Fun “you’re the GM” thread

[ThatJerryKid]

You are the Cowboys GM and you get to decide which 5 you are signing to long term contracts, the others walk. Or you can sign any other FA not on the list but you only get 5. Who you signing?

Ezekiel Elliott
Dak Prescott
Demarcus Lawrence
Byron Jones
Amari Cooper
Earl Thomas
Landon Collins
Justin Houston

 

[KingintheNorth]

Ezekiel Elliott
Dak Prescott
Demarcus Lawrence
Amari Cooper
Earl Thomas

 

[QuincyCarterEra]

Dak
Cooper
Lawrence
Byron
Jaylon

 

[WillieBeamen]

You are the Cowboys GM and you get to decide which 5 you are signing to long term contracts, the others walk. Or you can sign any other FA not on the list but you only get 5. Who you signing?

Ezekiel Elliott
Dak Prescott
Demarcus Lawrence
Byron Jones
Amari Cooper
Earl Thomas
Landon Collins
Justin Houston

Zeke
Tank
Coop
Earl
Houston

Id give arizona a third for Rosen, then watch my team thrive

 

[Fletch]

Dak
Cooper
Lawrence
Byron
Jaylon

No Zeke? F-ing crazy.

 

[BigCatMonaco]

Zeke
Tank
Coop
Earl
Houston

Id give arizona a third for Rosen, then watch my team thrive

Based on what exactly?
His pro tape?
Dak clearly dominates that.

His college tape?
Dak threw for 3 fewer INTs and 21 more TDS

On one fewer attempt.

Rosen threw 1170 college passes.
Dak threw 1169.

Better completion percentage.
More yards per attempt.
That doesn’t take into account his 41 RUSHING TDs.

At no level has josh Rosen outperformed or even performed at a comparable level to dak.

It’s simple numbers.

 

[QuincyCarterEra]

No Zeke? F-ing crazy.

Some people understand, others dont.

 

[BigCatMonaco]

Some people understand, others dont.

Remember how good Dallas was when they had a top 5 rusher in 2015?


There’s a difference between accruing yards and being a dominant running back. Zeke is the latter.

 

[Risen Star]

Ezekiel Elliott
Amari Cooper
Nick Foles
Tyrann Mathieu
Sheldon Richardson

 

[WillieBeamen]

Based on what exactly?
His pro tape?
Dak clearly dominates that.

His college tape?
Dak threw for 3 fewer INTs and 21 more TDS

On one fewer attempt.

Rosen threw 1170 college passes.
Dak threw 1169.

Better completion percentage.
More yards per attempt.
That doesn’t take into account his 41 RUSHING TDs.

At no level has josh Rosen outperformed or even performed at a comparable level to dak.

It’s simple numbers.

I can write an essay as to why I loathe Prescott as our starting QB.

But the main reason hes not included in this list is im not paying a non difference maker at QB, $30m a year. Give me Rosen on a rookie contract with the 5th year option and im good to go

 

[Rayman70]

signing Dak, Amari,Collins,ET and Zeke..short term. The others get traded or walk. the caveat is DLAW...I would tag him and he either plays or gets traded...his call.

 

[QuincyCarterEra]

Remember how good Dallas was when they had a top 5 rusher in 2015?


There’s a difference between accruing yards and being a dominant running back. Zeke is the latter.

What does that have to do with what I said? Zeke's good.

 

[TwoCentPlain]

Based on what exactly?
His pro tape?
Dak clearly dominates that.

His college tape?
Dak threw for 3 fewer INTs and 21 more TDS

On one fewer attempt.

Rosen threw 1170 college passes.
Dak threw 1169.

Better completion percentage.
More yards per attempt.
That doesn’t take into account his 41 RUSHING TDs.

At no level has josh Rosen outperformed or even performed at a comparable level to dak.

It’s simple numbers.

Everything you say is true. I am gad you took the time to school a Dak-hater. I pretty much just ignore the diehard Dak haters. It probably went in one ear and out the other @WillieBeamen

 

[WillieBeamen]

Everything you say is true. I am gad you took the time to school a Dak-hater. I pretty much just ignore the diehard Dak haters. It probably went in one ear and out the other @WillieBeamen

Read my response


Paying a non difference maker at QB $30m a year is asinine and will set this franchise back

 

[TwoCentPlain]

Read my response


Paying a non difference maker at QB $30m a year is asinine and will set this franchise back

I did. You also wrote "I can write an essay as to why I loathe Prescott as our starting QB."

 

[WillieBeamen]

I did. You also wrote "I can write an essay as to why I loathe Prescott as our starting QB."

Yes, im not a fan of his. With that said, everyone with common sense should agres that in no way should he be getting paid more money than Arod, Brady, Ryan, etc. You know, former MVPs

 

[cowboyec]

DLaw.
Dak.
Cooper.
Zeke.
Ndamukong Suh.
(trade our 7th to denver for Von Miller.)
rename AT&T...Tom Landry Stadium.


save Jones for later.
Jaylon gets his too.

 

[Nav22]

Yes, im not a fan of his. With that said, everyone with common sense should agres that in no way should he be getting paid more money than Arod, Brady, Ryan, etc. You know, former MVPs

I’m sorry that you’re not familiar with how markets work.

You think paying Dak is costly? Try having cheap scrubs at the position for the next decade.

Dak’s numbers and W/L record suggest he’s pretty good. If you disagree, you’re falling behind.

 

[BigCatMonaco]

Yes, im not a fan of his. With that said, everyone with common sense should agres that in no way should he be getting paid more money than Arod, Brady, Ryan, etc. You know, former MVPs

Not every QB is married to someone who earns more than he does. Tom has been underpaid his entire career.

 

[75boyz]

You are the Cowboys GM and you get to decide which 5 you are signing to long term contracts, the others walk. Or you can sign any other FA not on the list but you only get 5. Who you signing?

Ezekiel Elliott
Dak Prescott
Demarcus Lawrence
Byron Jones
Amari Cooper
Earl Thomas
Landon Collins
Justin Houston

Tank
Coop
Zeke
Jaylon
Tua... (Oh, never mind, hes for Draft Zone discussion...LOL, my bad!)