Apples and oranges.
Compare the caliber of defenses these quarterbacks faced over their collegiate career. Luck and Manning would have destroyed Moore's numbers against Boise State opponents.
I'm not sure if you watch college football.
Boise St. is a D-I college football. That's the top division in college football.
Below are the AP Rankings for the years Kellen Moore was at Boise St.
This is the rankings to the top college football team in the country:
Rank ............ 2008
1 ............ Florida (13–1) (48)
2 ............ Utah (13–0) (16)
3 ............ USC (12–1) (1)
4 ............ Texas (12–1)
5 ............ Oklahoma (12–2)
6 ............ Alabama (12–2)
7 ............ TCU (11–2)
8 ............ Penn State (11–2)
9 ............ Ohio State (10–3)
10 ............ Oregon (10–3)
11 ............ Boise State (12–1)
12 ............ Texas Tech (11–2)
13 ............ Georgia (10–3)
14 ............ Ole Miss (9–4)
15 ............ Virginia Tech (10–4)
16 ............ Oklahoma State (9–4)
17 ............ Cincinnati (11–3)
18 ............ Oregon State (9–4)
19 ............ Missouri (10–4)
20 ............ Iowa (9–4)
21 ............ Florida State (9–4)
22 ............ Georgia Tech (9–4)
23 ............ West Virginia (9–4)
24 ............ Michigan State (9–4)
25 ............ BYU (10–3)
Rank ............ 2009
1 ............ Alabama (14–0) (60)
2 ............ Texas (13–1)
3 ............ Florida (13–1)
4 ............ Boise State (14–0)
5 ............ Ohio State (11–2)
6 ............ TCU (12–1)
7 ............ Iowa (11–2)
8 ............ Cincinnati (12–1)
9 ............ Penn State (11–2)
10 ............ Virginia Tech (10–3)
11 ............ Oregon (10–3)
12 ............ BYU (11–2)
13 ............ Georgia Tech (11–3)
14 ............ Nebraska (10–4)
15 ............ Pittsburgh (10–3)
16 ............ Wisconsin (10–3)
17 ............ LSU (9–4)
18 ............ Utah (10–3)
19 ............ Miami (FL) (9–4)
20 ............ Ole Miss (9–4)
21 ............ Texas Tech (9–4)
22 ............ USC (9–4)
23 ............ Central Michigan (12–2)
24 ............ Clemson (9–5)
25 ............ West Virginia (9–4)
Rank ............ 2010
1 ............ Auburn (14–0) (56)
2 ............ TCU (13–0) (3)
3 ............ Oregon (12–1)
4 ............ Stanford (12–1)
5 ............ Ohio State (12–1)
6 ............ Oklahoma (12–2)
7 ............ Wisconsin (11–2)
8 ............ LSU (11–2)
9 ............ Boise State (12–1)
10 ............ Alabama (10–3)
11 ............ Nevada (13–1)
12 ............ Arkansas (10–3)
13 ............ Oklahoma State (11–2)
14 ............ Michigan State (11–2)
15 ............ Mississippi State (9–4)
16 ............ Virginia Tech (11–3)
17 ............ Florida State (10–4)
18 ............ Missouri (10–3)
19 ............ Texas A&M (9–4)
20 ............ Nebraska (10–4)
21 ............ UCF (11–3)
22 ............ South Carolina (9–5)
23 ............ Maryland (9–4)
24 ............ Tulsa (10–3)
25 ............ NC State (9–4)
Rank ............ 2011
1 ............ Alabama (12–1) (55)
2 ............ LSU (13–1) (1)
3 ............ Oklahoma State (12–1) (4)
4 ............ Oregon (12–2)
5 ............ Arkansas (11–2)
6 ............ USC (10–2)
7 ............ Stanford (11–2)
8 ............ Boise State (12–1)
9 ............ South Carolina (11–2)
10 ............ Wisconsin (11–3)
11 ............ Michigan State (11–3)
12 ............ Michigan (11–2)
13 ............ Baylor (10–3)
14 ............ TCU (11–2)
15 ............ Kansas State (10–3)
16 ............ Oklahoma (10–3)
17 ............ West Virginia (10–3)
18 ............ Houston (13–1)
19 ............ Georgia (10–4)
20 ............ Southern Miss (12–2)
21 ............ Virginia Tech (11–3)
22 ............ Clemson (10–4)
23 ............ Florida State (9–4)
24 ............ Nebraska (9–4)
25 ............ Cincinnati (10–3)