speedkilz88;4173735 said:
Filomena's computer was still in the room along with other items. It would be rather obvious to both of them that it didn't appear that anything was missing. If I was going to fake a break-in I guarantee you something would be missing. It just doesn't make sense that they would fake a break-in and then say nothing was stolen. I don't believe there is any evidence of a faked break-in either since it's only conjecture by Mignini rather than actual proof.
Amanda said that Meredith sometimes locked the door. It's more strange that Filomena claimed that Meredith never locked the door. How would she know that? I hardly ever lock my bedroom door but it would be ridiculous for anyone to claim I never lock my door. Neither are lying they just have different experiences(or different expectations) when coming to visit Meredith in her bedroom. You really have to look at these things with common sense if they truly were involved what would be the purpose to delaying the police from opening the door? Meredith is already dead it wouldn't benefit them at all. It's more conjecture by the prosecution.
There is no evidence of a clean up so that lamp theory gets shot down right there. Meredith might have borrowed it before she was attacked or Rudy may have got it to search under the bed. It's quite the leap to use as proof that two people(and that Amanda and Rafael were those two people) used the lamps to clean up evidence they were there. By the way if they did do that they need to be hired by the CIA because they are really good, best in the world to clean up all their dna/prints and leave nothing but Rudy there. Also point out that the prosecutions fingerprint expert said that there was no sign of a cleanup.
Got proof that it was opened easily? What does that even mean? Seen Rafael, not exactly the door knocking in type. I know I'm not either. If it was so easy the cop that was worried initially about breaking the door down could have opened it since it was so easy. The cop was the one that didn't want to break the door open, he wanted to wait and make sure that Meredith wasn't simply somewhere else. This is just more conjecture from Mignini being parroted.
This is still conjecture. It doesn't even say what was said that's suppose to be incriminating. I'm sure that her mother had a lot of different conversations with Amanda over what was happening and could have easily confused them. Not that I even know that any of this is true. Certainly not something that would be used in court for convicting someone.
Ridiculous the call to the Carabinieri was confirmed to have been placed prior to the postal police arrival. Mignini and the postal cops had video of when the postal police arrived but the time stamp was off. They were either idiots or they purposely subtracted time rather than adding time that it was off by. So the prosecution gave the wrong time which the defense has proven already.
This so called evidence is just biased conjecture meant to assassinate their credibility. It doesn't prove guilt just proves how far the prosecution would go to mislead the public. They did even worse with a lot of misinformation given to the media early on in the case that ended up not being true at all. Then in the last trial when all their "evidence" blew up into smoke they topped it by name calling and showing Amanda's vibrator and the crime scene photos of a naked Meredith.
Re: the break-in
Good points, I've always thought the language barrier due to Amanda's limited understanding of Italian could have contributed to the police's misjudgements. For example:
How do we know they said
"there is absolutely nothing missing" or "it appears nothing is missing?
That's a big difference and could have easily been misunderstood
How do we counter the statement that Filomena left her room clean with no clothes thrown about, but broken window glass was found on top of clothes instead of under them (which would seem expected)?
Re: Locked Door
I agree and stated I don't see why both couldn't be correct from their own perspective. Since apparently Meredith didn't like Amanda and was bothered by her singing/guitar playing, then maybe she closed her door when just Amanda & her were at home, but left it open when everyone was home.
Re: the Clean-up
How do we explain the bare right footprint on the bathmat but none leading to or from the bathmat? Who's is it and how do we know?
Do you have a non-biased source for this:
Also point out that the prosecutions fingerprint expert said that there was no sign of a cleanup.
Thx for the reply
