Twitter: Rush is 6th in QB Rating

Calvin2Tony2Emmitt2Julius

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,648
Reaction score
1,922
How!!!??? it is good to see Cooper Rush get the shine he deserves. He's worked his *** off for it. Look I'm not the type to let knuckle draggin neaderthals and their agendas

Taint how I see things. Cooper Rush is doing his thing and We ARE damn lucky to have him. I'll talk about Dak when he returns

Screw em all It's Cooper Rush all day every day. IT'S HIS TIME TO SHINE

Let's go Cowboys
 

MyFairLady

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,434
Reaction score
6,582
QBR is a much more accurate analytic
Not sure if I would agree it would depend on what it is you are interested in. QBR seems to be a more modern system that encompasses the threat of the QB run. Quarterback rating is still the better indicator of how well a player can throw the ball compared to his peers.
 

USArmyVet

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,708
Reaction score
15,031
Cooper Rush is the Dallas equivalent of Trent Dilfer when he was with the Ravens.
He didn't have a big arm and came in to 'manage' the games given the Ravens had a top rushing attack and stout defense. Dilfer went 7-1 and led the Ravens to the Super Bowl.
Obviously I am not saying that is what Rush will do but Rush has shown that the best approach for this team isn't a QB that passes for near 600 attempts but rather a QB that manages the game, avoids mistakes, and allows the rushing game and defense to control the game.
 

MWH1967

The Cook
Messages
7,051
Reaction score
9,381
System QB that no one has a ton of tape on and a really good defense playing so, so teams.

Perfect storm.
 

aikemirv

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,219
Reaction score
9,721
He really has played well. We are fortunate no one else picked him up off waivers.
He was not going anywhere. He knew the Cowboys wanted him back and what backup in their right mind would want to learn a new offense?
 

Smith22

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,505
Reaction score
1,074
You can tell he is growing more comfortable with the offense week by week, I just feel he is a bit limited with his arm strength.
 

Smith22

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,505
Reaction score
1,074
Cooper Rush is the Dallas equivalent of Trent Dilfer when he was with the Ravens.
He didn't have a big arm and came in to 'manage' the games given the Ravens had a top rushing attack and stout defense. Dilfer went 7-1 and led the Ravens to the Super Bowl.
Obviously I am not saying that is what Rush will do but Rush has shown that the best approach for this team isn't a QB that passes for near 600 attempts but rather a QB that manages the game, avoids mistakes, and allows the rushing game and defense to control the game.
Pretty decent comparison, especially with the arm strength.
 

USArmyVet

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,708
Reaction score
15,031
I will be very curious what happens when Dak is ready to go in terms of how he approaches the offense and if there is a major shift in performance (aka more passing attempts and less rushing).
 

Aerolithe_Lion

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,869
Reaction score
11,841
Not sure if I would agree it would depend on what it is you are interested in. QBR seems to be a more modern system that encompasses the threat of the QB run. Quarterback rating is still the better indicator of how well a player can throw the ball compared to his peers.

Maybe, maybe not. Problem is throwing the ball isn’t the sole purpose of a QB, and even then there are metrics that passer rating ignores.

Passer Rating:

Number of attempts completed, yards thrown with those completions, whether those completions became touchdowns or interceptions. That’s it. Anything else the player is doing is ignored. Anything. For Instance….

Sacks

On Sunday, Carson Wentz was 25 for 43 for 211 yards. No turnovers, completed over 50% of his passes, so passer rating is fine with it. But he was also sacked 9 times. Part of this was on his Oline, can’t talk about sacks without starting with Oline, but a lot of it was on him. How long he was holding on to the ball is insane, that’s a QBR stat.



Those sacks repeatedly took them out of convertible 2nd and 3rd down opportunities, absolutely costing them the game; and passer rating does not care because it’s not “throwing the football.”


Competition

If you were to throw 6 TDs against the Buffalo Bills, that’d be a wildly impressive feat, right? Equally as impressive as throwing 6 TDs against the NY Jets? Passer Rating doesn’t care. A TD is a touchdown, and they’re all equally easy regardless of game circumstance or opponents. Those are QBR stats. Home or Away, top defense or bad defense, 1st quarter tied or 4th quarter down by 2: QBR factors in every single one of those things.

Smart QB Plays

Its 3rd and long on your opponent’s 30 and you’re down by 2. The defense goes all out blitz and you can’t find your guy right away… what do you do? Passer rating says don’t you dare throw that ball away, that’s an incompletion and that means you’re a bad QB. Take the sack, take your team out of field goal range, preserve your rating. What if you’re down by 4 and you’re on the 50 with 3 seconds left? We need to kneel to accept the loss, because if I throw a Hail Mary and get intercepted, thatll kill my nice passer rating on the day. Why would intentionally hurting your passer rating be a good thing? Because it’s not a particularly well thought-out stat. QBR factors for all of this.


Running the Ball

You brought this one up, it is part of QBR yes. But the problem with neglecting it is that running is a part of QB play today. What teams have QBs who never run? Rodgers runs. Dak runs. Wentz runs. Garoppolo runs. That guy in Tampa who was drafted in 2000 doesn’t run. That is the era passer rating was built for.

Scenario: A team is down by 3 at the end of the game, runs on first down, and then the rush is on so the QB has to throw it away on second down. On third and long, there’s an opening up the middle, so he takes off for 15 yards. First down again, bad pass rush, throw the ball away. Second down, RB up the middle for 9 yards. Timeout. Third down, QB sneak. Timeout. Close to field goal range. 1st and 10, quick WR out route for 6 yards, goes out of bounds. 2nd down, deep incompletion trying to end it right there. Third down, roll out scramble to the right side, hit WR on the sideline for 5 yards, get out of bounds, kick the field goal, win the game.

We’ve seen drive win the game like this all the time. Passer Rating conclusion: 2 for 5, 11 yards, 0.0 rating. You had the worst drive ever recorded, and you likely cost your team the game. QBR conclusion: it was a 2 minute drill in the 4th quarter, you converted 3 first downs with you arm and with your legs, got your team into field goal range with time left on the clock, excellent drive.

The problem with Passer rating isn’t that it ignores running stats, the problem is it ignore everything; every single tiny bit of context is completely irrelevant as long as you’re hitting your deep bombs when you’re down by 30.
 
Top