Look at the NYG, they have what we are missing?

[blueblood70]

look at SaquanB, having a great ROY campaign and his offense looks bad.. BTW all the talk about Dak needing better WR/TEs will make HIM better,

doesnt NY have SB, OBJ, some decent slot guys, Engram at TE, arguably a season vet at QB Shurmur a better Coaching tree guy, hows that working out? if the QB is not playing well for whatever reason it will blow the play calling up..

Yes many things are broken but no way Daks better then ELI, different layers both playing poorly but Eli was given all the things we seem to be missing outside of a consistent Oline, and still Eli and the team are struggling as much or more then us..

all the Dak apologists say give him better targets and better coaching.. well Eli has all that and still failing. its ELI and its Dak..sure we have other ral issues but if OBJ and Ingram were here, dak would all of a sudden be fixed?

I say no..

 

[jazzcat22]

Our biggest issue is coaching.
not saying Dak can be fixed, but he sure could be better from better coaching and a better playbook / scheme.
And for sure a better QB coach.

But the offense as a whole, will benefit from better coaching.

 

[Ken]

look at SaquanB, having a great ROY campaign and his offense looks bad.. BTW all the talk about Dak needing better WR/TEs will make HIM better,

doesnt NY have SB, OBJ, some decent slot guys, Engram at TE, arguably a season vet at QB Shurmur a better Coaching tree guy, hows that working out? if the QB is not playing well for whatever reason it will blow the play calling up..

Yes many things are broken but no way Daks better then ELI, different layers both playing poorly but Eli was given all the things we seem to be missing outside of a consistent Oline, and still Eli and the team are struggling as much or more then us..

all the Dak apologists say give him better targets and better coaching.. well Eli has all that and still failing. its ELI and its Dak..sure we have other ral issues but if OBJ and Ingram were here, dak would all of a sudden be fixed?

I say no..

Thanks for you info.

I say yes. I say Eli has been done for years. I say Dak doesn't pee his pants after 1 second in the pocket...

 

[blueblood70]

Thanks for you info.

I say yes. I say Eli has been done for years. I say Dak doesn't pee his pants after 1 second in the pocket...

no hes runs sideways and backwards instead of climbing the pocket or going up and eventually gets sacked after holding it 3 secs and staring down the rush and have had fumble issues as well..they are both equally bad this season and the main cause for the poor offensive outputs of their teams..

 

[ClintDagger]

look at SaquanB, having a great ROY campaign and his offense looks bad.. BTW all the talk about Dak needing better WR/TEs will make HIM better,

doesnt NY have SB, OBJ, some decent slot guys, Engram at TE, arguably a season vet at QB Shurmur a better Coaching tree guy, hows that working out? if the QB is not playing well for whatever reason it will blow the play calling up..

Yes many things are broken but no way Daks better then ELI, different layers both playing poorly but Eli was given all the things we seem to be missing outside of a consistent Oline, and still Eli and the team are struggling as much or more then us..

all the Dak apologists say give him better targets and better coaching.. well Eli has all that and still failing. its ELI and its Dak..sure we have other ral issues but if OBJ and Ingram were here, dak would all of a sudden be fixed?

I say no..

Eli is washed up and is at the end of the road. But I think if you ask any QB would you rather have a top 10 WR/TE unit and a bottom 10 OL unit, or Vice versa.... Every single one would choose the latter.

 

[funkytown]

Eli is toast. He's done. That's whats wrong with the Giants.

 

[Brax]

look at SaquanB, having a great ROY campaign and his offense looks bad.. BTW all the talk about Dak needing better WR/TEs will make HIM better,

doesnt NY have SB, OBJ, some decent slot guys, Engram at TE, arguably a season vet at QB Shurmur a better Coaching tree guy, hows that working out? if the QB is not playing well for whatever reason it will blow the play calling up..

Yes many things are broken but no way Daks better then ELI, different layers both playing poorly but Eli was given all the things we seem to be missing outside of a consistent Oline, and still Eli and the team are struggling as much or more then us..

all the Dak apologists say give him better targets and better coaching.. well Eli has all that and still failing. its ELI and its Dak..sure we have other ral issues but if OBJ and Ingram were here, dak would all of a sudden be fixed?

I say no..

Yes you are correct, common denominator BAD QB play. Remember Eli was so bad last year he got benched. They fire the HC cause he benched him, he was right Eli is plain bad, unfortunately he is better than Dak which says it all. Dak should be benched but JG doesn't have the stones to do what is best for the team because Jerry just will not allow it.

 

[Redball Express]

look at SaquanB, having a great ROY campaign and his offense looks bad.. BTW all the talk about Dak needing better WR/TEs will make HIM better,

doesnt NY have SB, OBJ, some decent slot guys, Engram at TE, arguably a season vet at QB Shurmur a better Coaching tree guy, hows that working out? if the QB is not playing well for whatever reason it will blow the play calling up..

Yes many things are broken but no way Daks better then ELI, different layers both playing poorly but Eli was given all the things we seem to be missing outside of a consistent Oline, and still Eli and the team are struggling as much or more then us..

all the Dak apologists say give him better targets and better coaching.. well Eli has all that and still failing. its ELI and its Dak..sure we have other ral issues but if OBJ and Ingram were here, dak would all of a sudden be fixed?

