5 Super Bowl winning QBs this weekend

mahoneybill

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,912
Reaction score
4,528
Joe Flacco 1
Tom Brady 3*
Peyton Manning 1
Russell Wilson 1
Aaron Rodgers 1


Just watched Jerry on Mike and Mike.

"We have to get Romo a Super Bowl ring"

Wish they would have added " Super Bowl Winning Teams". It's not all about the QB. They don't face the other 11 by themselves.....

That said Tony deserves to become part of that QB circle.
 

Venger

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,661
Reaction score
788
Wish they would have added " Super Bowl Winning Teams".

So who constitutes that? We've won 5, do we count now? Because this team hasn't won squat.

But Manning has. But his current team - squat. But the Broncos have in the past. The point is the most important position on the team is occupied by a guy who has won it all.
 

LittleBoyBlue

Redvolution
Messages
35,766
Reaction score
8,411
It has to be...

Romo is as good as it gets. Put him on any one of those other teams, and he wins and goes down as possibly the best ever...

It has to be...

Romo is as good as it gets. Put him on any one of those other teams, and he wins and goes down as possibly the best ever...

It's crazy.

I agree he can be "as good as it gets"...

It was possible that he could go down as "one of the best ever".....

Now, we just have to get him ONE Super Bowl... That's a start!
 

Roadtrip635

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,833
Reaction score
28,187
It's crazy.

I agree he can be "as good as it gets"...

It was possible that he could go down as "one of the best ever".....

Now, we just have to get him ONE Super Bowl... That's a start!

Yep, need to get him a ring and all that criticism goes away. The "Race For Seis"
 

mahoneybill

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,912
Reaction score
4,528
So who constitutes that? We've won 5, do we count now? Because this team hasn't won squat.

But Manning has. But his current team - squat. But the Broncos have in the past. The point is the most important position on the team is occupied by a guy who has won it all.

My point is that all of the teams have the opportunity to add to their wins.

This is a team accomplishment, that at times gets totally credited to the QB.

To me I'd like to see Tony join that group and the other Cowboy QB's who share the honor of being the QB of a Super Bowl winning team
 

LittleBoyBlue

Redvolution
Messages
35,766
Reaction score
8,411
Wish they would have added " Super Bowl Winning Teams". It's not all about the QB. They don't face the other 11 by themselves.....

That said Tony deserves to become part of that QB circle.

Think about it... If I put Super Bowl winning teams then the number goes up by two because you have to include the cowboys and the colts
 

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member
Messages
54,312
Reaction score
32,716
Joe Flacco 1
Tom Brady 3*
Peyton Manning 1
Russell Wilson 1
Aaron Rodgers 1


Just watched Jerry on Mike and Mike.

"We have to get Romo a Super Bowl ring"

Also heard Jerry say he was interested in two things when he bought the Cowboys franchise.

1. Making money off his investment
2. Learning how to coach.

From the horse's mouth. :laugh:
 

LittleBoyBlue

Redvolution
Messages
35,766
Reaction score
8,411
Also heard Jerry say he was interested in two things when he bought the Cowboys franchise.

1. Making money off his investment
2. Learning how to coach.

From the horse's mouth. :laugh:

Yeah I heard that...
Then... I tried the Jedi mind trick on MYSELF.

DIdnt work .... Lmao....not his guy is nuts... Still love him though
 

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member
Messages
54,312
Reaction score
32,716
Think about it... If I put Super Bowl winning teams then the number goes up by two because you have to include the cowboys and the colts

I thought about that too.

Super Bowl winning teams (and appearances)

Baltimore - 2 (2)
New England - 3 (7)
Denver - 2 (7)
Dallas - 5 (8)
Green Bay 4 (5)
Indy 2* (3*)
Carolina 0 (1)


*includes when they were the Baltimore Colts
 
Last edited:

LittleBoyBlue

Redvolution
Messages
35,766
Reaction score
8,411
I thought about that too.

Super Bowl winning teams (and appearances)

Baltimore - 2 (2)
New England - 3 (7)
Denver - 2 (6)
Dallas - 5 (8)
Green Bay 4 (5)
Indy 2* (3*)
Carolina 0 (1)


*includes when they were the Baltimore Colts

Broncos 2 wins 5 loses = 7 total


Yeah that baltimore one should go in our column.
 

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member
Messages
54,312
Reaction score
32,716
Honestly, if Romo wins a Super Bowl, I'd say he turned out to be what Favre should have been. Favre FINALLY won a Super Bowl because the Cowboys started to slide because of the loss of Jimmy Johnson. I'm pretty convinced - though I have no way to prove this so this is mere speculation - that if Jimmy doesn't leave, the Packers never advance past the Cowboys. Favre was just too reckless. But with the void that the Cowboys created when its dynasty started to dismantle, the Packers filled that void.

Favre won a Super Bowl against a pretty weak Patriots team - weak relatively speaking.

But Favre should have played in far more Super Bowls, but he had a penchant for recklessness and always threw critical interceptions at the worst times. He should have at least three more Super Bowl appearances.

If Romo breaks through and if his health/back holds out and if he sips from the Fountain of Youth like Favre did, I could see with his maturity the Cowboys getting to multiple Super Bowls. He just needs to get over the hump. But I would compare Romo to Favre minus the ring. But I still don't consider Favre the greatest quarterback ever, though he's in the top 15, maybe 10 but I really haven't considered ranking them.
 

mattjames2010

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,838
Reaction score
20,694
One of the best is different than THE best.

And that could be debated as well, if you got by QB rating. It would be either he or Rodgers. Me, personally, it's Rodgers. I'm not sure the game has ever seen a QB as sharp as him before.
 
Top