Dak vs. Wentz

Captain-Crash

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,500
Reaction score
33,756
well I see what your saying, I prefer to judge dak based on how he plays and decisions he makes, and I dont like to compare qb's.
Dak has been from real bad to real good, it varys, lets wait and see if that continues, or if MM can get him to be good more consistently.

I see all qb's throw bad passes, and fumble or get stripped, sacked, do stupid stuff, but the key is to not do very much of that and be consistent.
Also in crunch time they need to be their best.
The thing I like about dak is he doesnt get hurt, is hard to bring down, can run fairly good, and he tries hard to be as good as he can.
His passing needs work, like I said that can be great to bad.
I want to see what he looks like this next season.

I also think many of our players may be much better this next season. A lot of things will be better, it all adds up.
better schemes can make a weak quarterback look better, but when he comes up against better defenses how much will that matter?
I don't hate dak, I just don't like him not getting any blame for bad games and blaming other quarterbacks who doesn't get this option.
 

BrAinPaiNt

Backwoods Sexy
Staff member
Messages
77,832
Reaction score
40,651
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
READ CAREFULLY

Some of you need to stop arguing with the name calling and personal insults.
There is no need for it and you know better.
Knock it off or you will be benched.
If you don't like each other, put the other on ignore and be done with it since it does not seem like you can control yourself with the silly insults and name calling.
 

Ken

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,530
Reaction score
17,178
Dude, its my scenario! You can't write a rule that gets him hurt before the 4th quarter 2:00 minute warning!
Nobody is out there trying to fumble or throw interceptions. Bad bounces/bad breaks happen every week.
Hopefully you learn from it and don't put yourself in the same situation.
Carry on lol
 

C42

Well-Known Member
Messages
859
Reaction score
454
Yes, a guy that was the No. 2 overall pick, who has been paid 100x more than Dak, whose team WON A DAMN SB WITHOUT HIM, and who still has a losing record vs. Dak...

It is just SAD that Carson Wentz isn't way better than Dak. Just completely pathetic for all the resources and advantages given to Wentz. Just grossly pathetic.
Lmao you’re the guy posing as a Panthers fan to defend Dak on another site. It’s that important to you, why?

EDIT: Apologies in advance if I’m wrong but I feel I’ve seen that name before.
 
Last edited:

Ranched

"We Are Penn State"
Messages
34,885
Reaction score
84,323
3lo8xc.jpg
https://imgflip.com/memegenerator
 

Pola_pe_a

Well-Known Member
Messages
972
Reaction score
829
Except he finished 2 seasons. Rookie year and this year.

Troy Aikman played 16 games 3 times in 12 seasons
Romo- 4 out of the 10 seasons he was a starter

I guess those guys were soft also.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: C42

C42

Well-Known Member
Messages
859
Reaction score
454
Except he finished 2 seasons. Rookie year and this year.

Troy Aikman played 16 games 3 times in 12 seasons
Romo- 4 out of the 10 seasons he was a starter

I guess those guys were soft also.
"Yea but Aikman sniffed smelling salts tho!!" - @Nav22 :rolleyes:
 

CB61

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,311
Reaction score
5,901
I know earlier in the season a lot of people were talking trash about Wentz and about how bad he looked. I include myself in that category because early in the season he did look bad. But look at him now. He threw for 4000 yards but not a single receiver on the Eagles team had more than 500. That is a pretty amazing stat. In his last few games Wentz was making his no name receivers look pretty good. The Eagles were running practice squad guys out there at RB, WR, and TE and Wentz was putting up a lot of yards and points.

Give credit where credit it due. The Eagles seem to come through when the chips are down while the Cowboys fold. Wentz is one of those guys who proved he can put a team on his shoulders and win games. That's what we need out of Dak instead of that miserable performance against the Eagles.
I'm not sure about his durability though but you're spot-on about him I think asking Cowboy fans and him being an eagle automatically makes him trash LOL but if I were the Eagles I would be definitely concerned with his durability and I'm not talking about the concussion he got in the playoffs either
 

CB61

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,311
Reaction score
5,901
Shows how much the OP knows......Prescott is Far ahead of Wentz in endorsements and commercial money earned.
Well see right there might be some of the problem with the players today they're more worried about money than winning I've stated several times that I would give my left one or my right one (as people have pointed out here asking me why not the right one) to play in the NFL and my lottery would be the Super Bowl I wouldn't need 50 gold chains or gold cleats or horseshoe coming out of my nose
 

GORICO

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,471
Reaction score
8,494
CowboysZone DIEHARD Fan
I know earlier in the season a lot of people were talking trash about Wentz and about how bad he looked. I include myself in that category because early in the season he did look bad. But look at him now. He threw for 4000 yards but not a single receiver on the Eagles team had more than 500. That is a pretty amazing stat. In his last few games Wentz was making his no name receivers look pretty good. The Eagles were running practice squad guys out there at RB, WR, and TE and Wentz was putting up a lot of yards and points.

