Cris Carter Says Witten Not All That

I know what ur saying but Witten's go to 3rd down conversions, although not pretty, are playmaking and are a mainstay with him. That play tho, where he continued running after his helmet got ripped off is epic!

I agree guy moves the chains better than anyone in the game, when I say big playmaker he is not going to stretch the field like Gates or Graham, he does not put up the TD they do but Witten game in and game out helps the Cowboys move the chains.
 
Romo shouldn't have gone so extreme with the praise, it comes off as insincere. Witten is obviously a great Cowboy and Carter is just another ESPN jerk, I can't even force myself to watch that dysfunctional crew of trolls.
 
I agree guy moves the chains better than anyone in the game, when I say big playmaker he is not going to stretch the field like Gates or Graham, he does not put up the TD they do but Witten game in and game out helps the Cowboys move the chains.

Witten does more all around than those guys. Jimmy Graham couldn't block Scandrick lol.
 
Meh...another useless thought from another blow hole. I can't get that 10 seconds back so, i thought i would just ***** about it,,,lol Kinda like keyshawn Johnson said Dallas was one of the worst teams in the NFL.

Well, at 4-1 their not. good grief...I love it when they hate. Stephen A Smith is my main target and some day he shall eat the crow...it's coming.

When did Key say that? Before season? Or still at 4-1?
 
I agree guy moves the chains better than anyone in the game, when I say big playmaker he is not going to stretch the field like Gates or Graham, he does not put up the TD they do but Witten game in and game out helps the Cowboys move the chains.
Witten moves the chains, just like Michael and Emmitt did. I'd take those kind of players everyday and all day.
 
Overreaction to CC's comments in 3 ... 2 ... wait, it's already occurred. Nevermind. ;)
 
When did Key say that? Before season? Or still at 4-1?
San frany week....Shows you just how much they really take the time to know and you would think they had all the access they need.

Just opinion...funny crap.
 
San frany week....Shows you just how much they really take the time to know and you would think they had all the access they need.

Just opinion...funny crap.

I agree.

Most 'experts' didn't take time to study the roster or they failed to realize this team had been adding talented football players since 2010, including most around here.
 
I havent listened to anything today, but just put on BSPN radio a few mins ago. There was a a commercial playing some conversation from Mike & Mike. Greeny was referring to Romo's comment about Witten being the greatest Cowboy ever and then CC chimed in. He said NO, and we dont even know if Witten is a Hall of Famer. Greeny questions him and then CC says something to the effect that Witten isnt a threat that opposing teams game plan for and has just happened to play in an era where he has benefited from Romo forcing him the ball all the time. Then he says Romo is just throwing some junk out there with those comments.


Did anybody hear this on Mike & Mike this morning?


You just cant make this stuff up.

And Chris Carter thinks he was a threat that opposing teams planned around ???
 
The main argument that will be used against Witten when it comes to HOF is his lack of TDs. Golic pointed out that Witten has like half the amount of career TDs as Antonio Gates, which will be the TE he gets compared to when they evaluate who should get in.

Witten is a really good player, plays the game the right way and is a great ambassador for Dallas. Nothing but respect for him from around the league and the general NFL fan base. It'll be interesting to see what happens when he becomes eligible. Probably doesn't have a shot at 1st ballot but over time he probably has a decent chance to get in.
 
He's not exactly wrong. Teams don't fear Witten.

No, he's exactly wrong. Teams both game plan for Witten and they have a healthy respect for him. It's fans who don't realize it because they don't pay all that much attention to what's going on as a whole. Jason had more than 1000 yards and 110 receptions two seasons ago--from the TE position. He threw in another ~75 or so last year, many of those plays that extended drives and move chains for an offense that was one of the most effective in the league in terms of getting points when they had their hands on the ball. As much as teams 'fear' anybody, they 'fear' players like Witten, because those are the player who beat you.

Opposing fans don't fear him because he doesn't score a lot and he doesn't get up and start smashing the ground and screaming whenever he catches the ball. He just gets up and goes back to the huddle and does it again.
 
I just googled Chris Carter stats, just to do a comparison between him and Witten. The whole first page of results looked funny, because they were for Chris Carter the baseball player. He didn't even make the first page of a google lookup :)
 
No, he's exactly wrong. Teams both game plan for Witten and they have a healthy respect for him. It's fans who don't realize it because they don't pay all that much attention to what's going on as a whole. Jason had more than 1000 yards and 110 receptions two seasons ago--from the TE position. He threw in another ~75 or so last year, many of those plays that extended drives and move chains for an offense that was one of the most effective in the league in terms of getting points when they had their hands on the ball. As much as teams 'fear' anybody, they 'fear' players like Witten, because those are the player who beat you.

Opposing fans don't fear him because he doesn't score a lot and he doesn't get up and start smashing the ground and screaming whenever he catches the ball. He just gets up and goes back to the huddle and does it again.

Love ya, but don't feel like reading a book!

I was only (kinda) kidding.
 
The main argument that will be used against Witten when it comes to HOF is his lack of TDs...
If a skill position player with 9 Pro Bowls and multiple first-team All-Pro selections were to fail to make it into the Hall of Fame after years of eligibility, there would have to be a criminal investigation.

It would literally set a precedent for skill-position players.
 
so Seahawks will use Cam along with LB to try and take Witten out, that should open some holes elsewhere. lol

lol i just think romo needs to chill. i've noticed after a few wins he can get carried with the superlatives. witten was asked about it yesterday and he was shocked it was being brought up with the seattle game a few days away. i like witten's approach.
 
If a skill position player with 9 Pro Bowls were to fail to make it into the Hall of Fame after years of eligibility, there would have to be a criminal investigation.

It would literally set a precedent for skill-position players.

Don't be surprised if it happens
 
why did romo bring up this topic this week?

ESPN is doing a E:60 special on Witten and Romo provided HIS opinion to Jeremy Schaap.

Also he was asked by Seattle media about Witten.

So let me guess, if we lose at Seattle (like everyone does) it will be Romo's fault for giving HIS opinion about Witten? Is that where this is going?
 
http://espn.go.com/boston/nfl/story...argeting-dallas-tight-end-jason-witten-sunday
"I evaluate [Witten] as one of the all-time greats," Belichick told Dallas reporters on a conference call earlier this week. "He's had a tremendous career -- still going strong. He's good at the running game, good at the passing game, plays down the field, clutch guy in tight situations when you need a catch over the middle or third down, red area, [and] those kinds of things. Really, he's a complete player. I don't see any weak points. Just an outstanding guy that you've got to be aware of at all times and he definitely is a guy that impacts the running game as well.

"There's a lot of good tight ends in the league and there's good players at every position, but he's as good as any player and I'm glad we only play him once every whatever it is, three or four years. That's plenty."
It's an old quote, but Bill Belichick pretty much disagrees. And honestly Jason Witten isn't that much less of a player today than he was in 2011. He gets targeted less today, sure, but that's in large part because we have more offensive weapons today than we did in 2011. Particularly Beasley, who's probably taking a lot of Witten's third down looks given how incredible he is at moving the chains. On the flip side, Witten appears (to me at least) to be a much better blocker today than he's ever been in his career.
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
475,044
Messages
14,578,787
Members
24,214
Latest member
whoami2066
Back
Top