All time QB rating top 10 list

[CowboyRoy]

1 Aaron Rodgers 104.93
2 Steve Young* 96.81
3 Tom Brady 96.62
4 Peyton Manning 95.71
5 Tony Romo 95.62
6 Philip Rivers 94.53
7 Drew Brees 94.27
8 Kurt Warner 93.71
9 Ben Roethlisberger 92.69
10 Joe Montana* 92.26

Nice to see Romo on there. At 97.3 QB rating Dak would be #2 all time if he continues his current pace.

 

[Mr_Slicky]

I'm curious how many years Romo played behind a terrible O-line.

 

[big dog cowboy]

At 97.3 QB rating Dak would be #2 all time if he continues his current pace.

Dak haters won't like that.

 

[terra]

The all time passing rating is increasingly useless when comparing past and present players. With all the rule changes the NFL has made in the last 40 years (starting in 1978) passer rating has climbed almost geometrically.
It is telling that Montana who played from 79-94, is still on the list. When he retired I think Staubach was #1. OR close to it. Now he barely makes the top 20 I bet.


https://www.profootballhof.com/all-time-passer-rating/

I found this. Roger is at #28 behind such all time greats as David Garrard and Marc Bulger.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

This list is not correct.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

The all time passing rating is increasingly useless when comparing past and present players. With all the rule changes the NFL has made in the last 40 years (starting in 1978) passer rating has climbed almost geometrically.
It is telling that Montana who played from 79-94, is still on the list. When he retired I think Staubach was #1. OR close to it. Now he barely makes the top 20 I bet.


https://www.profootballhof.com/all-time-passer-rating/

I found this. Roger is at #28 behind such all time greats as David Garrard and Marc Bulger.

That list is not correct. Here's a correct list.

https://www.footballdb.com/leaders/career-passing-rating

 

[Jarntt]

Dak haters won't like that.

While I personally bring this point up when Dak is criticized as not being any good and think it is telling, It's a different world nowadays. Mahomes career rating is 108.7. I remember Bob Griese used to be around the league leaders a lot of the time and his career rating is 77.1.

That being said, Dak is tied for 7th. Still pretty darn good. Where did you get your numbers? Brees in particular seems off

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/leaders/pass_rating_career.htm

 

[CowboyRoy]

This list is not correct.

My list didnt include more recent QB's.

But you got me..........Dak is tied with Brady for 7th all time, not 2nd.

 

[Captain-Crash]

