Are we already going the Garrett route with McCarthy?

[Mannix]

Remembering all the scapegoats that Garrett left in his wake while he survived for nine (9) painful years, are we already three (3) years in moving deck chairs around on the Titanic by firing personnel without totally cleaning house and including HC? I hope not. McCarthy brings nothing to the table in my opinion....he does NOT make a difference during any given game. He didn't even grab Junior by the arm and insist he run the ball in the last two (2) minutes at Jacksonville...he didn't insist we run on 2nd and 2 at SF. These are the things that a WALK AROUND HC has TIME TO DO during any given game. He lied to get the HC job....he admitted to not knowing all of the offensive terminology (no wonder he doesn't want to call plays)....I still maintain as others in the know have, that the guy is lazy. We can do way better...look at the teams we've beaten the last two (2) years to achieve 12-5 records....not all that impressive when you break it down.

 

[75boyz]

I'll stick to bottom line post season success which is why he was hired.
In his last 5 years as a HC he's won 1 playoff game.

 

[jazzcat22]

MM had an injured Dak with a broken foot his 1st year, then back to back 12-5 seasons, and got to the divisional round this season. You don't fire a coach for that.
He will be here his 5 years if they make the playoffs next season.

And if those that want MM gone, be careful, as you will get Jason 2.0 in Kellen as HC if DQ is not promoted or leaves.

 

[75boyz]

MM had an injured Dak with a broken foot his 1st year, then back to back 12-5 seasons, and got to the divisional round this season. You don't fire a coach for that.
He will be here his 5 years if they make the playoffs next season.

And if those that want MM gone, be careful, as you will get Jason 2.0 in Kellen as HC if DQ is not promoted or leaves.

The Garrett Redemption Story, aka Moore to HC has been the master plan all along...

 

[Cowboy_svt]

ill take two 12-5 years (with the starting qb going down in both seasons for a period of time), playoffs twice than 8-8 mediocrity
Remember the sack fiasco atlanta game in 2017? 2015 as a whole with that '14 roster? Icing his own kicker?
Comparing him to anything like that is some truly off base stuff

 

[Coogiguy03]

MM had an injured Dak with a broken foot his 1st year, then back to back 12-5 seasons, and got to the divisional round this season. You don't fire a coach for that.
He will be here his 5 years if they make the playoffs next season.

And if those that want MM gone, be careful, as you will get Jason 2.0 in Kellen as HC if DQ is not promoted or leaves.

Woooooooooow lol could so see this happening

 

[kskboys]

MM had an injured Dak with a broken foot his 1st year, then back to back 12-5 seasons, and got to the divisional round this season. You don't fire a coach for that.
He will be here his 5 years if they make the playoffs next season.

And if those that want MM gone, be careful, as you will get Jason 2.0 in Kellen as HC if DQ is not promoted or leaves.

MM has been a breath of fresh air. We finally have S's and a NT. And it shows. Now, it's time to upgrade elsewhere.

 

[Coogiguy03]

The Garrett Redemption Story, aka Moore to HC has been the master plan all along...

Right

 

[john van brocklin]

MM had an injured Dak with a broken foot his 1st year, then back to back 12-5 seasons, and got to the divisional round this season. You don't fire a coach for that.
He will be here his 5 years if they make the playoffs next season.

And if those that want MM gone, be careful, as you will get Jason 2.0 in Kellen as HC if DQ is not promoted or leaves.

Yes . No doubt in my mind that Jerry thanks Moore is the next boy wonder genius head coach.
We are going to get him and waste another 10 years of this franchise like we did with Garrett.
I cant wait until Jerry is no longer in charge of this franchise.
Give me Stephen Jones..
I cant believe I just typed that...

 

[Coogiguy03]

MM has been a breath of fresh air. We finally have S's and a NT. And it shows. Now, it's time to upgrade elsewhere.

That's all Quinn, you're right my friend I've never seen us have needs and they get addressed. Usually it's we need WR help and you see us sign a damn backup center

 

[Mannix]

MM had an injured Dak with a broken foot his 1st year, then back to back 12-5 seasons, and got to the divisional round this season. You don't fire a coach for that.
He will be here his 5 years if they make the playoffs next season.

And if those that want MM gone, be careful, as you will get Jason 2.0 in Kellen as HC if DQ is not promoted or leaves.

TRUST ME....I am NOT calling for Kellen. And the "be careful" warning is tired...ask Iowa fans who have been limited by Kirk Ferentz for the last 15 years. The teams that push all their chips in, are now winning Super Bowls....with one of them about to win another....MM will NOT be contending for any Super Bowls, unless he rides another HOF QB's coattails not named Dak to a Lombardi.

 

[kskboys]

That's all Quinn, you're right my friend I've never seen us have needs and they get addressed. Usually it's we need WR help and you see us sign a damn backup center

MM is middle of the pack, but he is a legit HC. And that was sorely needed. First legit HC we've had since Tuna.

 

[khiladi]

Those personnel moves were contracts ending. Jerry waited for Garrett's contract to finish, while basically retaining him as a lame-duck HC when all was said and done. This FO doesn't can people, unless it's absolutely necessary, as firing probably means a lot of money wasted.

 

[NoLuv4Jerry]

Remembering all the scapegoats that Garrett left in his wake while he survived for nine (9) painful years, are we already three (3) years in moving deck chairs around on the Titanic by firing personnel without totally cleaning house and including HC? I hope not. McCarthy brings nothing to the table in my opinion....he does NOT make a difference during any given game. He didn't even grab Junior by the arm and insist he run the ball in the last two (2) minutes at Jacksonville...he didn't insist we run on 2nd and 2 at SF. These are the things that a WALK AROUND HC has TIME TO DO during any given game. He lied to get the HC job....he admitted to not knowing all of the offensive terminology (no wonder he doesn't want to call plays)....I still maintain as others in the know have, that the guy is lazy. We can do way better...look at the teams we've beaten the last two (2) years to achieve 12-5 records....not all that impressive when you break it down.

That is all I have been saying when people go on and on about the interception before the half against SF. Either McCarthy is not allowed to interfere, or McCarthy agreed with the decision to throw the football on 2 and 2. If either are true...we're screwed!!!!!!!

 

[kskboys]

Those personnel moves were contracts ending. Jerry waited for Garrett's contract to finish, while basically retaining him as a lame-duck HC when all was said and done. This FO doesn't can people, unless it's absolutely necessary, as firing probably means a lot of money wasted.

Worse than that. He's too dumb to know who to fire and when.

 

[john van brocklin]

MM is middle of the pack, but he is a legit HC. And that was sorely needed. First legit HC we've had since Tuna.

Middle of the pack HC is about as good as you can expect in Dallas.
Jerry for some reason will not hire a top shelf HC.
Its just nuts....

 

[G2]

MM has been a breath of fresh air. We finally have S's and a NT. And it shows. Now, it's time to upgrade elsewhere.

Changed the culture imo.

 

[CTcowboy203]

Mm had a very good year this year I disagree with your premis

 

[Mannix]

Nobody has addressed yet exactly what he does game day to "make a difference" in winning a game....nor has anyone addressed yet, why a "walk around" coach with nothing to do but manage a game does not confer with and demand what approach Junior takes in critical situations of a game....I cited two (2) very critical situations above where he clearly dropped the ball. As Noluv4Jerry pointed out, maybe he did confer and came to the same brain dead conclusion that Junior did....if so, God help us!

 

[john van brocklin]

Changed the culture imo.

I would not go that far.
Until Jerry is no longer in charge promoting an Entertainment , entitled culture it is largely unchanged.