Best New Hire Coach of the Offseason?

DandyDon52 · Jun 11, 2020

RoboQB said:
one strong opinion the
Riverboat Ron would fail in Washington.

he may fail, but he is the best coach wash has had in many many years.
It will be harder for dallas to beat wash now.

big dog cowboy · Jun 11, 2020

McCarthy was the best choice for the Cowboys.

That's all I care about.

Diehardblues · Jun 11, 2020

sjmike said:
There were 5 new coaches hired this year:
-Matt Rhule
-Kevin Stefanski
-Joe Judge
-Ron Rivera
-Mike McCarthy
Did we get the best one or is there someone you would have rather have. Did Jerry just go for a name hire instead of the best candidate or is the best name also the best candidate. My feelings are that just moving on from Garrett is an upgrade but I also think that McCarthy brings the experience to a team that is ready to take it to the next level. Rhule is interesting but he is gonna have a learning curve as is Judge. What say you?

Ruhle is definitely a hot commodity coming out of college. Turned 2 Dormant programs around.

I think Rivera is an interesting hire in Wash. They have some pieces there which could make it interesting if their QB can play.

Judge is the unknown but coming from Pats gets the attention. A solid hire as OC should help develop Jones if he is real deal as QB , NY could be improved.

I see McCarthy as an easy hire for Jerry wanting a proven name to quite the criticism. And this HC probably inherits the most talent so expectations will be high.

MikeB80 · Jun 11, 2020

jazzcat22 said:
What?
There is nothing to tear down in Dallas as there is in Carolina.

We have a talented team, but did not have the coaching. You got what you wanted from your post. as to a new HC, new assistants, and actually a lot of young players to come up with this new coaching staff.
So this is the perfect year to do this the way they have. A QB that has improved, and will improve. Many players have not hit their prime yet.

There was a way to tear down and take a different approach with a new coach and new assistants.

Dallas signed old free agents, a troubled free agent and retread coaches so no it's not what I wanted personally.

I know this was not the conventional thinking but I wanted to see the organization become different and totally get rid of the garrett years and rebuild from the ground up.

MikeB80 · Jun 11, 2020

CowboyRoy said:
Who is the guy in NY? Whoever that moron is has to be the worst of them. Any fool that would hire Garrett to run your offense has to be the worst. Garrett will slowly weasel his way into the HC job as he undercuts him.

He most likely didn't hire him and Mara probably played a heavy hand in that.

DandyDon52 · Jun 11, 2020

I would have to say MM and he does walk into a pretty good situation.

DandyDon52 · Jun 11, 2020

MikeB80 said:
There was a way to tear down and take a different approach with a new coach and new assistants.

Dallas signed old free agents, a troubled free agent and retread coaches so no it's not what I wanted personally.

I know this was not the conventional thinking but I wanted to see the organization become different and totally get rid of the garrett years and rebuild from the ground up.

Plus the other option was the jones boys were going to not do what you would, but keep jg and all staff except the DC and def coaches.
That was the plan before they talked to mike.

CowboyRoy · Jun 11, 2020

Diehardblues said:
Ruhle is definitely a hot commodity coming out of college. Turned 2 Dormant programs around.

I think Rivera is an interesting hire in Wash. They have some pieces there which could make it interesting if their QB can play.

Judge is the unknown but coming from Pats gets the attention. A solid hire as OC should help develop Jones if he is real deal as QB , NY could be improved.

I see McCarthy as an easy hire for Jerry wanting a proven name to quite the criticism. And this HC probably inherits the most talent so expectations will be high.

A solid hire at OC? You mean your hero Garrett?

RoboQB · Jun 11, 2020

DandyDon52 said:
he may fail, but he is the best coach wash has had in many many years.
It will be harder for dallas to beat wash now.

I've long had a theory involving the Commanders new players and coaches in
the DC area. It's a bad mix for certain personalities. It wasn't always that way.
I think it changed when DeSean Jackson went there. I know he's long gone
but there's something there that remained when he left. I can't quite put it into words.
(Full disclosure: I live in the area and despise the Commanders)

I agree that he's a good coach, and maybe he turns the team around, but the
vibe in his new city is much different than the Carolinas.

