Where does Scott Linehan fit in the worst coordinators in Dallas history?

[Whyjerry]

My worst 5 list - Jack Riley, Monte Kiffin, Rob Ryan, Scott Linehan, David Shula.

Given the talent level I think he is the second worst in history.

What do you think?

 

[CowboyRoy]

My worst 5 list - Jack Riley, Monte Kiffin, Rob Ryan, Scott Linehan, David Shula.

Given the talent level I think he is the second worst in history.

What do you think?

First of all, he is head and shoulders above Garrett as OC. Garrett was far and away the WORST OC this team has EVER seen. And its not even close. If you recall he didn't even like to run the ball. Just figured out what play action was about 4 years ago. Rubs, picks, screens, crossing routes, ect….ect……..Garrett still hasn't learned.

 

[cowboyblue22]

he is not very good but I don't think much of the staff from the head coach on down

 

[glimmerman]

Could rate it better if it was his playbook. It’s JG playbook. Where does JG rank, he was OC.

 

[Batman1980]

Could rate it better if it was his playbook. It’s JG playbook. Where does JG rank, he was OC.

Don't care, he's the OC, it's his fault. That's how it works. There's enough talent on this team to be at least middle of the pack throwing the ball. Especially with a top 3 RB in the backfield.

 

[waving monkey]

My worst 5 list - Jack Riley, Monte Kiffin, Rob Ryan, Scott Linehan, David Shula.

Given the talent level I think he is the second worst in history.

What do you think?

I dont care

 

[Whyjerry]

2015 is stuck in my mind. Watching them work without Romo was painful.

 

[glimmerman]

Don't care, he's the OC, it's his fault. That's how it works. There's enough talent on this team to be at least middle of the pack throwing the ball. Especially with a top 3 RB in the backfield.

JG was worse than Linehan and it’s his own playbook.

 

[Whyjerry]

I dont care

You cared enough to type you don't care. If you don't like the post, move on. No need to be a smartazz.

 

[catiii]

He sucks as does the Clapping Clown who is even worse. I agree with your appraisal.

 

[waving monkey]

You cared enough to type you don't care. If you don't like the post, move on. No need to be a smartazz.

There might be or not be. I did care enough to say it makes no difference in whats happening now.
I saw your post [which is your right] as another gratuitous disparagement of the team. I. My right.

 

[bigdnlaca]

Rob Ryan wasn't that bad imo. He came in with a terrible secondary that included injuries to starting corners that weren't playing very good the year prior . Then they get Carr and Claiborne but then he was getting guys off the street due to injuries in other areas. He tried his best with what he had (especially in the 2nd season). 2012 defense was put in a lot of bad situations because the offense wasn't taking care of the ball and they weren't running the football (blame JG since he was calling the plays).

The one knock against him is that he did make the scheme too complicated for some players to understand.

 

[Batman1980]

When opposing players and even former players from here are pointing out the same flaws fans can see drinking beer on their couches on Sunday, it's a problem.

 

[Whyjerry]

There might be or not be. I did care enough to say it makes no difference in whats happening now.
I saw your post [which is your right] as another gratuitous disparagement of the team. I. My right.

What? The offense is a mess. It was a fair question.

 

[JayFord]

Id put him above all of those people you listed

 

[exciter]

My worst 5 list - Jack Riley, Monte Kiffin, Rob Ryan, Scott Linehan, David Shula.

Given the talent level I think he is the second worst in history.

What do you think?

Who was the one from Cincinnati in QCs 2nd year that ran a west coast that had the goofy play where the te would fall down then sneak out the backside. Hes 1-5 then start counting the others!

 

[jrumann59]

Who was the one from Cincinnati in QCs 2nd year that ran a west coast that had the goofy play where the te would fall down then sneak out the backside. Hes 1-5 then start counting the others!

Coslet.

 

[cern]

I prefer rating the best, not worst. still, it's subjective at best.

 

[exciter]

Coslet.

Yeah, that was bad!

 

[jrumann59]

Zampese had a little stagnation in his playcalling...