Rank Player Rate Years Tm
1 Patrick Mahomes 108.7 2017-2020 kan
2 Deshaun Watson 104.5 2017-2020 htx
3 Aaron Rodgers 103.9 2005-2020 gnb
4 Russell Wilson 101.7 2012-2020 sea
5 Drew Brees 98.7 2001-2020 2TM
6 Kirk Cousins 97.9 2012-2020 2TM
7 Tom Brady 97.3 2000-2020 2TM
Dak Prescott 97.3 2016-2020 dal
9 Tony Romo 97.1 2004-2016 dal
10 Steve Young+ 96.8 1985-1999 2TM
11 Peyton Manning+ 96.5 1998-2015 2TM
12 Philip Rivers 95.2 2004-2020 2TM
13 Matt Ryan 94.5 2008-2020 atl
14 Ben Roethlisberger 94.0 2004-2020 pit
15 Kurt Warner+ 93.7 1998-2009 3TM
16 Joe Montana+ 92.3 1979-1994 2TM
17 Derek Carr 92.1 2014-2020 rai
18 Ryan Tannehill 92.0 2012-2020 2TM
19 Jared Goff 91.5 2016-2020 ram
20 Chad Pennington 90.1 2000-2010 2TM
Rank Player Rate Years Tm
21 Matthew Stafford 89.9 2009-2020 det
22 Teddy Bridgewater 89.5 2014-2020 3TM
Andrew Luck 89.5 2012-2018 clt
Marcus Mariota 89.5 2015-2020 2TM
Matt Schaub 89.5 2004-2020 4TM
26 Carson Wentz 89.2 2016-2020 phi
27 Baker Mayfield 89.1 2018-2020 cle
28 Colin Kaepernick 88.9 2011-2016 sfo
29 Carson Palmer 87.9 2004-2017 3TM
30 Daunte Culpepper 87.8 1999-2009 4TM
31 Andy Dalton 87.5 2011-2020 2TM
Jeff Garcia 87.5 1999-2009 5TM
33 Mitchell Trubisky 87.2 2017-2020 chi
34 Nick Foles 87.1 2012-2020 5TM
35 Alex Smith 86.9 2005-2020 3TM
Jameis Winston 86.9 2015-2020 2TM
37 Otto Graham+ 86.6 1946-1955 cle
38 Dan Marino+ 86.4 1983-1999 mia
39 Brett Favre+ 86.0 1991-2010 4TM
Trent Green 86.0 1997-2008 4TM
Rank Player Rate Years Tm
41 David Garrard 85.8 2002-2010 jax
Cam Newton 85.8 2011-2020 2TM
43 Donovan McNabb 85.6 1999-2011 3TM
44 Jay Cutler 85.3 2006-2017 3TM
45 Case Keenum 85.2 2012-2020 6TM
46 Rich Gannon 84.7 1987-2004 4TM
47 Sam Bradford 84.5 2010-2018 4TM
48 Marc Bulger 84.4 2002-2009 ram
Jim Kelly+ 84.4 1986-1996 buf
50 Joe Flacco 84.1 2008-2020 3TM
Eli Manning 84.1 2004-2019 nyg
52 Mark Brunell 84.0 1994-2011 5TM
53 Roger Staubach+ 83.4 1969-1979 dal
54 Steve McNair 82.8 1995-2007 2TM
55 Brian Griese 82.7 1998-2008 4TM
Neil Lomax 82.7 1981-1988 crd
57 Len Dawson+ 82.6 1957-1975 3TM
Sonny Jurgensen+ 82.6 1957-1974 2TM
59 Brad Johnson 82.5 1994-2008 4TM
60 Matt Hasselbeck 82.4 1999-2015 4TM
Rank Player Rate Years Tm
61 Ryan Fitzpatrick 82.3 2005-2020 8TM
62 Brian Hoyer 82.1 2009-2020 7TM
63 Ken Anderson 81.9 1971-1986 cin
64 Bernie Kosar 81.8 1985-1996 3TM
Neil O'Donnell 81.8 1991-2003 4TM
66 Jason Campbell 81.7 2006-2014 5TM
Danny White 81.7 1976-1988 dal
68 Troy Aikman+ 81.6 1989-2000 dal
69 Randall Cunningham 81.5 1985-2001 4TM
Dave Krieg 81.5 1980-1998 6TM
71 Jake Delhomme 81.3 1999-2011 4TM
72 Kyle Orton 81.2 2005-2014 5TM
73 Boomer Esiason 81.1 1984-1997 3TM
74 Warren Moon+ 80.9 1984-2000 4TM
75 Blake Bortles 80.6 2014-2019 2TM
76 Jeff Hostetler 80.5 1985-1997 3TM
Bart Starr+ 80.5 1956-1971 gnb
78 Jeff George 80.4 1990-2001 5TM
Ken O'Brien 80.4 1984-1993 2TM
Fran Tarkenton+ 80.4 1961-1978 2TM
Rank Player Rate Years Tm
Michael Vick 80.4 2001-2015 4TM
82 Steve Beuerlein 80.3 1988-2003 6TM
83 Dan Fouts+ 80.2 1973-1987 sdg
84 John Elway+ 79.9 1983-1998 den
85 Tony Eason 79.7 1983-1990 2TM
Josh McCown 79.7 2002-2019 9TM
87 Elvis Grbac 79.6 1994-2001 3TM
88 Chris Chandler 79.1 1988-2004 7TM
89 Byron Leftwich 78.9 2003-2012 4TM
Mark Rypien 78.9 1988-2001 5TM
91 Jim Everett 78.6 1986-1997 3TM
92 Aaron Brooks 78.5 2000-2006 2TM
Matt Cassel 78.5 2005-2018 7TM
Phil Simms 78.5 1979-1993 nyg
95 Bert Jones 78.2 1973-1982 2TM
Jim McMahon 78.2 1982-1996 6TM
Johnny Unitas+ 78.2 1956-1973 2TM
98 Jeff Blake 78.0 1992-2005 7TM
Bobby Hebert 78.0 1985-1996 2TM
100 Josh Freeman 77.6 2009-2015 3TM
