You're paying a QB everyone sees as somewhere around 12ish to 15ish the 2nd most per year.
I said it once and I'll say it again...
You should only pay top dollar for top talent, not because it's "their turn to get paid".
In theory yes, but when there’s only 5/6 top talent guys what do you want a team to do, let their franchise QB walk?
Once the ball started rolling then it’s too late. Once owners started paying Kirk Cousins, Jimmy Garrapolo, and Alex Smith elite money then the train left the station and it can’t be stopped.
You either have a QB that isn’t elite but still can be good to great at times or you have one that hamstrings you.
If your solution is cycling through guys until you land on an elite QB then you’re just talking to talk because it’s not actually realistic. GM’s, coaches, and players have leashes and want to feed their family. They aren’t just going to go through QB after QB to find the guy. Once you find someone you can win games with any human who wants his job in the NFL will do what they can to keep them.
Also, spinning the QB wheel and hoping to land on a jackpot could take you 20 years. Look at Chicago, Jacksonville, NYJ etc. At the end of the day this thing is a business and not just a competition in a vacuum. Front offices and most fanbases would rather have a competent winning team that gives you a chance rather than churning the heck outta your QB and team to try to find the right combination. It’s not Madden, these are real people who want to fill stands and keep their jobs. They don’t have the time to just go throwing darts until they find a Herbert or Mahomes.
I say all of this to say I think the absolute most pointless thing is complaining about or arguing that non-elite QB’s should get paid. Obviously people should be paid based on their rank, but that just not the way the NFL works. When elite QB’s are as scarce as they are the ones in the middle will be paid more. It’s just market rules man. I agree that these guys in theory shouldn’t be this paid, but I don’t get why you and other continue to shake your fist at the sky about this.
It’s not based solely on on-field performance and it never will be. Just let this salary thing go guys, it’s not changing anytime soon. Unless a team has a clear and obvious upgrade in front of it seldom will they move on from a top 15-16 QB. Just is what it is man.