Give credit where credit it due. The Eagles seem to come through when the chips are down while the Cowboys fold. Wentz is one of those guys who proved he can put a team on his shoulders and win games. That's what we need out of Dak instead of that miserable performance against the Eagles.

can't disagree
 

Proof

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,915
Reaction score
13,768
Wentz is the better player. Dallas had a make shift receiving corps to start 2018 and we all saw the results which led to a trade for Amari Cooper. Yes Prescott improved a lot going into 2019 and it showed early. But, does anyone honestly believe Prescott gets the Eagles to the playoffs with all those injured WRs and RBs? And does anyone believe Dallas misses the playoffs if Wentz is QB from the Minnesota game on?

Trying to be objective would help...doesn't mean Prescott is not good or is worthless, it just means that someone is a better player.

you seem to confuse objectivity with agreeing with your opinion. I think it’s clear, and has been clear for some time now that Dak is the superior player and that objectively the only argument is a knee jerk one based on the past month.

I can admit that what wentz and the eagles accomplished to end the season with the walking wounded was highly impressive, but I honestly give more of the credit to pederson.
 

JoeKing

Diehard
Messages
35,557
Reaction score
31,022
I know earlier in the season a lot of people were talking trash about Wentz and about how bad he looked. I include myself in that category because early in the season he did look bad. But look at him now. He threw for 4000 yards but not a single receiver on the Eagles team had more than 500. That is a pretty amazing stat. In his last few games Wentz was making his no name receivers look pretty good. The Eagles were running practice squad guys out there at RB, WR, and TE and Wentz was putting up a lot of yards and points.

Give credit where credit it due. The Eagles seem to come through when the chips are down while the Cowboys fold. Wentz is one of those guys who proved he can put a team on his shoulders and win games. That's what we need out of Dak instead of that miserable performance against the Eagles.
Way to disregard the one ability that Wince proved he does not have once again and that is reliability. He gets hurt and can not finish what he started. By the way, that is something Dak has never had a problem with. You cherry-pick one game to praise Wince and tear down Dak but if you compare their seasons as a whole, Dak had the much better season. It's a team-oriented sport so look elsewhere if you want to point a finger at why the Cowboys did not make the playoffs.
 

Proof

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,915
Reaction score
13,768
If you are going to quote stats get them right. Quoting one seasons stats when the Eagles lost every starting WR is disingenuous.

Career YPA- Dak 7.6. Wentz. 6.9.

Look at Dak in ‘17 when he had bad WRs his YPA was well below Wentz.


So overall Dak still considerably higher lol. Thanks for highlighting that my guy. You’re doing gods work
 

RJ_MacReady

It's all in the reflexes
Messages
3,952
Reaction score
7,084
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
"Yea but Aikman sniffed smelling salts tho!!" - @Nav22 :rolleyes:
Good point. Your boy didn’t even give that a try before running (arms to his side) to the nearest sideline physician, begging his way out of a big game.

He ain’t built for 90’s football, obviously, but now we see that he isn’t even able to control his **** during this QB friendly era.

Does the league need to event another nerf rule like they did for Brady with the “lower leg” rule? Maybe put a belt with flags on it for the ole’ neck boils ginger?
 

slick325

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,118
Reaction score
8,811
you seem to confuse objectivity with agreeing with your opinion. I think it’s clear, and has been clear for some time now that Dak is the superior player and that objectively the only argument is a knee jerk one based on the past month.

I can admit that what wentz and the eagles accomplished to end the season with the walking wounded was highly impressive, but I honestly give more of the credit to pederson.

You're entitled to your opinion as I am mine.
 

LatinMind

iPhotoshop
Messages
17,430
Reaction score
11,554
I know earlier in the season a lot of people were talking trash about Wentz and about how bad he looked. I include myself in that category because early in the season he did look bad. But look at him now. He threw for 4000 yards but not a single receiver on the Eagles team had more than 500. That is a pretty amazing stat. In his last few games Wentz was making his no name receivers look pretty good. The Eagles were running practice squad guys out there at RB, WR, and TE and Wentz was putting up a lot of yards and points.

Give credit where credit it due. The Eagles seem to come through when the chips are down while the Cowboys fold. Wentz is one of those guys who proved he can put a team on his shoulders and win games. That's what we need out of Dak instead of that miserable performance against the Eagles.
Wentz in a playoff game stinks it up gets hurt, his backup comes in and gives the Eagles hope. Thats been his M.O since he's been in the NFL. All of the Eagles success has come with him injuried not with him.
 

LatinMind

iPhotoshop
Messages
17,430
Reaction score
11,554
Not to mention Half of his yrds went to 3 players and the players who the offense runs through Ertz, Geodert, and Sanders. In the eagles offense Wrs are their luxury. The offense isnt running through them. They are the Hot read. The offense is flowing through their TEs and RB.
 
Top