Rank Player Rate Years Tm
Jim Harbaugh 77.6 1987-2000 4TM
Frank Ryan 77.6 1958-1970 3TM
103 Jon Kitna 77.4 1997-2011 4TM
Joe Theismann 77.4 1974-1985 was
105 Charlie Batch 77.2 1998-2012 2TM
106 Drew Bledsoe 77.1 1993-2006 3TM
Jay Fiedler 77.1 1995-2005 5TM
Bob Griese+ 77.1 1967-1980 mia
109 Bill Kenney 77.0 1980-1988 kan
110 Gary Danielson 76.6 1976-1988 2TM
Erik Kramer 76.6 1987-1999 4TM
112 Doug Flutie 76.3 1986-2005 4TM
113 Chad Henne 76.1 2008-2020 3TM
114 Stan Humphries 75.8 1989-1997 2TM
115 Wade Wilson 75.6 1981-1998 5TM
116 Steve Bartkowski 75.4 1975-1986 2TM
117 Steve Bono 75.3 1985-1999 7TM
Scott Mitchell 75.3 1991-2001 4TM
Ken Stabler+ 75.3 1970-1984 3TM
120 Tim Couch 75.1 1999-2003 cle
Rank Player Rate Years Tm
Norm Van Brocklin+ 75.1 1949-1960 2TM
122 Sid Luckman+ 75.0 1939-1950 chi
Vinny Testaverde 75.0 1987-2007 7TM
124 David Carr 74.9 2002-2012 4TM
Chris Miller 74.9 1987-1999 3TM
126 Don Meredith 74.8 1960-1968 dal
Brian Sipe 74.8 1974-1983 cle
128 Jake Plummer 74.6 1997-2006 2TM
129 Roman Gabriel 74.3 1962-1977 2TM
Y.A. Tittle+ 74.3 1948-1964 3TM
131 Steve DeBerg 74.2 1978-1998 6TM
Gus Frerotte 74.2 1994-2008 7TM
133 Earl Morrall 74.1 1956-1976 6TM
134 Kerry Collins 73.8 1995-2011 6TM
135 Frankie Albert 73.5 1946-1952 sfo
Craig Morton 73.5 1965-1982 3TM
137 Rodney Peete 73.3 1989-2004 6TM
138 Mark Sanchez 73.2 2009-2018 4TM
139 Daryle Lamonica 72.9 1963-1974 2TM
Greg Landry 72.9 1968-1984 3TM
Rank Player Rate Years Tm
Don Majkowski 72.9 1987-1996 3TM
142 Ron Jaworski 72.8 1974-1989 4TM
Tommy Kramer 72.8 1977-1990 2TM
144 Tony Banks 72.4 1996-2005 4TM
145 Bubby Brister 72.3 1986-2000 5TM
John Brodie 72.3 1957-1973 sfo
Blaine Gabbert 72.3 2011-2020 5TM
148 Sammy Baugh+ 72.2 1937-1952 was
Milt Plum 72.2 1957-1969 4TM
Billy Wade 72.2 1954-1966 2TM
151 Jay Schroeder 71.7 1985-1994 4TM
152 Billy Kilmer 71.6 1961-1978 3TM
153 Bill Munson 71.5 1964-1979 5TM
154 Rex Grossman 71.4 2003-2012 3TM
155 Terry Bradshaw+ 70.9 1970-1983 pit
Lynn Dickey 70.9 1971-1985 2TM
157 Kordell Stewart 70.7 1995-2005 3TM
158 Derek Anderson 70.4 2006-2018 4TM
159 Trent Dilfer 70.2 1994-2007 5TM
Bill Nelsen 70.2 1963-1972 2TM
Rank Player Rate Years Tm
161 Vince Ferragamo 70.1 1977-1986 3TM
162 Steve Grogan 69.6 1975-1990 nwe
163 Kyle Boller 69.5 2003-2011 3TM
164 Joey Harrington 69.4 2002-2007 3TM
Doug Williams 69.4 1978-1989 2TM
166 Charley Johnson 69.2 1961-1975 3TM
167 Mike Tomczak 68.9 1985-1999 4TM
168 Eric Hipple 68.7 1980-1989 det
169 Joe Ferguson 68.4 1973-1990 4TM
170 Charlie Conerly 68.2 1948-1961 nyg
171 Dave Brown 67.9 1992-2001 2TM
172 Billy Joe Tolliver 67.7 1989-1999 5TM
Marc Wilson 67.7 1980-1990 2TM
174 Tom Flores+ 67.6 1960-1969 3TM
Richard Todd 67.6 1976-1985 2TM
176 Jim Plunkett 67.5 1971-1986 3TM
177 John Hadl 67.4 1962-1977 4TM
178 Jim Zorn 67.3 1976-1987 3TM
179 Archie Manning 67.1 1971-1984 3TM
180 Jim Hart 66.6 1966-1984 2TM
Rank Player Rate Years Tm
181 Joe Namath+ 65.5 1965-1977 2TM
Norm Snead 65.5 1961-1976 5TM
183 Rick Mirer 63.5 1993-2003 5TM
184 Bobby Layne+ 63.4 1948-1962 4TM
185 Mike Livingston 63.3 1968-1979 kan
Mike Pagel 63.3 1982-1993 3TM
Jack Trudeau 63.3 1986-1995 3TM
188 Ed Brown 62.8 1954-1965 3TM
189 Mark Malone 61.9 1980-1989 3TM
190 Bob Waterfield+ 61.6 1945-1952 ram
191 Eddie LeBaron 61.4 1952-1963 2TM
192 George Blanda+ 60.6 1949-1975 4TM
193 Babe Parilli 59.6 1952-1969 5TM
194 Dan Pastorini 59.1 1971-1983 4TM
195 Jack Kemp 57.3 1957-1969 3TM
196 Tobin Rote 56.8 1950-1966 4TM
197 Cotton Davidson 54.9 1954-1968 3TM
198 Mike Phipps 52.6 1970-1981 2TM
199 Frank Tripucka 52.2 1949-1963 4TM

