No, what I'm basically saying is that your way of thinking is why everyone thinks what you say is "weird." You made the comment that when you say things, people think you weird. If you go against facts and 98% of opinion, ALL THE TIME, you put yourself in that category.
It's ok to go against the grain, and have your own way of thinking. But when it's completely opposite ALL the time from what most are saying, you have to admit, your arguing for the sake of arguing.
Now to your point this time. Do I think Romo and a healthy defense gets us into the playoffs? Hard to say. That's a lot of 'ifs"... Our defense is never healthy. Sean Lee, our supposed defensive leader, hasn't played in important games since high school. He's hurt every year during crunch time. So don't count on him to be healthy at the end of any year. Ware is past his prime and will be hurt every year from now on. Who knows if Spencer will play again on this team. Other than Hatcher, Carr and Orlando, there's nobody else who matters. Everyone of our defensive starters who were hurt, are no better than the backups.
Kyle Orton played as well as most would have played. Tony hasn't proved EVER, that he would take us any further in the playoffs. He's played with some good defenses. Oh, but then it was the lack of WR's, or OL, or RB's. So I guess I just answered the question. NO, I don't think we would have got into the playoffs with Tony or our healthy defense. Even if we did, we were gonna get smoked by whomever we played. Coaching and talent would have prevented us from doing anything. Just as it will this year most likely....We need 7-8 new starters on defense to be a real contender. With the money we have available, and the way we draft, we will go into next season upgrading only 2 perhaps 3 of those positions.