Are the Cowboys wrong to ask their players to take less?

Stash

Staff member
Messages
81,531
Reaction score
110,341
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I'm curious to see the opinions of my fellow board members on this subject?

Do you agree or disagree with the Cowboys approach and message to their players up for contract that they should take less money so that more players from the team nucleus can be kept around?
 
I'm curious to see the opinions of my fellow board members on this subject?

Do you agree or disagree with the Cowboys approach and message to their players up for contract that they should take less money so that more players from the team nucleus can be kept around?

They would be wrong not to ask them.

A player taking less money gives you an advantage.
 
Yes. Pay the players for what they are worth.

Zeke #1 RB contract. Dak #12-15 QB and not top 5 QB contract. Will save several millions by not overpaying Dak.

Get rid of the old (Witten), weak, often injured (Lee and potentially M. Collins), and drug addicts (Gregory) to free up some cap space.
 
I think very few would say they're wrong to ask through the agent. But they would be foolish to expect it. And if this question is in regards to the story about the Cowboys circumventing agents, if it is illegal according to labor laws, then I would say asking the player directly is obviously wrong.
 
No. It's in the teams best interest to not pay top dollar for everyone.
 
Yes. Pay the players for what they are worth.

Zeke #1 RB contract. Dak #12-15 QB and not top 5 QB contract. Will save several millions by not overpaying Dak.

Get rid of the old (Witten), weak, often injured (Lee and potentially M. Collins), and drug addicts (Gregory) to free up some cap space.

I don't think Gregory counts anything against the cap
 
They would be wrong not to ask them.

A player taking less money gives you an advantage.

It doesn't, and I think that in some cases, it's part of seeing a bigger picture.

Let's face it, the Cowboys have never been "cheap" when it comes to the cap and paying their players. In fact, I can name plenty of times where they could have done it and didn't.

While I realize that players play this game for money and to take care of their families, I also realize that it is in fact not the only factor involved in their career. The biggest factor? Undoubtedly. But certainly not the only one.

They also want to have success, both on the field with wins and accolades, but off the field as well, via endorsements and life after football. And that life after football constitutes much more of life than the time on it.

Let's face facts, the Joneses aren't trying to be cheap here, they're trying to keep as many players togetherness as possible under the constraints of the salary cap. They're not about to put the money in their pockets. They already have more than enough.

But if there is no compromise from any of these players, some of them are undoubtedly going to be out in the cold. Going to a lesser team, solely for money, and missing out on a lot of potential "life after football" opportunities for the sake of a few dollars more in the short term.

I don't think it's worth it.
 
giphy.gif
 
Oh course not. My philosophy (and I have passed it down to my kids), is to always ask for the favor, the free upgrade, an added perk, etc. If you don't ask, they don't have an opportunity to say yes.
 
I'm curious to see the opinions of my fellow board members on this subject?

Do you agree or disagree with the Cowboys approach and message to their players up for contract that they should take less money so that more players from the team nucleus can be kept around?
Wrong in asking? Not at all. But it's also not wrong for a player to ask for the moon.
 
Asking and saying they should are two different things. The minute they don't have use for you the team will cut you without giving you the chance to negotiate a paycut. So the players should and have to pursue as much as they possibly can.
Dallas has negotiated paycuts in the past.
10x more often, they've negotiated pay raises.
 
No, its their job & right to point out the full benefits of playing A) for THE Dallas Cowboys & B) on a team that can Contend
Playing for the Dallas Cowboys is not that attractive now for 2 reasons:

1. Players are not paid on merit. Asking them (or Zeke) to take less than what they deserve; while offering to greatly overpay the favorites (Dak).

2. The Cowboys have not won anything in 23 years and it looks like the drought will continue for several more years; based on how the Jones' are running things.
 
I'm curious to see the opinions of my fellow board members on this subject?

Do you agree or disagree with the Cowboys approach and message to their players up for contract that they should take less money so that more players from the team nucleus can be kept around?

They're not wrong for asking, but it's also not wrong for a player to want what they think they are worth.

Seeing people rip into players as "greedy" and "selfish" cracks me up. I wonder how many here have asked their employer for less, for the good of the company? I'll bet I can guess.
 
I'm curious to see the opinions of my fellow board members on this subject?

Do you agree or disagree with the Cowboys approach and message to their players up for contract that they should take less money so that more players from the team nucleus can be kept around?

As a negotiation tactic there is absolutely nothing wrong with it. I guarantee the Cowboys are not an outlier in regards to this tactic, we just have an owner/GM with loose gums.
 
Wrong in asking? Not at all. But it's also not wrong for a player to ask for the moon.

I don't think it's "wrong" for the players to ask, but I think they need to be aware that if everyone "asks for the moon", not everyone is going to get it. And in fact, someone - likely one of them - is going to be out of the picture. I hope that the players are aware of and willing to accept that fact as well.
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,578
Messages
14,546,592
Members
24,212
Latest member
JerryJonesSupporter
Back
Top