Well Blue, here’s a broader perspective on Elam:
- He’s been with 4 different teams in the last two seasons.
- The Cowboys are the only team that gave up two draft picks to acquire him last year. We received a 6th and gave up a 5th and a 7th round pick. Not a lot but still draft capital.
- The Cowboys chose to waive him before the 2025 season ended. He was bad.
- The Titans picked him up off waivers in late Nov last year but also later cut him.
- The chiefs did sign him to a one year cheap deal as a FA two weeks ago but he’s buried pretty deep on their depth chart. Maybe he makes the team. We will see.
It doesn’t seem that we are that great at judging talent. It came out last year when they traded for him that we had him rated him highly in the 2022 draft. À pattern we also followed with the trade acquisition of WRJonathan Wingo in 2024 for a 4th round pick.
Much like we had with several other one year players that didn’t work out like LB Kenneth Murray and LB Jack Sanborn. Elam, Murray and Sanborn were supposed to really help our D last year. None of them are still here.
Stop trying to convince me my thought process was wrong, because it’s not.
I’m literally explaining that all these guys, including Trey Lance and sometimes players who get shipped out like Nahshon Wright, and others people didn’t like such as Woods or Awuzie, are in the same boat. The guys we brought in last year—fine, we get it—but those draft picks you’re talking about are nothing, absolutely nothing. They do what other teams do: bring guys in and hope they can work out at least as role players. It wasn’t Elim’s fault; he was in a bad defense with no pass rush and a defensive coordinator who didn’t want to create one. It was a horrible defense, and not one player who started the year on the roster looked good. Most of the defense was terrible, and they all had their worst years—that’s not a coincidence.
The point is, every team has a bunch of one-year players and role players filling out the bottom of their roster, moving from team to team. Jerry’s not the only one who does this. I know you’re quick to criticize him and claim he operates differently, but it’s really the same as what most teams do.
Take Kansas City, for example. If you break down their free agent spending, you’ll see they’ve traded away some of their better players without a solid backup plan, similar to what we did in 2018 with the wide receiver-by-committee approach. Yes, they’ve won a lot of Super Bowls, but they’re not the all-in, aggressive team people make them out to be. They’ve taken some of our leftovers—like Wilson and Hitchens—but have also let key players walk. That’s why they’re in their current spot: they let their two best corners go and now they’re scrambling for role players, just like the Cowboys did.
Sometimes the Jerry hate goes overboard. With those hate goggles on, it’s easy to forget that most of the league operates this way.
They’re not like the Rams, Eagles, or the occasional team that takes a big swing. I’m not saying they shouldn’t try that once in a while, but most teams care about the cap and budget, make tough roster decisions, and deal with holdouts, franchise tags, and fifth-year options.
I know Jerry’s not popular, and I’m not defending him, but it’s really not as different as people make it out to be. I see it all the time—folks make excuses, backtrack, and try to explain why this case is somehow unique. But plenty of ex-players our fans thought were terrible and should never play again end up on other teams. Same goes for coaches—anyone who thought Matt Eberflus would be out of work for long was wrong. He’s now with a better team, a better organization. Ironic, isn’t it? He landed in a better place. And to be clear, I agreed he needed to go—what happened was beyond a disaster, worse than that movie about all those trains crashing into each other at full speed.
From my perspective, about 90% of the league operates pretty much the same way, but occasionally you have those who swing for the fences—going all in with aggressive, budget-busting moves. Over the last two offseasons, I’ve got to give Jerry some credit for being more aggressive and getting ahead of things, even if it didn’t always work out. This offseason, he’s made the effort—it’s not his fault they didn’t land Crosby, Dean, or Walker—but that aggressive mindset could still lead to surprises and moves before the season starts. It might not be exactly what the fan base wants, but I’ve noticed subtle changes over the past two years. Last year didn’t pan out, but they kept that approach through midseason, making trades, and so far this year they’ve stayed aggressive. Just because some deals didn’t work out doesn’t mean they’ve gone down with the ship—they’ve thrown caution to the wind and are operating a bit differently, in my opinion.