Dozens of accidentally merged threads ** LOCKED **

[Vtwin]

You could replace Dak with any of the average group and end up in the same place. At the least.

 

[DasTex]

72 Dolphins are on notice

 

[ChronicCowboy]

Alright fine that’s probably a playoff team

No way….weak RB, LB and DT corps; zero depth at OL and CB. Dak a huge question mark. Only two positions I feel good about are WR and DE (and that’s WITH Micah).

 

[KingCorcoran]

Damn so basically they traded CGJ for nothing?

Got a fifth for a sixth in the deal, which the teams have since trade back to each other. But Philly unloaded a contract they did not feel was worthwhile.

 

[starfan1]

Ranking Dak with anything higher than 'average' when he hasn't won a conference championship is WILD .

Im sorry but this makes 0 sense. Allen and Jackson,Mayfield should be average by your criteria then? The Dak derangement crew is gonna be strong in this thread. Mountain is missing should be here soon

 

[erod]

I'd probably push a healthy Dak up a notch or two ahead of maybe a Stafford or a Mayfield, but overall this list seems solid. Glad they put a "wait and see" on Daniels, Nix, and Williams too.

Always said Dak was a 7 to 12 range QB.

Dak isn't close to Mayfield or Stafford. Mayfield is starting to play at a very high level now.

There are 5-6 quarterbacks listed below Dak that we ALL would take over him right now.

 

[Carson]

Booth. WTH

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Perhaps a little high for Dak, considering last season, but not by much

why is Hurts ahead of Allen? or Burrows. Just because his team carried him to a superbowl?

 

[Carson]

Missed that Mafah was on the initial 53 after reading he was headed to IR. I guess that he and Carson could not be put on IR until first being on the roster?

I would probably park Grier and Adeniji on the practice squad and bring them up, but if we do that with Goodwin, we can only bring up one other, so one will have to be placed back on the 53.

Yes they must make the 53 to go the Ir to return.

If not every team would just IR all of their extra bodies lol

 

[reddyuta]

we desperately need a DT,we cannot play these 1Ts against Philly- they might not throw a pass if we did.

 

[OGSixshooter]

Another “I hate Jerry Jones thread!”. Shocker.

He made it so easy. He's a narcissist who is mad that others don't see him as a visionary. Generally speaking, human beings will forgive narcissism - even the malignant strain - if you get results and are successful. If not, hate awaits.

 

[exciter]

Surprised only 5 WR.

I guess Mafah not on IR then. Unless that move will be made soon.

Really no major surprises maybe a few minor ones.

Mingo will be back!

 

[jblaze2004]

Baker Mayfield had one year that was better than Daks and all of a sudden he is better lol. How about no. It's crazy how much hate Dak gets.

 

[Tabascocat]

At least, the deuce is loose!

 

[dacopacabana]

1. Philly
2. Detroit
3. Bucs
4. Cards
5. Gb
6. Dallas
7. Chicago
8. Wsh
9. La
10. Falcons
11. Seahawks
12. Sf
13. Car
14. No
15. Minny
16. Nyg

???

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

I'm not sure I have Mahomes above Jackson,Burrow and Allen any longer. Hurts is too high should be in good category.

I semi-agree with this. Mahomes has not been mvp caliber the last 2 year; Jackson has flat outplayed him

But then there’s the argument he just wins no matter what, and he steps up in the playoffs. But in that case, you gotta give that to Hurts too; his career playoff stats are insane

 

[exciter]

Overshown?

Pup!

 

[big dog cowboy]

Perhaps a little high for Dak, considering last season, but not by much

Looks about right to me. You can't discount 3 seasons of 12 wins and say just "considering last season".

Looking at the entire list, way to much emphasis put on last year.

 

[OGSixshooter]

Don't see Daniels. List is bogus if he's not on it.

 

[OGSixshooter]

so when they come out flat in Philly it’s going to be “we got a lot of work to do but we’ll get there”

Game 7 Dak: I'm just about to get hot! Had to knock off the rust.