I say no..

Eli will probably be released at the end of the year and they will draft their QB.

If he is released..

I would take him as a backup in a heart beat.

 

[PhillyCowboysFan]

Eli will probably be released at the end of the year and they will draft their QB.

If he is released..

I would take him as a backup in a heart beat.

Isn’t Eli a two Super Bowl MVP? I think he will retire before he signs as a backup.

 

[Jarv]

Eli will probably be released at the end of the year and they will draft their QB.

If he is released..

I would take him as a backup in a heart beat.

Yeah and probably 1 or 2 spots ahead of us and get the QB we need.

 

[Stash]

Their offensive line is horrendous. Even when they’ve invested big time in it, it’s failed.

 

[Brax]

Eli will probably be released at the end of the year and they will draft their QB.

If he is released..

I would take him as a backup in a heart beat.

That's something to look forward to a washed up bum to back up a never was, wonderful.

 

[blueblood70]

are there any true top 10 QBs in this next drive, no reaches ? not following too much but isn't 2020 a better crop of College Qbs?

 

[JustChip]

I

look at SaquanB, having a great ROY campaign and his offense looks bad.. BTW all the talk about Dak needing better WR/TEs will make HIM better,

doesnt NY have SB, OBJ, some decent slot guys, Engram at TE, arguably a season vet at QB Shurmur a better Coaching tree guy, hows that working out? if the QB is not playing well for whatever reason it will blow the play calling up..

Yes many things are broken but no way Daks better then ELI, different layers both playing poorly but Eli was given all the things we seem to be missing outside of a consistent Oline, and still Eli and the team are struggling as much or more then us..

all the Dak apologists say give him better targets and better coaching.. well Eli has all that and still failing. its ELI and its Dak..sure we have other ral issues but if OBJ and Ingram were here, dak would all of a sudden be fixed?

I say no..

What it really says is there are a lot of factors that have to come together just right for a team to have success. Changing any one of those factors may provide some level of improvement, but doesn't ensure that all the ills will suddenly be fixed. Coaching is the most important factor, but even a change there doesn't guarantee ultimate success. Same with the QB. Same with the WRs. Etc.

 

[rags747]

look at SaquanB, having a great ROY campaign and his offense looks bad.. BTW all the talk about Dak needing better WR/TEs will make HIM better,

doesnt NY have SB, OBJ, some decent slot guys, Engram at TE, arguably a season vet at QB Shurmur a better Coaching tree guy, hows that working out? if the QB is not playing well for whatever reason it will blow the play calling up..

Yes many things are broken but no way Daks better then ELI, different layers both playing poorly but Eli was given all the things we seem to be missing outside of a consistent Oline, and still Eli and the team are struggling as much or more then us..

all the Dak apologists say give him better targets and better coaching.. well Eli has all that and still failing. its ELI and its Dak..sure we have other ral issues but if OBJ and Ingram were here, dak would all of a sudden be fixed?

I say no..

Great example, We need a QB unfortunately the Giants are all set to take who we need.

 

[Captain-Crash]

I don't know what giants team you're looking at, but Eli has the worst offensive line in the east, followed by the skins. The cowboys and eagles have great offensive line compared to these teams..

 

[Doomsay]

The Giants have a great shot at a #1 draft pick, which is more than we can hope for at this point.

 

[dfense]

Eli will probably be released at the end of the year and they will draft their QB.

If he is released..

I would take him as a backup in a heart beat.

Or god willing, the Cowboys will be bold and admit Dak will make a great backup and Draft a top shelf QB. They can tell Dak it's an open competition just to save face and at the same time steal the Giants future QB out from under them. They will then have a solid 1-2 QB depth and won't have to worry about watching the Giants franchise QB for the next 10 years and wondering "If we only could have got that guy."

 

[SinCityMex]

look at SaquanB, having a great ROY campaign and his offense looks bad.. BTW all the talk about Dak needing better WR/TEs will make HIM better,

doesnt NY have SB, OBJ, some decent slot guys, Engram at TE, arguably a season vet at QB Shurmur a better Coaching tree guy, hows that working out? if the QB is not playing well for whatever reason it will blow the play calling up..

Yes many things are broken but no way Daks better then ELI, different layers both playing poorly but Eli was given all the things we seem to be missing outside of a consistent Oline, and still Eli and the team are struggling as much or more then us..

all the Dak apologists say give him better targets and better coaching.. well Eli has all that and still failing. its ELI and its Dak..sure we have other ral issues but if OBJ and Ingram were here, dak would all of a sudden be fixed?

I say no..

With our luck Gints take Justin Herbert and we stick with Dak I feel we will be at bottom of nfc east for a long time. I feel like we’re doomed this sucks.

 

[blueblood70]

With our luck Gints take Justin Herbert and we stick with Dak I feel we will be at bottom of nfc east for a long time. I feel like we’re doomed this sucks.

so theres only ONE good QB coming out this year or the drop off from 1-2 is huge??