 Dak led his team to a playoff birth and Herbert hasn't, regardless if they won it or not Herbert hasn't led his team to nothing. It's mind numbing you can't give me any factors that make Herbert better. I consistently have Dak in the 7-10 RANGE, but I don't have Herbert ahead of Dak, he hasn't been in the league long enough or done anything. What has he done?

You like stats, right?

Did you know that if Herbert was a Cowboy he'd have the record for TDs and yards for a single season?

Dak and Romo wouldn't anymore.

Herbert did in year 2 what no Cowboys QB in history has ever done in those two categories.

It means nothing in the grand scheme of things, but I know you like stats and all.

 

[Adreme]

You keep talking about 2,3,4 years, you most definitely can compare that by year 2 Dak led his team to a playoff birth and Herbert hasn't, regardless if they won it or not Herbert hasn't led his team to nothing. It's mind numbing you can't give me any factors that make Herbert better. I consistently have Dak in the 7-10 RANGE, but I don't have Herbert ahead of Dak, he hasn't been in the league long enough or done anything. What has he done?

Just as the fact that Dak has not gone all the way is not a mark against him, the fact that Herbert has done less is also not a mark against him. The measure of a QB is simply how good are they because whether they win or not depends entirely on what you surround them with.

At the age of 33 Matt Stafford did not suddenly learn how to be a better QB, he simply had a better team around him but yet now everyone acts like NOW he is a great QB. He was great before and is great now but the only difference is that now people notice because he had a better team around him. Herbert is a great QB, and whether he wins or not in a loaded AFC will come entirely down to what they surround him with but he will be great regardless of what that is.

 

[Dre11]

You like stats, right?

Did you know that if Herbert was a Cowboy he'd have the record for TDs and yards for a single season?

Dak and Romo wouldn't anymore.

Herbert did in year 2 what no Cowboys QB in history has ever done in those two categories.

It means nothing in the grand scheme of things, but I know you like stats and all.

Lol...what makes you think that. That's just your opinion. There's no evidence to prove that, different system and an entirely different dynamic playing for Dallas.