How bad do you want Garrett gone

[CB61]

I heard if Garrett gets fired he's in line to be the guy in the or the new guy in the Limu emu commercial LOL

 

[leeblair]

Just curious to other fans' thoughts on a ridiculous hypothetical.

Would you want us to shock everybody, & get to the Super Bowl this year, assuming two things:

1. Losing in the SB

2. Garrett would be resigned for at least another 5yrs.

Honestly, I think the bar is lower. I think if somehow, some way, this team makes it TO the NFC Championship, Garrett will be resigned. Even with a humiliating loss. I believe JJ & Co. have pretty much telegraphed, that is the bar.

So, what would be your preference..? Make it farther than we have in the last couple decades, knowing Garrett ain't going anywhere, or having our usual late season disappointment, & going another direction as far as coaching goes, going forward..?

I don't think the Cowboys should win a Super Bowl as long as Garrett is around. Not even a fluke-which it would be.
The coordinators would do the coaching, and Garrett would take the credit.
Just like 2016.
No. Not even a tiny bit.

 

[anava]

We could win the Super bowl and I would still want him gone.

 

[cowboy_ron]

Just curious to other fans' thoughts on a ridiculous hypothetical.

Would you want us to shock everybody, & get to the Super Bowl this year, assuming two things:

1. Losing in the SB

2. Garrett would be resigned for at least another 5yrs.

Honestly, I think the bar is lower. I think if somehow, some way, this team makes it TO the NFC Championship, Garrett will be resigned. Even with a humiliating loss. I believe JJ & Co. have pretty much telegraphed, that is the bar.

So, what would be your preference..? Make it farther than we have in the last couple decades, knowing Garrett ain't going anywhere, or having our usual late season disappointment, & going another direction as far as coaching goes, going forward..?

5 years is too long super bowl or not,..........if he lucked out and won a super bowl I could see 2 years

 

[OmerV]

Garrett needs to go. But getting rid of him and just hiring another coach without some structural and cultural changes at the top will just be a new coat of paint on the Titanic. Fans need to push for REAL change, not just a new puppet for Jerry to play with.

How do fans push for that?

 

[Kaiser]

How do fans push for that?

They start 26 new threads on it every day. Duhhh...

 

[Bobhaze]

If Garrett gets the team to the Super Bowl, he deserves to keep his job.

The reason I want him fired is because I don't believe he and his philosophy can get us there. If he proves me wrong, I'd be fine with him being re-signed.

If he gets to the NFC Championship Game, keeping him would depend on a few things. Were we competitive in the game? Were coaching errors/being outcoached a factor in the loss? Those things would need to be evaluated. I believe that whenever we lose it's not going to be because the other team had more talent but because we were outcoached.

I'd like to say it's Super Bowl or bust for him. However, since I think we'll likely lose to Philly or be ousted early from the playoffs, I don't think we'll be left in a quandary.

If pigs could fly...

 

[ICP]

What I want, is after the last game the Cowboys play this year, whatever that may be. Is to NEVER lay eyes on that red head again.

 

[Whyjerry]

Under no circumstances do I want him back. None.

 

[Praxit]

...super bowl or bust. If Garrett gets cowboys to SB, win or lose. I'll take him for 2 more years. ...

 

[gimmesix]

If pigs could fly...

Pretty much.

 

[conner01]

Only Jerry knows
But if I was making the decision it would be get to super bowl or get out

 

[willia451]

If Garrett can make it to the NFCCG he will have accomplished more than any other coach in the post-Jimmy era. Including Parcells.

That's a no-brainer in my mind.

 

[SlammedZero]

Count me in on the Super Bowl or Bust crowd. And to be honest I'm saying Super Bowl WIN for him to stay. I just think it is time for a new approach in Dallas. Garrett's shtick is long in the tooth.

 

[Hadenough]

If Garrett got this team to a SB it would be on sheer luck. Basically the team got itself there despite what Garrett does. Send him packing regardless.

 

[cowboyblue22]

I think he has reached his top level with the cowboys I want him gone want to go in another direction I just don't believe he has it in him to win a divisional playoff game and I don't believe he will

 

[MoistMayonnaise]

I don't care how far we do or don't go, Jason goes.

Even a SB win won't change my mind.

 

[big dog cowboy]

How bad do you want Garrett gone

He's still here?

 

[BrassCowboy]

As painful as a hypothetical Super Bowl win and 5 more years of JG would be..I'm happy with #6 and not looking back.

I mean, come on, it's the first in far too many disappointing seasons. Give me #6.

But he didn't say a Superbowl win... The op says Superbowl loss and JG resigned for 5 years.

 

[BrassCowboy]

I know I have said a Superbowl win or loss would be enough but I am leaning to a need for a Superbowl win only would save Garrett at this point