 

[CowboyRoy]

While I personally bring this point up when Dak is criticized as not being any good and think it is telling, It's a different world nowadays. Mahomes career rating is 108.7. I remember Bob Griese used to be around the league leaders a lot of the time and his career rating is 77.1.

That being said, Dak is tied for 7th. Still pretty darn good. Where did you get your numbers? Brees in particular seems off

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/leaders/pass_rating_career.htm

https://www.profootballhof.com/all-time-passer-rating/

Didnt include some of the younger guys. Yep................7 is amazing.

 

[ShortRound]

I would say that list spans about 2-3 different eras in the NFL, hard to truly compare.

 

[stiletto]

Whatever year the 5 yard contact rule (Mel Blount) went into effect should be at least one cutoff...I think 78 and then harder enforcement 2014. Not 100% sure.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

I'm curious how many years Romo played behind a terrible O-line.

About 2 or 3…..

 

[jazzcat22]

1 Aaron Rodgers 104.93
2 Steve Young* 96.81
3 Tom Brady 96.62
4 Peyton Manning 95.71
5 Tony Romo 95.62
6 Philip Rivers 94.53
7 Drew Brees 94.27
8 Kurt Warner 93.71
9 Ben Roethlisberger 92.69
10 Joe Montana* 92.26

Nice to see Romo on there. At 97.3 QB rating Dak would be #2 all time if he continues his current pace.

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/leaders/pass_rating_career.htm

Not according to this. Dak and Tom Boy are tied at #7.
Dak can move up on that list though.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Dak is on pace to be a All time great…..

 

[acr731]

I'm curious how many years Romo played behind a terrible O-line.

Pretty much his entire career. Dak has had better and they still failed.

 

[acr731]

Dak is on pace to be a All time great…..

Only if he can play for another 30 years.

 

[America's Cowboy]

Pretty much his entire career. Dak has had better and they still failed.

100% not true. Come on, Acr...you're better than that.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/leaders/pass_rating_career.htm

Not according to this. Dak and Tom Boy are tied at #7.
Dak can move up on that list though.

Mahomes though

Over 4 points above #2 Watson lol

 

[CowboyRoy]

100% not true. Come on, Acr...you're better than that.

LOL.......No he isnt!!