Tank for arch

Disagree. Dak had 2 tipped INTs. Arch threw 2 INTs, one into coverage and another just didn't get it in there fast enough, DB came off his receiver and picked it. Both were on him. None of those picks were on Dak.

Arch is closer to Herbert.
Herbert plays better than Arch….Arch overrated as hell. His name is what has everybody on him.
 
He probably stays after this fiasco. Slow bloomer? he might turn into a Peyton but the people who have bought in... need to lay off for a couple years.
 
Arch Manning NEEDS all the college experience before going pro. He has all the tools, but he is a long way from being an NFL starter.

I suspect even once he does go pro, he will still likely need a couple of years.
 
Anyone who ever propped up Arch Manning needs to quit discussing football. They clearly have no idea what they were ever talking about, and they only propped him up because of his last name.

You guys know who you are…
 
Arch is a mental disaster back there. He has the physical tools but lacks the mental ones.
 

What sillyness is this. Dak is a Top 6 Quarterback.... consistently makes everyone's list high even if he isn't filed in Mahomes or Allen's category.

Arch is unproven and can't even make it in college where it's way easier, and given where he plays which makes it even easier.
 

Staff online

Cowboys Pick'em

DAL @ GB
Oct 18, 2026 at 7:20 PM
Make your pick
42 member(s) have picked so far. Picks are revealed at kickoff.
+ 12 more games to pick this week
Season leaders
The leaderboard starts filling in once the first games are graded. Get your picks in!

Survivor Pool

40 of 40 still standing
Week 6 · last kickoff Oct 19, 2026 at 7:15 PM
Join the pool

Forum statistics

Threads
476,570
Messages
14,701,168
Members
24,234
Latest member
Justdatruth
Back
Top