DandyDon52 · Jun 11, 2020

RoboQB said:
I've long had a theory involving the Commanders new players and coaches in
the DC area. It's a bad mix for certain personalities. It wasn't always that way.
I think it changed when DeSean Jackson went there. I know he's long gone
but there's something there that remained when he left. I can't quite put it into words.
(Full disclosure: I live in the area and despise the Commanders)

I agree that he's a good coach, and maybe he turns the team around, but the
vibe in his new city is much different than the Carolinas.

Sounds like maybe u should move to the dallas area? :thumbup:

But what u are talking about , could that stem from the owner Synder?
I dont like him as a owner :thumbdown:

, and the Commanders havent been good since he bought the team.

J-man · Jun 11, 2020

I'll say big Mike was the best choice for Dallas.
I think Judge is in trouble now that JG is there. could cause tensions in the locker room if things go badly early on
River boat Ron will clash hard with the idiot running the skins into the ground.
Kevin Stefanski is with the Browns for Pete's sake. poor guy, almost feel sorry for him.
Rhule is interesting, but I think for Dallas he was the longest shot with the deepest home run potential, but too much of a long shot to take with this team.

RoboQB · Jun 11, 2020

DandyDon52 said:
Sounds like maybe u should move to the dallas area?
But what u are talking about , could that stem from the owner Synder?
I dont like him as a owner , and the Commanders havent been good since he bought the team.

Yes, I agree.Snyder is the common denominator in my theory.
He's a terrible owner.

I'd love to live near Dallas. Maybe someday.

Blast From The Past · Jun 12, 2020

stasheroo said:
We got the one that’s coached a team to a Super Bowl victory so that gives us the edge in my opinion.

Unless you believe in history. I hope MM beats the odds and becomes the first. I love whoever coaches the Cowboys until they don't. Then I may only like them. lol

Texas2Step41 · Jun 12, 2020

I know you’re talking about HCs but Bones as ST coordinator will do wonders to the dumpster fire we’ve had the last few seasons

Big_D · Jun 12, 2020

CowboyRoy said:
A solid hire at OC? You mean your hero Garrett?

very weird. Some still think he was a good OC. Stats don’t tell the whole story! He took over a top tier offense in 2007 and they were a complete dumpster fire by 2010. The 2009 playoff game against Minnesota was a joke.

Stash · Jun 12, 2020

CowboyRoy said:
A solid hire at OC? You mean your hero Garrett?

Stash · Jun 12, 2020

Big_D said:
very weird. Some still think he was a good OC. Stats don’t tell the whole story! He took over a top tier offense in 2007 and they were a complete dumpster fire by 2010. The 2009 playoff game against Minnesota was a joke.

A myth perpetrated by his few, remaining supporters (the 4 of them anyway). They count on people accepting what they say without actually looking things up.

Direwolf63 · Jun 12, 2020

sjmike said:
There were 5 new coaches hired this year:
-Matt Rhule
-Kevin Stefanski
-Joe Judge
-Ron Rivera
-Mike McCarthy
Did we get the best one or is there someone you would have rather have. Did Jerry just go for a name hire instead of the best candidate or is the best name also the best candidate. My feelings are that just moving on from Garrett is an upgrade but I also think that McCarthy brings the experience to a team that is ready to take it to the next level. Rhule is interesting but he is gonna have a learning curve as is Judge. What say you?

Of those 5 I would have taken Rhule

But compared to the clown show from last year, any of those would have been a dramatic improvement

CowboyRoy · Jun 13, 2020

Big_D said:
very weird. Some still think he was a good OC. Stats don’t tell the whole story! He took over a top tier offense in 2007 and they were a complete dumpster fire by 2010. The 2009 playoff game against Minnesota was a joke.

the same troll got done telling me he didn’t think Garrett was a good game day coach or play caller. But.......he’s a good oc? Lol

Whirlwin · Jun 13, 2020

As long as we get special teams fixed. We only started one drive on the opponents side of the field last season

Best New Hire Coach of the Offseason?

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member

MikeB80

Well-Known Member

MikeB80

Well-Known Member

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member

RoboQB

Well-Known Member

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member

J-man

Well-Known Member

RoboQB

Well-Known Member

Blast From The Past

Well-Known Member

Texas2Step41

Well-Known Member

Big_D

Well-Known Member

Stash

Stash

Direwolf63

RXP

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member

Whirlwin

Cowboy , It’s a way of life.