I've still not recovered from the playoff loss, it's really knocked the stuffing out of me in terms of my confidence this team can go all the way. While the loss does not solely sit on Dak's shoulders, it's his performance that has taken away my positivity as I just don't think he's good enough to carry this team consistently.
I don't think Dak is the best QB in the league, he's also far from being the worst. I also don't think he just average, he's better than that - he's a good QB, in my opinion borderline top 10.
There's a couple of issues for me;
Dak's contract needs him to be top 5. He's paid elite money and it's simply a result of the cap era that will weaken other areas of the team with less cash to spend. He can't carry this team and he doesn't elevate players around him. That's ok with a well rounded roster but his contract stops that happening. Not his fault, he didn't write the contract but it is what it is.
The 2nd reason and for me, the biggest reason is his patchy play over a season. Dak can look elite for a run of games, it happened this year but it doesn't last and he has a down game or 2, then maybe back to looking great. Those down games don't always happen against the best teams in the league so I'll not push that opinion but there is more evidence that not over 6 years that the better teams can bottle him up and he fails to rise to elite status. Now Dak can win against the best teams, we've seen it before but my problem........and I mean biggest issue I have is I simply cannot see him string together 3 top-tier performances in the playoffs against the best teams in the league.
I think we can win well with Dak, I think we can finish 12-5 again, Dak is not a bad QB but he's not elite and we can't overcome the cap hit he brings.