Because as long as he is here, we are good for 9-12 wins. Being a playoff team is that all that has mattered to the organization for the past 20 years. The Jones arent going to give up a safe playoff birth for an unknown. Its not imprortant how far we go, its just getting there and maintaining a degree of national relevance.
"Good enough" is why we hired McCarthy without giving anyone else a serious interview. "Good enough " is why McCarthy is still here after another playoff failure. Thats also what Prescott means to this organization. I believe those that think there is a chance he wont get extended will be very disappointed. We will have Prescott until we cant win 10 games with him anymore
I think every fan should know by now its almost a foregone conclusion Dak will be extended. He's a good QB, a bad one wouldn't win as many games as he has. However, he's too inconsistent in the biggest games to be relied on alone just like Romo. He's had 5 chances in the playoffs and whether if its the 1st or 2nd game the losing effort looks similiar. Certainly the coaches shoulder blame for a bad gameplan, but the best QBs find a way to give their teams a chance.
The biggest problem in all this is Dak's looming contract likely to be 50 to 60 million a year is just too much for a player that doesn't deliver in the playoffs. Its difficult to fathom because I firmly believe Dak helped the Cowboys be net positive 2-3 games in the regular season to get them there. However, come playoffs there's lots of average and below QBs that could have turned in a similar performance for a fraction of the cost where you can reallocate funds to get better elsewhere.
I just don't think Dak is worth the cost of a high end pass rusher + cb1 + WR2, or any combo of 2 to 3 elite to very good players you could have instead.